Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (of detransitionerende) man die ongeveer tien jaar vóór 2019 van man naar vrouw transitioneerde en eind 2019 vrede had met man zijn; ik spaarde voor een mastectomie terwijl ik in therapie was, met de bedoeling te detransitioneren. Mijn dysforie begon rond mijn 8e en was verweven met ernstig pesten in mijn jeugd omdat ik niet aan genderverwachtingen voldeed, en met seksueel misbruik in mijn jeugd, wat volgens mij de eerste aanleiding was. Door traumagerichte therapie, meditatie en dysforie te zien als negatieve gedachtelussen in plaats van een aangeboren aandoening, loste ik mijn lichamelijke dysforie op en begon ik me af te vragen of getransitioneerd blijven een eerlijk leven was. Ik blijf kritisch over het informed-consentmodel/de gender-affirmerende zorg en pleit voor therapie en andere behandelingen vóór transitie, zonder tegen transitie van volledig geïnformeerde volwassenen te zijn. Eind 2019 ging ik nog door voor vrouw terwijl ik spaarde voor een operatie, en had ik besloten niet te daten voordat ik mijn beslissing had genomen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and first started thinking I should have been a girl around age 8, with dysphoric thoughts beginning then. I grew up gender non-conforming and was relentlessly bullied for it — called slurs every day, spat on, had trash cans dumped on me, was chased, groped, and pantsed by boys trying to determine my sex, and threatened with violence regularly. I also experienced childhood sexual abuse (CSA), which I later came to believe was the initial trigger for my dysphoric feelings, intertwined with being very gender non-conforming and the thought that I would be safe if only my genitals were gone. A doctor once dismissed my mention of sexual abuse as unrelated to my desire for surgery.
I first started questioning if I was trans and planning transition around the turn of the millennium (roughly 1999-2000), and I found my way onto early trans boards online in early 1999 by searching phrases like 'I want to be a girl.' Before transitioning I had been wearing mostly women's clothing for a couple of years and was regularly assumed to be a woman. Knowing I could pass was the deciding factor in transitioning; I came out as trans everywhere a few months before walking into the clinic, which counted as a voluntary real-life experience and let me skip the wait. Transition felt right and easy — overnight I went from unacceptable to acceptable in society.
I transitioned roughly a decade before these 2019 posts, so around 2009. I medically transitioned with estrogen (HRT) and had breast augmentation surgery. My emotions felt more stable about a month after starting HRT, and I appreciated looking younger and more feminine compared to being on testosterone. I passed and lived stealth much of the time, having sex with a number of men over the years. For most of that decade I was happy being trans, dating and hooking up while choosing when to be stealth and when to be open.
Over the past year leading up to 2019, and especially the last month, it had been building up to feel like more and more of a charade to hide that I am gay and feminine. Transition had lost its sense of living true to myself. The core issue became dating: I felt I could no longer respect men who wouldn't acknowledge that being with me was two men having sex, without shame or need to hide. I wanted partners to fully perceive me as a gay man with no mental loophole to see me otherwise. Everywhere other than dating I was comfortable with however people perceived me.
Around 2018-2019 I underwent a major shift in understanding my dysphoria. Through trauma-focused therapy, years of meditation, endurance running, healthy eating, and learning to manage panic attacks and dissociative episodes, I came to understand dysphoria as rooted in negative thought loops rather than an innate, permanent condition. I separated social dysphoria (external and internal) from true physical dysphoria and realized physical dysphoria was about moments of body awareness triggering cascading negative thoughts. This realization took almost a year of focused work built on about three years of prior self-improvement efforts. As a result, I reached a point where I had not felt physical dysphoria for a couple of months — the first time in a very long time I felt at peace with my biological sex.
However, this peace led me to question whether remaining transitioned was an honest enough life. I began seriously considering detransition in 2019. I decided not to date until I figured out what to do, so as not to have someone else's opinion cluttering my decision. I estimated needing 7-9 months to save enough money for a mastectomy (to undo my breast augmentation), since I assumed insurance wouldn't cover it, and planned to use that time for therapy — particularly to work on a major trauma I realized was likely linked to having transitioned and to my dysphoric thoughts. I noted that detransition would make life harder in some ways but would be more true to myself, and that I no longer needed my body to be 'a living closet.'
I also noted some silver linings: as someone who transitioned male-to-female, I was on the 'lucky end' for appearance from HRT in terms of looking younger, and I planned to use strength training to avoid looking like 'some weird boys' after detransition. I was still passing as female in late 2019 while saving for the mastectomy.
In terms of my views, I am critical of the informed consent and gender-affirming model of care, and I researched the history of transition-related surgeries and standards of care extensively, posting about it. I believe dysphoria is a mental disorder but that mental health issues shouldn't be stigmatized, and I'm against the idea that transition is the only treatment. I'm not opposed to transition for someone of sound mind who fully understands the risks, but I take a negative tone toward transition when advising people who are questioning, to provide a counter to positive stories. I also believe strongly that one cannot actually change sex — only modify one's appearance — and that coming to terms with that truth is essential. I've advocated for trauma-informed therapy, CBT for negative thought loops, and better healthcare access for detransitioned people. I found comfort in studying Buddhism as a philosophy on suffering. I also dealt with anger at the realization that I could only live the life I wanted and be accepted by society through radically altering my body.
As of these 2019 posts, I identified as male, had made peace with being male, was still socially transitioned and passing as female, and was saving for a mastectomy while in therapy, intending to detransition. I described myself as gay and feminine.