Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd/gedesisteerd persoon die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar mijn hele leven ongewenste genderdissonantie heeft ervaren; ik werd me in de jaren 60 voor het eerst van het transseksuele fenomeen bewust en bestudeer het intensief sinds ongeveer 1972. Ik gebruikte ruim 20 jaar psychofarmaca, die me verdoofden, en ik stopte ermee in 2012, waarna ik me weer levend voelde en zwoer ze nooit meer te nemen. Ik geloof dat genderdissonantie fysieke, endocrien gerelateerde oorzaken heeft en ben kritisch over alleen-bevestigende therapie, terwijl ik geloof dat iedereen zijn eigen manier moet vinden om ermee om te gaan en dat het ongemak in de loop van een leven komt en gaat. Ik heb een dochter en benadruk vergeving, zelfacceptatie en zelfkennis. Ik heb geen transitiegerelateerde operaties of hormonen van mezelf beschreven, en er worden geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging na detransitie beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have experienced gender dissonance — what I also call gender incongruence — my entire life. I did not ask for it, I did not choose it, and it has always been unwanted, yet I cannot escape it. I first became aware of the transsexual phenomenon in the 1960s, and it resonated with me; I have been studying this subject intensely since about 1972, and I have researched the transsexual phenomenon since the late 1960s. I have never transitioned, and my stated challenge has been learning to live a healthy, productive, fulfilling life while continuing to experience gender dissonance.
I was on psychotropic drugs for over 20 years. They alleviated some of my gender distress, but in my view all they really did was make me numb to living and experiencing life. When I stopped taking them in 2012, I was amazed at how I felt alive again and was able to experience my emotions again. I said I will never take those types of drugs again.
I hold a strongly physiological view of gender dissonance. I have pointed to evidence going back to the 1950s suggesting gender dissonance can result from exogenous endocrine disruptors — hormones or chemicals that mimic hormones — acting on the developing fetus in the womb, citing diethylstilbestrol (DES), prescribed to pregnant women from the late 1930s to the late 1980s, and the modern 'soup' of endocrine disrupting chemicals in food, skin care products, water, air, pharmaceuticals and fabrics. I have argued that exogenous hormones or hormone-like chemicals permanently alter brain structure during fetal development, and that EDC exposure in early childhood contributes. I have compared autism rates (1 in 3000 in the 1970s versus about 1 in 40 today) to EDC prevalence, and I have linked my own situation to my mother's likely having been given medroxyprogesterone (a synthetic progestin, not progesterone) in pregnancy, while acknowledging this shows correlation, not cause and effect. I maintain a website collecting this research. I reject the framing of gender dissonance as mental illness as merely one perspective, and I reject the claim that masculine/feminine is a social construct as ideology rather than reality.
I am critical of affirmation-only therapy. I posted asking whether we need more therapists able to help people with gender dissonance cope and gain skills to remain living in their birth sex, arguing that the overwhelming majority of therapists engage in affirmation therapy and do not challenge clients to think through the lifetime consequences of transitioning. I noted that for some, the only alternatives they see are lifelong psychotropic medication or ending their life, and I asked where the professionals are who can help people cope. I have recommended SEGM and rethinkime.org as resources for finding non-affirming therapists, and I have shared a podcast in which an FtM detransitioner compared doctors saying 'let's try T and see if it helps' to saying 'let's try cocaine and see if it helps' — quick, powerful, addictive and permanent.
At the same time, I take a non-dogmatic view of individual choices: for some people changes to appearance may bring relief, for others cross-sex hormone therapy, and for some surgery may be their only source of relief. There are no simple answers. Even fully understanding physical causes does nothing for the person experiencing dysphoria; the challenge is how to live a fulfilling life while experiencing it, and each person must find their own way to cope. I believe the discomfort lasts a lifetime, though its strength ebbs and flows, and that nothing external will alleviate it. I emphasize self-acceptance and self-understanding as critical to human flourishing, quoting Socrates: 'Know thyself, for once we know ourselves, we may learn how to care for ourselves, otherwise we never shall.'
On a personal level I have worked on forgiving people I felt had hurt me, even maliciously, especially when they never sought forgiveness; I learned that holding resentment and anger hurt me and meant little to the other person, and I had to let go for my own mental health and healing. I have a daughter (she was given progesterone with her second child to mitigate the possibility of premature birth). I encourage others to keep working at getting to know themselves.
I have not described any surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers of my own, nor a formal detransition, since I never transitioned. I have not described a specific diagnosed mental health condition beyond gender distress treated with psychotropics for over two decades.