Alle verhalen

Een geestelijke-gezondheidswerker die nooit transitioneerde — en er toch tegen strijdt

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd575
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw die aan gedetransitioneerd grenst — ik ben nooit getransitioneerd, maar ik ben een genderdoorbrekende vrouw met complex trauma door emotioneel mishandelende ouders, werk in een instelling voor geestelijke gezondheidszorg en ben sterk kritisch over medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen. Ik geloof niet in transgenderisme, zie gender als synoniem voor biologisch geslacht en transitie als een vorm van zelfbeschadiging of ontsnapping aan trauma, en ik vergelijk transgeneeskunde met lobotomie. Ik heb veel tijd besteed aan het online onderzoeken van hormonen, operaties en puberteitsremmers en het ertegen argumenteren op detrans- en transfora. Ik heb complex trauma en bijbehorende mentale problemen uit mijn opvoeding, waar ik van probeer te herstellen terwijl ik zelfstandig woon. Ik steun therapie boven medische ingrepen en heb detransitiebronnen aan anderen aanbevolen.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and have always identified as a woman — I've never transitioned myself, but I've spent a lot of time thinking and arguing about it, and I've been active in detrans spaces for a while now. I'd describe myself as a gender non-conforming woman. I also mentioned at one point that I used to cosplay as a male character and was perceived as male while doing so, but I always knew consciously that I was female. Growing up, I had parents who didn't work through their own past trauma and became emotionally abusive as adults. I've said that as a result I suffer with mental health problems because of their abusive parenting. I live independently now and I'm trying to recover from what I describe as complex trauma. I don't go into more detail about diagnoses, but the trauma and its mental health effects are something I've referenced more than once. A lot of my energy has gone into arguing with people online — mostly with males who identify as trans women. I've spent months researching hormones and surgeries, and countless hours researching what a woman or man 'really means' anatomically and biologically. I've linked studies on testosterone, estrogen, puberty blockers, Lupron, chemical castration, John Money's David Reimer case, and forensic sex determination. I've told people directly: 'I spent months researching into these hormones and surgeries but it doesn't do anything lol.' My core position is that gender and sex are the same thing — biological — while gender roles are socially constructed stereotypes. I don't believe in transgenderism. I've compared trans medicine to lobotomy repeatedly: 'Lobotomies the gay away. Trans the gay away.' I think most trans people are actually gay and that transition is a way of escaping same-sex attraction or trauma. I've written: 'You are just escaping your trauma by becoming someone else. You need to talk to a therapist to unravel your trauma and heal from it.' I'm very critical of medical transition, especially for minors. I've argued that hormones cause infertility, cancer, sexual dysfunction, osteoporosis, blood clots, diabetes, and shortened lifespan, and that puberty blockers cause irreversible damage like brittle bones. I've said things like: 'Transgenderism is believing you are above God, and what your body was designed to be by taking abnormal amounts of hormones and surgeries.' I've also said I'm an atheist but that I encourage people to adopt a religion like Christianity if it helps them deal with suffering in healthy ways. I've worked in a mental health facility. I've written: 'I worked in a mental health facility and met many delusional patients who thought they were the opposite sex, a helicopter, a dictator, and other titles that did not reflect their real self.' That experience clearly shapes how I view gender dysphoria — as a delusion or mental illness, which I've noted is in the DSM-5. I'm not opposed to adults making their own choices — I've said repeatedly 'I don't care if consenting adults make that choice' — but I draw a hard line at minors: 'kids can't consent.' I've recommended detransitioners like Shape Shifter and Tulip R to people, and I've encouraged therapy over medical intervention. I've told people to seek therapists who aren't gender therapists. On feminism, I take a fairly traditional view of gender roles. I've said 'Gender roles will always exist' and that 'It's important for men to be masculine and women to be feminine,' arguing these roles are hardwired into biology for offspring survival. I've also argued that both sexes have privileges and struggles — men get drafted into war and take dangerous jobs, women face sexual violence — and that there's a balance rather than one being superior. I've dealt with some homophobia-adjacent views too — I've argued that many trans people are gay and that 'trans the gay away' is the modern equivalent of 'Lobotomies the gay away,' which puts me in an odd position of criticizing transition partly on gay-rights grounds. As for regret — I don't have personal regret about transition since I never transitioned. But I've expressed deep sympathy for people who regret it. When someone posted about surgeries not making them happy, I responded: 'I'm sorry to hear that the surgeries didn't make you happy…but also relieved that you can now recover from your experiences.' I've also told people who are detransitioning to stop caring about what others think and to focus on being 'the best and healthy version of yourself (without hormones of course). Exercising, dieting, meditating etc.' I've also dealt with some anger and grief about what I see happening to young people: 'I'm horrified how young people made such serious decision. When I was a teen, I couldn't decide which college I wanted to attend, let alone decide my gender.' I've suggested that some people could pursue legal charges for child abuse over what was done to them as minors. I don't currently identify as trans, desisted, or re-transitioned — I never identified as trans in the first place. I'm a detransition-adjacent ally: a gender non-conforming woman with complex trauma from an abusive upbringing, working in mental health, who is strongly critical of medical transition and particularly of transitioning minors. My advocacy has been mostly online — arguing in forums, sharing research, and recommending detransition resources.