Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd, maar drie jaar lang ertegen geargumenteerd

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd591
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw: ik ben als vrouw geboren, ben nooit zelf getransitioneerd, en identificeer en presenteer me als vrouw. Ik kwam als waarnemer naar deze gemeenschap met een vriend(in) die transitie overwoog, en in 2022-2024 werd ik steeds kritischer over medische transitie: ik betoogde dat het een tijdelijke oplossing is voor onderliggende dysmorfie en depressie en pleitte in plaats daarvan voor 'gendervertrouwen-therapie'. Ik heb detransitioners als Chloe Cole geprezen, geprobeerd een vriend(in) die met oestrogeen begon zachtjes weg te sturen van transitie, en onomwonden gezegd dat 'Niemand trans is.' Ik heb geen persoonlijke spijt over hormonen of operaties beschreven, aangezien ik die nooit onderging, noch suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging. Ik blijf mensen die detransitioneren steunen en ben kritisch over hoe de pro-transbeweging op afwijkende meningen reageert.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and I have never described a personal history of gender dysphoria, transition, hormones, or surgery in anything I've posted — my involvement in this community has been as an observer, a friend of people who transition, and someone working out my views on the whole question. The first thing I remember posting, in April 2022, was that I'd read a Walt Heyer opinion piece in USA Today simply because I was curious what the statistics on regret actually were. I mentioned that I have a dear friend who is transitioning from a he to a she with hormones and considering surgery, and I said that I think as teens you aren't mature enough to really understand yet, and that it takes therapy and a good hard look at whom you want to be. That was the framing I started from, and it has stayed fairly consistent. In November 2022 I shared Chloe Cole's story, calling it heartbreaking, and posted a link to one of her YouTube appearances, saying we need more people like this who aren't afraid to come forward with their stories, because people are willing to listen, they just have to make the first step. In May 2023 I started arguing more directly. I posted a thread titled 'Social norms & surgery' laying out how I talk through it: if gender and sex aren't the same thing, why are the operations called 'gender affirming' surgeries, and why puberty blockers? I argued that surgery is undertaken to appear a certain way, back to the initial biological appearance of a certain sex, which isn't a social idea, and that meds and blockers block biological appearances of female/male characteristics — 'It's down to the science.' In the same period I pushed back on people who said gender roles mean nothing while attaching 'femme' things to how they carry themselves, and I questioned why anyone would undergo surgery to get what is essentially a visual stereotype of a penis when it isn't an actual functioning penis. I described that whole framing as 'a fantasy world of a feeling inside when it's really just a mental disorder of dysmorphia.' I've been asked directly in threads what I am, and I've answered plainly: 'Female,' 'Woman.' I've also, in a couple of posts where people posted photos, commented warmly on how someone looks — 'Your features are insanely beautiful. You look radiant,' 'I love those earrings... you are glowing,' and once noting that someone's 'eyes shine in the wig.' I told one person I could see the difference in them after detransitioning, that the glow behind them was undeniable and their expression seemed happier. In October 2023 I wrote a post titled 'Feelings' asking people who felt 'in a different body' whether they knew what trans was before they felt that feeling, or whether they just felt out of body; whether wanting opposite reproductive organs was about what would suit their idea of gender; how changing organs would help body dysmorphia if you don't believe in gender roles; and whether the trans movement had pushed them into thinking they needed to change organs to cure their feelings. I wrote that gender affirming surgeries give false hope to an individual hoping for basic care, that care starts with mental evaluation not transition, that children cannot consent to puberty blockers because puberty is not a medical condition, that no one is born in the wrong body, that mental illness is treatable, and that biology cannot change. I've been through a pregnancy, and I've said that when I got pregnant I realized this is not something I wanted and I celebrated my femininity and biological body. I've recommended 'gender confidence therapy' to several people, and I've told people that a feeling and a wanting should be separate — everyone focuses on the feeling which creates the wanting and forgets the need; you need to take care of your biological body, and the health risks of transitioning down the line are far greater than filling the void of a want. I've said the root of these struggles is gender dysmorphia mixed with clinical depression, and that transition is a temporary fix for a lifelong problem. I have a friend, someone I got to know about a year before I wrote about them, who started taking estrogen because they felt the urge to transition and wanted to date men and be seen as normal. I described him as a gay man wanting to become a woman to appear female to men, and I said I've been trying to help them with my experience, though we aren't super close, and that I fear they are confused and want to gently help them. I've been critical of the pro-trans movement for blocking and attacking differing opinions while calling other people one-sided, saying 'It's sick really,' and I've said I stay far away from those communities because it's a pitchfork society despite claiming to love all. I've said flatly that 'No one is trans,' that transitioning is an action to a problem that doesn't exist in normal reality, and that those in question need therapists who specialize in gender questioning and gender confidence therapy. I've also said the world is losing all common sense, all the way down to biology. I've been supportive of detransitioners publicly — praising Chloe Cole, telling one person 'Godspeed' and that I was proud of them for realizing something didn't feel right, for creating a circle of new friends and partners who support them, and framing that as goodness shining in, 'rays of just pure love from God,' while saying evil and immoral principles are everywhere in society now and that if you question things you get called a bigot. I've told people they aren't alone, sent love, and told someone to stay clean and healthy for them and their future family. I have not described any personal regret about transition, because I have not described transitioning. My story here is one of a friend and community observer who has become increasingly convinced that transition is the wrong answer, and who now actively tries to gently redirect people I know toward therapy rather than medical steps.