Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar jarenlang worstelde met dysforie: ik haatte het om als meisje gezien te worden en mijn lichaam. Ik ben autistisch, en na ongeveer twee jaar leren over autisme en autistisch maskeren is mijn dysforie bijna helemaal verdwenen, en ik accepteer nu dat ik een niet-stereotiepe vrouw ben en geen man. Ik heb nooit operaties of hormonen gehad, dus er zijn geen onomkeerbare medische veranderingen of vruchtbaarheidszorgen door transitie. Ik post nu actief in detrans-gemeenschappen, feliciteer anderen die desisteren en betoog dat transitie een makkelijke ontsnapping is die onderliggende problemen niet oplost. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over medische transitie en geloof dat dysforie behandeld moet worden als een psychisch gezondheidsprobleem, bij voorkeur met therapie en zelfacceptatie in plaats van operaties.
Volledig verhaal
I first realized I was attracted to guys at 17 — I had my first crush on a guy then, and for the longest time I thought I was gay because I didn't feel anything for guys, but eventually I did. I never medically transitioned and I have no masculine features, but because I don't dress femininely I still get called 'sir' on the street, which I see as just stereotypes rather than anything to do with my actual appearance.
I struggled with dysphoria for many years. I hated being viewed as a girl, I hated my boobs, and I hated my body. I thought I was a man in a woman's body. I've described that thinking as very unhealthy for me and for everyone around me, and I said I did everything I could to get away from that way of thinking. I never medically transitioned, and I now tell others not to bind because binding is horrible for your ribs and lungs.
I'm autistic. Finding out I'm autistic and going down the rabbit hole of what that truly means was transformative for me — I can say that in about 2 years my dysphoria is almost completely gone. I still dress the same: oversized shirts and oversized sweaters, no dresses in my closet, and I hate being viewed as feminine or lumped in with the stereotypical category of 'women.' But I still am a woman, and being non-stereotypical doesn't make me a man. I've explained that as autistic women we learn from a young age to mask our autistic traits and basically be a different person so we won't be considered weird, and because of that we tend to try taking back control of other aspects of our personality, in this case gender identity. I took control of the way I dress instead. I still have trouble with masking. I believe most autistic people exposed to transgenderism will identify that way because it looks like an easy way out of a deeper problem we all share, which is not identifying with humanity.
I've told others that transition is only an attempt to escape the problems in life, and that the problems go nowhere after doing it. I've said that transitioning is not the only solution to gender dysphoria — it's an easy way out that feels great at first, but then all the other issues come back and you find you both destroyed your body and did nothing for your mental health. I've recommended therapy, but stressed you need a therapist who won't just tell you to transition like it'll solve all your problems, and that you're the same person after you transition, you only change physically. I've said the medical route is basically sterilizing yourself for life and that it isn't the right thing to do in the situation I was discussing. I also recommended that someone stopping HRT should take some T.
I've been open about my own situation being similar to others' who posted on the detrans subreddit, and I've offered to DM people going through it. I've congratulated many people on detransitioning or desisting, saying things like 'Congratulations for waking up' and that it's only going to go up from here. I've said the stigma of speaking up is worth it and that close ones will love you just the same if they are true ones.
I hold critical views of medical transition broadly: I've said gender dysphoria is a mental illness that causes pain and suffering, that no physical solution cures a mental disorder, and that we have to admit it's a disorder to be able to treat it. I've claimed pharma profits enormously from each person who transitions. I've also said gender is defined by gender roles and nothing else, which is why it's a social construct and pointless, and that the only people enforcing stereotypes are those saying that if you don't match them you're the other gender.
On related topics I've argued that a father should have an equal say in abortion decisions (unless rape), that both sexes bear responsibility for avoiding pregnancy, and that a man can't compare a vasectomy to an abortion. I've commented on how women are treated in some cultures, framing it as a problem of where you're from. I've also advocated for the term 'observed female at birth' (OFAB) rather than 'assigned at birth,' saying no one assigns anything.
I've told people they can still dress and behave however they want while being a woman, that womanhood isn't necessarily feminine, and that they have nothing but time. I've advised people to filter their media and not get sucked into seeing trans content. I've also said I wouldn't recommend implants but maybe plastic surgery to reshape nipples and the general area after chest changes.