Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd, maar hier om ertegenin te gaan

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd166
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gendercritisch persoon die zich nooit als trans heeft geïdentificeerd of is getransitioneerd, en ik neem deel aan deze gemeenschap als ideologische bondgenoot en niet als iemand met een eigen ervaring van detransitie. Ik geloof niet dat trans-zijn een aangeboren aandoening is en betoog dat genderdysforie het best wordt aangepakt met een gendercritische therapeut in plaats van door te transitioneren. Ik ben fel gekant tegen cross-sekse hormonen, puberteitsremmers en geslachtsaanpassende chirurgie, vooral voor jongeren, en ik ben in deze fora uitgesproken geweest – soms strijdlustig. Ik heb in dit materiaal geen persoonlijke problemen met mentale gezondheid, suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven. Ik blijf vastberaden kritisch over transitie voor anderen, terwijl ik zorgen uit over mensen die ik ken die zijn getransitioneerd.

Volledig verhaal

I have never identified as trans and have never transitioned; I write from the perspective of someone who is gender critical and who has spent time in this community engaging with people who are detransitioning, considering detransition, or considering transition in the first place. My participation here is ideological and political rather than autobiographical in the usual sense of this forum. I came to these discussions with firm convictions: I do not believe that being trans is an inherent or innate condition. As I put it, "No one is 'really' trans though. It isn't an inherent condition, it is something you decide to do," and I added that everyone who is trans thinks they are really trans until they aren't, which means there is no way to know in advance who will and won't detransition. I reject the idea of gendered brains entirely, arguing that there is "literally zero evidence that a male can be born with a female brain or vice versa" and that there is no "gender center" in the brain. I define sex in strictly chromosomal terms — "XX = Female, XY = Male" — while acknowledging that intersex conditions exist but insisting they are rare and irrelevant to the broader point about sexual dimorphism. I have been outspoken in opposing transition, particularly for young people. I told one parent considering their child's transition that their daughter was "taking or heading toward taking dangerous exogenous hormones that will ruin her health" and urged them to "stop humoring your child and explain to them that they are female." I have warned about puberty blockers specifically, claiming that "'Puberty blockers' means Lupron" and describing it as a cancer drug with severe side effects. I have described cross-sex hormones as dangerous, particularly exogenous testosterone to female bodies, and I have characterized sex reassignment surgery in stark terms, telling one person who had genital surgery that they had "literally mutilated your genitals." I have also been critical of what I see as the health consequences of transition, linking to articles about heart attack risk in transgender people and about complications from testosterone. I have argued that transition is "ineffective at changing your sex, making you pass, or giving you a real vagina." On the question of who belongs in this community, I noted that some participants are people who never transitioned but have friends, family, or community members who did, and I counted myself among those who are upset about what is happening to people they know, as well as to communities and movements "under attack by illiberal, authoritarian, anti-science trans rights activists." I have been openly critical of Blaire White, describing her as "an internet huckster" who cultivates a career as "a reasonable trans person" for reactionary audiences, and I have speculated that ContraPoints might desist in the future. I have also pushed back against what I see as the medical and scientific consensus on gender, dismissing studies on transgender brain structure as "bullshit cherrypicked studies heavily misinterpreted and misrepresented" and criticizing p-value gaming and publication bias in sex and gender research. I have been blunt and at times combative in these exchanges, and I am aware that my tone has been criticized. I have defended this by saying that I am speaking anonymously because it is "the only place I can speak OBVIOUS truth without the world trying to fuck my life up." I have also expressed the view that people who are gender nonconforming should be encouraged to work through their feelings with a therapist — preferably a gender critical one — rather than transition, and that being gender nonconforming does not make someone anything other than a gender-nonconforming person of their own sex. I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, or detransition in this transcript, and I have not discussed my own mental health, family, relationships, or sexuality. My involvement appears to be that of an ideological ally rather than someone with lived experience of transition.