Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een biologische man die nooit is getransitioneerd; ik zeg dat mijn lichaam me zei dat niet te doen, en ik laat me leiden door mijn eigen respect voor mijn lichaam. Ik ben actief in detransitie-ruimtes als criticus van transitiegeneeskunde en waarschuw anderen voor onomkeerbare veranderingen, hormonen en operaties die ik "de oplichterij van de eeuw" noem, terwijl ik toegeef dat sommige operatieresultaten echt indrukwekkend zijn. Persoonlijk ben ik een hetero man van 36 die jaren nodig had om te accepteren dat ik langzame, intieme opbouw met partners nodig heb en slechts twee vrouwen heb gevonden bij wie ik dat niveau bereikte. Ik ben botweg en regelbrekend geweest in deze fora, en zeg dat het waarschuwen van mensen ieders taak is en dat hard taalgebruik gerechtvaardigd is om lichamen te beschermen. Ik meld geen geschiedenis van suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I am a biological male — I've said so plainly when people asked me about my own position in these debates. I never transitioned myself; in fact I've said that I never did it in the first place "because my body told me not to. Sounds silly but my body knows what's best for itself. Always did." My involvement in the detransition community has been as an outsider offering warnings, opinions, and blunt advice rather than as someone recounting my own medical journey.
Physically I describe myself as tall, shaved-headed, muscular, white, and typically dressed in blue jeans and a white T-shirt — an appearance people have told me is intimidating, that I've made guys and girls afraid to be judged by me. That baffles me, I've said, because I never judge anyone and I'm "almost pathologically" unsure about things. Sexually I identify as a man attracted to women, and I've been open about being into "girlish boys" and spending hours on "caged sissy" videos — a private taste I keep separate from what I think people should do with their bodies. I've also said I'm into femdom as an illustration of the point that a fantasy doesn't have to become an identity.
I'm 36 as of August 2022 (I contrasted being 18 with being 36 when talking about sexual confidence). At 18, I said, my greatest failure was not understanding my own sexual tempo; I couldn't get hard the first time with a woman and felt pressure to be a "quick lay" kind of guy. It took about a month of intimacy for me to get comfortable, and in my whole life I've found only two women I reached that level with. Learning and accepting that about myself is what "saved me," I wrote. I'm not a Tinder person, I need complicity, trust, intimacy, spirituality, and genuine liking of the person's body and mind before opening up, and I recommend massage as a pro tip for slow starters.
I hold strongly critical views about transition medicine. I've called transition "the scam of the century" and described people who go through with it in degrading terms when quoting someone else's self-description back to them. I've warned that "you pay for what you do to your body at 18 when you reach 40" — that the body is "a library of your every mistake," "a bank account and you can only withdraw from it" — and that hormones are "super powerful agents of change" we don't fully understand. When someone said they might retransition, I pushed back hard: "are you really going to retransition again? Are you not at all worried what it does to your body? In my darkest hour, my guide was my respect for my own body. I couldn't hurt it and that kept me from the biggest mistakes." I've argued you can change your gender expression through clothing, language, posture, friends, activities, and job "without doing any damage to your body," and summed up my position as "Embrace your bliss, just don't cut up your body for it." I've conceded that some surgical results are impressive and a testament to medical progress, but argued those outcomes are luck and genetics used to promote surgeries that won't give the same result to most people who try.
I've been combative about this. I said I warned people about harms only to be told "to shut up and fuck off," and that when the predicted harms arrived it "breaks me up, that I could see it coming but I couldn't do a fucking thing to stop it." I've said I simply do not care about subreddit rules, that I'm banned from a number of them, and that I'll "never be influenced by tinpot dictators." I believe warning people is everyone's job: "if you see something say something." I justified harsh language as protective, "like pain is warranted to get you to avoid damage to your body." I've also shared the link to coverage of the UK shutting down its biggest gender clinic for kids.
On other people's detransitions I try to be kind: I told one person they "fell for the scam of the century," that I think they're a victim, and that I wouldn't judge them for past mistakes. I've counseled others not to change genders over ordinary emotions like jealousy — "Jealousy is normal as fuck" — offering the solutions of working at it or forgetting about it. Politically I lean toward wealth inequality as the real issue and am critical of where I think the left went after achieving what it should have on welfare, equality, and racism. I have no reported history of self-harm, suicidal ideation, or suicide attempts.