Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw en butch lesbienne die als tiener sociaal transitioneerde — met hen/die en een gekozen naam — maar nooit medisch transitioneerde, en na een paar jaar desisteerde. Ik heb autisme en OCD, een voorgeschiedenis van een eetstoornis, PMDD en PCOS, en werd als kind gepest omdat ik een jongensachtig meisje en lesbisch was in een traditionele cultuur. Ik bond 7-8 jaar in (wat mijn ribbenkast en houding beschadigde) en onderging een borstverkleining van H naar D-cup, waar ik blij mee ben. Ik leef nu comfortabel als mannelijke vrouw met een steunende partner en vrienden, al ervaar ik in progressieve ruimtes voortdurend druk om me als non-binair te identificeren. Ik ben kritisch op genderidentiteitsconcepten, tegen medische transitie van minderjarigen en voor het recht van volwassenen om te transitioneren als persoonlijke keuze voor lichaamsmodificatie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I've identified as trans or nonbinary at different points in my life, but I never medically transitioned. I don't consider myself to have a "gender identity" — I just exist as a woman and I don't want to be a man. I'm a desisted female, and I've been a masc/butch lesbian the whole time.
Growing up I was always a tomboy. I got bullied for being a lesbian and a tomboy, and I was raised with very rigid gender roles in a traditional culture — I get stared at all the time now and got bullied as a kid. I've felt uncomfortable with being a woman for a long time, largely because of external factors: being catcalled by older men, painful periods, not being taken seriously just because I'm a woman, plus the stereotypes and strict beauty standards we're expected to live up to. I socially transitioned as a teen and then went back — no medical interventions. I went by they/them pronouns for a while but nobody used them, so I just stopped asking, though a lot of people did use my chosen name (it was rare, not in English, and the constant mispronunciations got tiring, so I went back to my given name). I also went by my middle name, which is unisex, for a while. I stopped wearing a binder and changed my name back, but I kept the same clothes and short hair, and I rarely wear makeup. I've been socially transitioned for a few years before desisting.
I bound my chest for 7 or 8 years and it messed up my ribcage and my posture and gave me breathing problems. Now I only wear low-impact sports bras in the correct size. I also had a breast reduction a few years ago — from an H cup to a D or DD — because my boobs were causing severe back pain, and I used to cry in fitting rooms because I was insecure about them being too big; I also struggled to exercise. The recovery was really difficult. I wish I could've gone smaller, but I didn't want nipple grafts. I'm happy with the reduction. I would only get a mastectomy for breast cancer prevention, since it runs in my family. It's relieving to be able to wear clothes that are made for someone with breasts and not have to bind.
I have a lot of issues with my reproductive system, including PMDD and PCOS, and facial hair from PCOS (I didn't take T). My periods before birth control were awful; hormonal birth control is the only thing that's helped. I've had bad experiences with the first two gynecologists I went to — the third one actually helped. Yasmin made me feel like I had PMDD every day; Nexplanon has worked pretty well for my PMDD but has other side effects. I feel better about being female when I'm on birth control. I also feel grossed out by my ability to have children, and I plan to stay on birth control for the next 25 years or so. I don't want children. I also have pelvic pain. I have autism, so I found a therapist who works with autistic adults — she's cool with gay people and doesn't get into discourse. I don't use the words "trans," "dysphoria," or "gender identity" with her; I talk about discomfort with my body and with being female, and my trauma. She's never brought up transition. I've been diagnosed with OCD. I'm in recovery from an eating disorder, partly because of fear of getting curves like girls with anorexia. In one of my therapy groups we weren't allowed to talk about the specifics of self harm or suicidal thoughts because of social contagion.
I've been unsure whether I want to go on T and a bunch of people will say I should just try it out for a couple weeks. I don't think getting on T would help if you don't treat the underlying OCD. One person in my life keeps trying to tell me I'm actually nonbinary and that I would look better if I took testosterone; people in "progressive" spaces constantly ask my pronouns and gender identity, while my feminine friends are never asked. In conservative spaces everyone correctly assumes I'm a butch lesbian, though they push traditional femininity onto me. I moved back to my hometown and no one asks about pronouns here — it's such a relief. I still face homophobia in my conservative town, but it feels easier because it's not coming from people who are supposed to be my allies. I've lost a few friends because they don't believe me, but most people in my life have been okay with my choice. I have a supportive partner who's attracted to women like me, and a good group of female friends who were also "weird kids" and fully accept me. I don't know any butches irl.
My favorite part of socially detransitioning is that I don't have to think much about my appearance. I'm still more masc, but I don't have to bind my chest or wear baggy clothes 24/7, and I don't have to worry about passing. I still feel uncomfortable with she/her sometimes but I'm trying to accept being a woman — it's much easier this way and I don't want to worry about how I'm perceived. What works for most people with body image issues and anxiety also works for my dysphoria: eating well, focusing on taking care of my body instead of how it looks, wearing comfortable clothes, accepting myself. Almost all of my discomfort with being female comes from external factors that could change, so it doesn't make sense for me to change myself. I wouldn't have a problem with being female if I lived in an egalitarian society where women were safer from sexual violence, and if I didn't have PCOS and pelvic pain.
I'm tired of labels being pushed on me in queer spaces. I feel uncomfortable when someone tries to tell me I'm actually nonbinary or assumes I use they/them because I'm detached from gender stereotypes. I find the concept of nonbinary and "egg" culture sexist — it's often about stereotypes and a hypersexualized view of women. How is it progressive to say that a female person with a pixie cut, leg hair, and no makeup is not a real woman? I don't consider myself cis or trans. I dislike the term "cis" because it assumes we're okay with sexist stereotypes. I'm against the concept of gender identity replacing sex. I'm a lesbian and I think the pressure for us to include males is destructive. I support anti-discrimination laws, protection from violence, and people dressing how they want and changing their names; I feel mixed about adults medically transitioning (viewing it as similar to body modifications — shouldn't be banned but risky); and I oppose minors medically transitioning, compelled pronoun use, males in female sports/prisons/locker rooms, and redefining sexual orientation around gender identity. I think teaching children about gender transition surgery is wrong, though I don't have a problem with a teacher mentioning her wife and baby. I'm not religious and I don't like either political party, but my views mostly align with the left. I've read stories about female detransitioners who regretted transition because they missed their connection with other women. I've watched detransition videos made by straight women and noticed patterns of sexual trauma, distress at puberty changes, and gender nonconformity. I've recommended Cori Cohn's content to others. I'm a masculine woman who doesn't fit mainstream beauty standards — it feels like womanhood on extra difficulty.