Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die ongeveer 4,5 jaar als transvrouw leefde op mtf-hormonen na mijn transitie in mijn midden twintig, en die rond 2020 detransitioneerde na een mentale inzinking. Nu identificeer ik me als feminiene, genderniet-conforme man en ben ik hartstochtelijk tegen transitie voor wie dan ook; ik zie het als een sekte en als misbruik. Ik heb BPS, een geschiedenis van anorexia (in herstel), een jaar psychose gerelateerd aan marihuana en transitie, zelfbeschadiging, en ik denk regelmatig aan zelfmoord. Mijn seksualiteit verschoof in ongeveer vijf jaar na het stoppen met porno van homoseksueel naar grotendeels heteroseksueel, en ik heb nog steeds erectiestoornissen, een terugwijkende haarlijn en resterend borstweefsel door oestrogeen. Ik pleit tegen transitie, steun ‘conversie’ richting zelfacceptatie en bouw aan een videogame met een detrans-personage.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I've always been gender nonconforming. As a kid I loved Barbies and other "girl toys," I hated getting my haircut and loved how long wigs made me feel, I had a naturally high voice that sometimes got me told I sounded like a girl, I had a small build, and I leaned feminine in personality. I was also forced at 12 to mow my family's huge backyard even though my personality suited indoor chores, and my sister never had to mow — I still hate lawns because of it. I also developed an eating disorder in my early teens; I now understand that restricting/dieting was my way of separating myself from my overbearing mother who had "let herself go."
I identified as genderqueer before transitioning — this was before "non-binary" was popular. The more I focused on "what gender I felt like," the more female I felt, and it got more pronounced over time, so I decided to transition. I transitioned in my mid-twenties. I saw transition partly as a way to escape aging poorly — I didn't want to become a "wide, leathery, hairy, unkempt old man" like my dad and other men I'd seen. I thought estrogen would stop me from aging into them. Everyone around me affirmed me and pushed back not at all; my parents are classic liberals. I saw a gender therapist and got access to hormones; I can barely remember the conversation. I was on mtf HRT for 4.5 years. I had childhood gender issues that I'd learned to suppress, then after a bad life event I started looking under that rock again and was consumed by what I now call trans ideology — the lie that gender nonconforming equals trans.
While trans I was obsessed with a self-portrait I drew — my body broken into angular pieces, minimalist and abstract so I could avoid depicting my "obviously not female face." I also had full laser hair removal; my beard was thick and full before and is now too sparse to keep long. I obsessively measured my waist while on estrogen. I did not get bottom surgery — that near miss haunts me. I also did not lose my genitals.
I detransitioned about 3 years before these posts (so around 2020, given posts dated 2023). My story is unusual: I detransitioned due to a mental breakdown — I wasn't thinking clearly and decided to detrans on a whim — and only afterward realized transition was 100% a mistake. I did not regret transition until after I detransitioned. After detransing I first went right back to being a "trad male," cut my hair, and then slowly realized gender norms are all bullshit. Now, 3 years later, I'm growing my hair out again, I keep long painted nails (black with a bright sparkly indigo underside), I wear dangly earrings and pastels, and I plan to experiment with skirts and dresses. I have a receded hairline and take finasteride to keep it from getting worse. I still have "moobs" from the estrogen and hope to look into medication for that once I lose weight.
I gained a significant amount of weight after deciding to stop starving myself, and I needed an entirely new wardrobe. Shopping for "male" clothing felt like being a child about to get my hair cut because "boys have short hair" — I couldn't stand men's fashion (button-ups, flannels, jeans, khakis, polos). I eventually searched for "tall women's clothing" (I'm 5'10") and found things that fit and that I liked.
On causes: I now believe transition was driven by my gender nonconformity, strict gender norms, an overbearing mother, fear of aging as a man, my eating disorder's desire to be small (I still look at men and think "they look so large... I don't want to be large"), and a culture that tells feminine boys they aren't real men. I was "consumed by trans ideology." I also say transgenderism "made me insane" — I was psychotic for about a year, half before and half after detransition, which I attribute to a combination of my actions (including being trans) and marijuana usage. I was dependent on being high all the time, had mega social anxiety, cognitive decline, psychosis, and neurosis; compared to now I was "the epitome of a shell of my current self." I also cut daily for 5 years. I have BPD. I struggle with anger — "transition is trauma" — and I say I have something like PTSD from it: thinking about being back there puts me in fight-or-flight. I couldn't stand being alone and felt all the pain when alone.
On therapy: every therapist I could see would gaslight me because I'm anti-trans or because I'm GNC. My current therapist brought up "discrimination against trans people" and it irritated me. A friend was trying to use his connections to find me a therapist, and I contacted GenSpect for therapy help. I said I cannot even call a crisis line about this. I posted in r/mtf about regret and was shadowbanned from Reddit entirely.
On sexuality: I was gay before/during transition — I followed that desire until I found my fantasy guy, "the man of my dreams," and he didn't want me. I started becoming attracted to women while I was trans, and it grew over time as I focused on it, while same-sex attraction diminished as I focused less on it and stopped watching porn. Over about 5 years I went from homosexual to heterosexual; I'm still "kinda bi," but all my masturbatory fantasies now involve me and a woman. I say I "desisted from being gay." I stopped watching porn and stopped having sex with randos; I made my sexual fantasies more positive. I now say heterosexuality is normal and healthy and that I'll call myself "normal and healthy" rather than straight.
On medical recovery: my testosterone was relatively normal at last check. My penis function has "largely returned after 3 years" but isn't totally there yet; my "lil guy" still isn't back to full strength, though I can get it to work when I want. Quitting porn helped the erectile dysfunction. I believe fertility returns within a year or so if there were no surgeries, and that libido came back "full force" in about 6 months, though E damages genitals.
On my current views: I am passionately opposed to transition for anyone. I say transgenderism is a cult, that it's "the left's version of sexism," that transition is abuse and self-harm, that bottom surgery is genital mutilation in any and every case, and that transition medications and surgeries should be banned everywhere. I believe "true trans" is a myth used to gaslight detransitioners — if you transition, you are trans, and detransitioning doesn't retroactively unmake it. I don't have a gender identity and reject the word "cisgender." I believe gender = sex, that gender identity is nonsense, and that the answer to gender dysphoria is to fight gender norms and be GNC as your birth sex. I support "trans conversion therapy" (self-acceptance and integration of GNC behavior) as distinct from gay conversion therapy. I hold critical views of homosexuality based partly on my own experience and my aunt's, and I ground my moral views in the Bible (I am religious, and I've been a target of religious abuse for my long painted nails in my conservative state). I emailed the Missouri government in support of an anti-transition bill — the first time I'd ever done that. I consider advocacy my life purpose: to destroy the attitude that makes feminine boys feel safer in a "costume" than as themselves. I'm making a video game in RPG Maker with a trans/detrans self-insert character. My art has flourished since detransitioning.
Current status: I am a detransitioned, gender nonconforming man. I still experience gender dysphoria sometimes, and I still sometimes "feel female," but I don't pay attention to it. I feel more at peace than I have in the past, though I still feel confused about who I am sometimes and wonder if I should just go full trad. I think about suicide on a regular basis but say being trans was so much worse, and I'm thankful I didn't transition as a kid. I am not anti-suicide but think it must be "completely logical."