Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als nurse practitioner werkt en HRT voorschrijft, en die gelooft dat transseksualiteit een stoornis is die als zodanig behandeld moet worden. Ik groeide op in de jaren 90 en denk dat ik mezelf transseksueel zou hebben gevonden als het huidige culturele klimaat toen had bestaan, al gaf de regel van mijn ouders dat 'als het niet permanent is en je geen pijn doet, het niet uitmaakt' me ruimte om mijn identiteit veilig te verkennen. Ik vond deze gemeenschap via verwijzingen ernaar op r/MtF en heb andere leden steun geboden terwijl ik pleit voor strengere regulering van transitiegeneeskunde, vooral voor kinderen. Ik vrees dat de huidige 'transmanie' zich zal wreken en echte transseksuelen zal schaden, evenals kinderen die 'verminkt en gesteriliseerd' worden maar niet echt transseksueel zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up in the 1990s, and I remember that back then this 'trans hogwash' wasn't a fanatical thing yet — though I honestly think that if it had been, I'd have thought I was a transsexual. When I was a teenager working out my angst and messing with my identity and presentation, a rule my parents set really helped me: 'if it's not permanent and it doesn't hurt you, it doesn't matter.' That translated into being allowed to shave my head but not get tattoos or piercings, being allowed to wear Marilyn Manson makeup and dog collars to school but not do drugs, and being allowed to listen to Devil music and play video games but not go to a rave. That bit of freedom gave me a lot of room, and at least for me and my siblings it was enough — now we're all disgustingly normal.
I also recall that when I was her age and wanted to be like the boys, it was mostly because I sucked at being a girl and boys rejected me. My suspicion is that this is the case with lots of trans kids: if you'll never be a beautiful perfect woman, maybe you'll be a decent dude; if the boys won't take you to prom, maybe they'll invite you to the football game.
I went to university in an era when the older-school approach to transsexualism as a psychopathology was doctrine, and even then we were still at a loss as to the cause of such suffering and how best to tweak treatment in order to avoid applying treatments to the wrong patients. I still think those older-school approaches are best.
Professionally, I am a nurse practitioner with my own practice, and I prescribe HRT. I do statistical science for a living as well. In my view, transsexualism is an illness and should be treated as such; Kenneth Zucker's work at CAMH in Toronto always seemed remarkably well thought out and fair to me, with the path to actual SRS being long and arduous and hormones nowhere near the first method of treatment — procedures to imitate the opposite sex taken one at a time only when the law of beneficence in medicine deemed it the last resort. I believe the only damage dropping homosexuality from the DSM ever did was opening the door for having transsexualism dropped from it too, and I fully expect the 6th edition to drop 'gender dysphoria' entirely if things continue the way they're going. I've said that transsexuals aren't 'replacing' anything with HRT — they're taking something foreign that doesn't belong in their bodies, and we just call it HRT for them because of political pressure and fear of losing our jobs. I've also said hormone protocols for transsexuals wouldn't be necessary if they didn't do things like remove their gonads.
I'm a conservative, and I would imagine that scrutiny of the trans condition could only help in alleviating it — it's obviously a real thing happening to people and causing them great suffering. I worry that all the pro-transmania, Jessica Yaniv type boogeymen, and aggressive pride flag attacks will backfire hugely in 10 years and transsexuals will no longer be afforded any favour in the public — or treatment. I've asked what will happen when all the mutilated and sterilized kids who are not transsexual start voicing this when they're older. I've advocated that we should 'regulate it to hell' and hoped that transition procedures aren't covered by tax-based insurance.
I found this community after seeing references in r/MtF about it being hateful and to be avoided — '....that's how I found it!' I've offered support to others here, telling one person that super small defectors from a population are usually interesting anomalies or misclassified, but that 'They're always real though. There's no getting around that. You're real as is whatever you've gone through. Hang in there.' I've also given advice to a parent of a daughter questioning her gender, suggesting activities and projects to get her focused on something besides gender and giving her positive places to be female and see that she can succeed at being female.
I don't describe undergoing any medical transition myself in these posts, and I don't describe a detransition process, surgeries, hormone use as a patient, or a specific current gender identity beyond how I've described my own teenage years and my conservative, clinical views.