Alle verhalen

Gender was een speciale interesse, en toen niet meer

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd393
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar jarenlang seksualiteit, traumareacties en vrouwenhaat verwarde met genderidentiteit. Ik ben autistisch en gender werd een tijdelijke speciale interesse die me ertoe bracht me buiten het vrouw zijn te identificeren. Terugkomen bij mezelf betekende het idee afwijzen dat ontsnappen aan vrouwenhaat rechtvaardigt om non-binair te worden, en mijn vrouw zijn op mijn eigen voorwaarden terugnemen. Nu vermijd ik het onderwerp in het dagelijks leven, trek ik non-binair zijn nog steeds in twijfel en raad ik anderen af en toe aan hun eigen lichaam niet te overhaasten. Mijn geestelijke gezondheid is stabiel en ik heb geen medische spijt, omdat ik nooit hormonen heb genomen of operaties heb gehad.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I am autistic. My detransition/desistance story is not a dramatic medical one — I never took hormones or had surgery — but it is a long, tangled process of figuring out how much of what I felt was really about gender versus about misogyny, sexuality, and my own autistic obsessions. I first got pulled into questioning gender through fiction. I wrote stories dealing with my own trauma, but I changed the character's gender to make it more comfortable to write about. When people got offended by that, I received death threats and gore images, which I did not deserve — it was fiction. Around the same time I noticed I had a pattern in how I consumed romance media: I used to read shoujo manga until it repulsed me how many abusive guys ended up with the female main character. Then I switched to BL (boys' love) and yaoi, and it never struck me as problematic in the same way because I could disconnect from the male characters. I unconsciously read that detachment as meaning I preferred that kind of relationship. I still enjoy BL, but now I read them knowing that almost all of them are made by women for a reason — and that a lot of what I was doing was escaping toxic hetero stories rather than expressing gender identity. I also confused attraction with identification. I was attracted to women but did not actually want to be one — or rather, I realized I was attracted to them rather than wanting to "be" them, and it's weird that I confused something like sexuality with gender identity, though it seems pretty common nowadays. I think a lot of girls and female-to-male people get enthralled with yaoi because there is some disconnection from your sex that lets you enjoy these erotic stories. I have also noticed that straight, lesbian, or bi girls can enjoy male-male romance precisely because it lets them disconnect from toxic heterosexual stories. A major driver for me was misogyny rather than dysphoria. I have more of an issue with how women are treated by society than with dysphoria itself. I avoid reading or watching heterosexual romances because most of them have the male lead treating the female lead horribly, and my mind associates "being born female = being degraded by men," leading to the conclusion "if I was a man I would never experience this," which is factually wrong. I have questioned whether trying to escape being a woman because of misogyny is enough reason to become nonbinary — in my experience it doesn't work, because the people who would hurt you don't care about the gender business and see through who you are. I have a friend in my women's group who developed "dysphoria" and wanted to try being nonbinary, but her reasoning boiled down to not liking how men treat her because they see her as a woman; being nonbinary isn't going to stop men from seeing her as her assigned sex. I also heard of people trying transgenderism or nonbinarism to achieve a kind of "sexless being," which I think is impossible and does more harm than good to deny your body's functions. Being autistic turned out to be central. One reason I became temporarily obsessed with gender was that it became one of my special interests without even knowing what that meant. That obsession, plus the online environment — I have seen tons of trans people on Twitter using an anime profile picture of their favorite character of their preferred gender with the trans flag as background — made the whole framework feel very present in my life. I also think people confuse actual dysphoria with aesthetics: I saw a mangaka who said a male character who wears cute clothes "would be me if I was a girl," and commenters immediately called the character an "egg." I think gender ideology has become the new astrology or MBTI, except with very harmful real-life consequences. Coming back to myself has been about reclaiming womanhood on my own terms. Since I'm a woman, whatever I like, feel, or wear contributes to this idea of womanhood — to me it doesn't have any rules, since I'm the one making them. I wish the term "crossdresser" didn't exist, since it's just clothes. I believe changing how we unconsciously raise boys and girls — socialization — is the first step to really changing society, and that should be taught to boys from the start. I still question nonbinarism to this day. I try to avoid talking about the subject in general; once when I said "female reproductive organ," someone told me I shouldn't "label it as feminine," which left me lost for words. On the question of how people identify, I have been confused by terms like genderfluid — I asked someone what they consider "male" gender and "female" gender in order to call themselves genderfluid, and I remain confused by the term, though if it works for them, more power to them. I also noted that I absolutely miss the earlier version of a well-known trans creator (before her detransition-adjacent reveal), and the worst part was that in the reveal video she talked about a male fan who watched her as an alternative to being a man, but now it looks like you either have to be one or the other and that you can't just live your life as gender-nonconforming. I have tried to give advice to others in the community: I told one person not to rush themselves, that learning to love and understand your own body takes time, that mistakes are normal at their age, and that their loved ones wouldn't look down on them if they wanted to return to how they used to be. I also suggested to another person that they find a better group of friends who don't diminish women just for being women, and get a therapist to guide them through the thought process, since it sounded like they had more issues with how women are treated by society than dysphoria. Currently I identify as a woman who desisted from a trans/nonbinary identification. I have no medical regrets since I never medically transitioned, but I do regret the time and mental energy spent confusing sexuality and trauma responses with gender identity. My mental health is stable now; the autistic special interest in gender has faded, and I have largely stepped back from engaging with the topic, preferring to avoid it in daily life.