Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich als transman identificeerde, ongeveer 2 jaar testosteron gebruikte (ongeveer 8 maanden in het mannelijke bereik) en een dubbele mastectomie had. Mijn dysforie was terug te voeren op seksueel misbruik in mijn kindertijd, gewichtstoename en pesten, en transitie voelde als een toevluchtsoord tegen intimidatie als meisje. Detransitie bracht echte lichamelijke kosten: chronische rugpijn door een niet genezen ribblessure, slappe zachte borsten en keelpijn die verdween toen ik met T stopte, maar stemtraining gedurende anderhalf jaar gaf me een vrouwelijke stem terug. Ik ging van drugsmisbruik en ernstige depressie naar grotendeels nuchter, veel gelukkiger en getrouwd met een geweldige echtgenoot. Nu geloof ik dat sommige mensen echt baat hebben bij transitie terwijl velen zoals ik verkeerd zijn gediagnosticeerd, en ik zou zelfs echte transmensen adviseren operaties uit te stellen tot de opties veiliger zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. My dysphoria didn't come from being transgender in the way I once believed — it spiraled out of childhood sexual abuse, then weight gain, then bullying and harassment about my body. When I found the trans movement, it felt like a refuge: a place where people would stop commenting on my body or harassing me as a girl. I transitioned and lived as a trans man for a while.
I was on testosterone for around 2 years, but only in male range for about 8 months of that. I also had a double mastectomy (top surgery). After detransitioning, I've dealt with lasting physical changes: I injured one of my ribs and it never healed properly, I have a lot of back pain, and my breasts are very soft and saggy now — I described them as feeling like an underfilled microbead pillow. I also had throat pain whenever I spoke while on T, which resolved after I'd been off T for about 3 months. I had already been doing a lot of voice training even while I was still trans-identifying, so by the time I came out as detransitioned I had an androgynous voice. Getting back to a spot-on female voice took probably a year and a half or two of continued voice training, but I feel it was entirely worth it. I wouldn't recommend voice surgery to anyone because the vocal cords are too delicate to just shave down.
Detransition was hard. At my most dysphoric during detransition, I leaned on a few things: a support person — a man who became my rock, someone I could just hang out with and who let me talk about things on my terms without judging me; venting to ChatGPT and to my journal to get things out of my head instead of letting them stew; and finding kinship with other detrans women, and to some extent trans women, reading how they worked through similar feelings. I went through phases with my body hair, which helped me stop seeing it as 'masculine' and start seeing it as a neutral, normal aspect of myself as a mammal — I didn't want to shave just to make society happy or to be more attractive to a love interest. I also invested in simple non-makeup skincare and beauty products: chapstick, body lotion, face wash, clean nails, moisturized skin. After top surgery I had to work up to taking baths again, but bubble baths helped — I'd put the bubbles over my chest if I struggled with seeing it. Points 1, 3 and 5 (support person, kinship with other detrans women, and self-care) were the most helpful.
Before detransition I had been drug-abusing and severely depressed. Now I'm mostly sober and much, much happier, and I have a wonderful husband. It's only been a couple of years and I promise it gets easier. I no longer care if people label me as male, female, nonbinary, lesbian, whatever — I know I'm a girl inside and that's my business. Coming out to friends as 'nonbinary any pronouns' was a useful stepping stone for me when I was afraid of losing my social circle; it got a positive response, though it's not perfect or easy. I recognize that getting rid of your entire social circle isn't a tradeoff many detrans people would choose.
I also dealt with a lot of social dysphoria during detransition that came from trying to conform to gender roles rather than from my body itself; once I realized that, I decided to dress and present in ways that made me comfortable. On the medical side, the depo shot worked for me to stop periods; I'm now on combined birth control and choose to have my period, but you can skip the placebo week to skip it — I get mine for $12/month shipped without insurance.
I now believe there are legitimate transgender people who genuinely benefit from transition, alongside many people who are misdiagnosed, misunderstood, or perhaps attention-seeking who end up under the trans label. I think both trans-inclusionary and trans-exclusionary camps are half right and half wrong, and that neither side sees there are two separate groups living under the trans label. For most people like me, a world without gender roles would have been ideal — we wouldn't have been put into boxes and could have been happy with our bodies, because our 'gender dysphoria' was caused by something other than gender identity disorder or gender incongruence. I still think even someone who is legitimately 100% trans should hold off until surgical options are better and less risky.