Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw. Ik ging op mijn 19e in transitie, gebruikte 6 maanden testosteron en ben ongeveer drie jaar geleden gestopt. Ik heb geen spijt van de transitie zelf — ik voelde me op testosteron juist lichamelijk en mentaal beter, omdat ik van nature een testosterontekort heb — maar ik stopte nadat ik besefte dat mijn dysforie samenhing met het systemische trauma van als vrouw geboren zijn en met een verlangen om verbonden te zijn met vrouwen als sociale klasse. Ik ervaar nog steeds extreme genderdysforie, denk nog steeds aan opnieuw transitioneren, en werk samen met mijn endometriose-artsen aan een lage dosis testosteron om medische redenen. Ik geloof niet in „echte trans” en zie transitie als een pleister op sociaal trauma, al wil ik wel door vreemden als man gezien worden. Ik ben bijna 22 en ben sinds mijn detransitie gegroeid in zelfacceptatie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I was yelling at my family to call me a boy name at two years old, and I cut my own hair at six. I wanted top surgery since I was 8 years old and testosterone since I was 11. I was diagnosed with gender identity disorder almost 10 years before I was able to get testosterone as an adult. The trans experience was a huge majority of my childhood, and my transition to adulthood was marked by medical transition and subsequent detransition.
I transitioned at 19 and was on testosterone for only 6 months. I stopped testosterone, but I have considered discussing with my endometriosis doctor team about going back on a low dose for wanted benefits. When I was on testosterone, my moods were much more stable, except when suffering testosterone withdrawals. This is likely because I am naturally testosterone deficient and have very naturally high estrogen — an imbalance, because it was too low testosterone and too high estrogen for a female. Other physical symptoms improved too: pain from endometriosis lessened, periods stopped completely right away with no drawbacks, and I had much more energy and enthusiasm. I honestly miss that. I loved testosterone.
I don't have any regrets about my actual transition. I'm glad I did it, and I wasn't unhappy when seeing changes. I stopped for reasons more related to inner and political realization. It's not so much regret of the actual transition, but more so realizing that being trans is a bandaid — that these feelings of gender dysphoria are actually part of the systemic trauma that comes with being born a member of the female class. Women are an oppressed class of people, and from birth we are socialized into painful conformity via sexual, psychological, physical, and emotional violence.
One of the major factors in my detransition was realizing my female ancestors probably struggled with these feelings too — that this thing now described and pathologized as gender dysphoria is a huge component of the female experience. It was a lot of looking inside myself and also outwards, at other women in my life, at my own mother, even. Relating my experiences to female experiences as a collective, realizing that I can't truly opt out of that, that I was trying to separate my "male self" from my trauma of being born a woman. A huge part of my own transition was wanting to be a feminine guy, to be able to dress feminine without feeling like it's something I'm forced into, without getting props for following my correct role if I wear a skirt. I didn't want my clothes to have a meaning behind it, to be scrutinized the way women are. I think being socialized female is itself traumatizing.
I also wanted to be respected the way men are respected. I want to be shirtless, to swim shirtless. I don't want to be seen as a sex object by people who pass me on the street. But I realized it's unfair to all other women for just me to opt out of misogyny. Why do I have to become male to have basic freedoms? I find it better to fight for all women to be free from misogyny, not just me. I want to be connected to women as a social class — the history, the richness, the real inner power that comes with this body.
As someone attracted to men, I also wondered whether wanting to transition and be in a relationship with men had to do with how, as a woman, relationships with men don't feel equal — that was another factor in my transition.
Dealing with doctors has been frustrating. Bringing up past testosterone treatment is relevant, and one doctor said, "oh what happened were you experimenting at that time?" I don't think going on cross-sex hormones and changing your body should be "experimenting." It often feels like I left a cult and I want to scream it from the rooftops, but I know therapists won't get it and I'll look like a "transphobe." Even normal people respond like "aw teehee sorry about your little oopsie," as if you're just one person who was failed when really the system is failing dysphoric people and LGB men and women as a whole.
I'm about three years past my transition now and have grown a lot. Where I got in my self-love today wasn't something I was able to feel when I stopped. I was 19 when transitioning and almost 22 now. As I continue to grow up, I realize how much being trans is about the refusal to grow up, because it's not really a sustainable way of living your life. I used to be deathly afraid of people who have the viewpoints I hold now.
I have extreme gender dysphoria that hasn't changed — I've been off testosterone for years and my feelings haven't changed; I just want to go on it again. I don't want to just be seen as "more like a man" — I want strangers to see me as a man, period. I can't just ignore my dysphoria. I felt the desire to transition before I ever knew what trans was. I never have ever wanted to give birth; liking children doesn't equate to wanting to give birth. I don't see transition as making a female person male, and I don't believe some people are "truly trans." I feel in my soul I should be a man, but it's important for people to unpack why that is — it's never for no reason. I hate everything that comes with being seen as female in society.
I've been outcasted by women my whole life and wanted to be a boy my whole life. Hanging out with women isn't innate to me. I've even been called a gorilla before by very young trans rights activists for not shaving my legs. I'm from the MENA region and have had a visible moustache since before transition. I still am very "gender confused" and think about "re-transitioning" a lot. I'm choosing testosterone as an option for treating my endometriosis.