Alle verhalen

Drie jaar van hormonen af, getekend door beide kanten

Man · Gedetransitioneerd28
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon voor wie dit onderwerp diep persoonlijk is: ik stopte drie jaar met hormonen en verliet het hele gebeuren met PTSS en diepe littekens nadat ik werd blootgesteld aan gender-kritische gemeenschappen als alternatief voor transitie. Ik doe nu steunwerk in de LGBT-gemeenschap en ben kritisch over de anti-transitie ideologische inslag van deze subreddit, terwijl ik toch geloof dat detransitie prima is en dat mensen gesteund moeten worden in wat ze ook besluiten. Ik heb een relatie met een vrouw met wie ik van plan ben te trouwen en die ook gedetransitioneerd is. Ik heb in deze posts geen volledige tijdlijn van mijn eigen transitie en detransitie uiteengezet, maar ik heb verwezen naar het gebruik van testosteron op enig moment.

Volledig verhaal

I have been active in and around this community on and off for about six months as of mid-2020, and I come to it as someone for whom the topic is deeply personal. I stopped hormones for three years, and that period was a huge part of my life, so I know what it is like to sit with the question of whether transition is right for you. My own path took a dark turn. I walked away from the whole thing with PTSD and some pretty deep scars, and I attribute that in large part to gender-critical rhetoric and gender-critical communities being offered to me as an alternative to transition. I now believe that kind of community is dangerous for someone who is genuinely trans, and that the question of whether to transition should be the domain of a therapist, not a hostile community. I have told people directly that a question like that 'isn't really a question for strangers, it's one for a psychologist,' and that someone could be trans and just scared, or not, and that this is part of figuring it out. I deal a lot in LGBT community support, and it matters to me that people questioning their gender can be pointed toward resources they might actually find useful. What worries me is the idea that someone questioning could find or be suggested a space largely made up of people with an ideology opposed to the concept of transition regardless of its merit for that individual. I have repeatedly raised this concern here: I pointed out that this sub's user base overwhelmingly overlaps with subreddits that are incredibly hostile to transition, that it has more users in common with conservative communities than with LGBT ones, and that the private subreddit itsafetish ranked third on that overlap list the last time I checked. I have said plainly that I think this place has a severe ideological bent against transition, and that I know a couple of people who were looking for a space to discuss the topic and explicitly avoided coming here because they were disgusted by the attitudes they found. At the same time, I try to be fair. I have said I don't think the sub itself is transphobic, though a sizable contingent of people who are seem very at home here, and I have noted that the sub has a rule against recommending medical transition, which I contrasted with trans subreddits that I said do not forbid recommending not transitioning. I have acknowledged that people who had a terrible experience being fairly dark on the idea of transition is something I can at least understand, and that some of the people here never transitioned at all. My overall stance is that I'd just like to see people happy being themselves, that detransition is fine, and that I'd be just as disappointed in a trans sub that ruled out any answers but transition as I am in spaces that rule out any answers but not transitioning. I have been openly critical of gender-critical spaces and their rhetoric. I called out an article whose negative talking points about trans people were being upvoted here, quoting lines like 'Much of the transgender agenda is driven by misogyny' and the suggestion to 'help the brain to accommodate the body,' and I described it as TERF content and religious conversion therapy. I have said this sub has a reputation for being a TERF recruiting ground, and that GC circles tend to see trans people as a hostile amorphous group resembling the worst possible examples. I also pushed back on a petition here, saying I'd like to see further support but could not support its wording. On a personal level, I am in a relationship with a woman: I referred to 'the girl I plan to marry' who detransitioned. I have also noted that I am 'lacking T for the opposite reason' and that I am more spiteful towards certain people than others, which suggests I have been on testosterone at some point, though I have not laid out the full timeline of my own transition and detransition in these posts. I have been combative at times in these threads, telling one person 'The hell is wrong with you' and generally engaging in long, pointed arguments about the sub's orientation.