Alle verhalen

Een jaar trans geïdentificeerd, zonder medische stappen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd976
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw die zich ongeveer een jaar als trans identificeerde maar nooit medisch transitioneerde, en ik identificeer me niet meer als trans. Nu geloof ik dat mijn wens om te transitioneren en mijn lichaamsongemak werden gedreven door opdringerige OCD-gedachten, mogelijk autisme, problemen met lichaamsbeeld en zware blootstelling aan trans en non-binaire inhoud in online fandomruimtes als tiener. Een vrouw met ‘terf’-achtige opvattingen hielp me begrijpen dat het normaal was om het andere geslacht te willen zijn zonder trans te zijn, al ben ik het niet eens met al haar opvattingen en steun ik transitie nog steeds voor sommige mensen. Ik pleit voor betere screening op OCD, autisme en lichaamsdysmorfie vóór medische transitie, en ik wil dat de stemmen van detransitioners worden gehoord zonder transfoob genoemd te worden. Ik worstel nog wat met mijn lichaam en genderidentiteit, maar ben oké met vrouw zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I am a female desister — someone who identified as trans for about a year but never medically transitioned. I came out as trans to my friends, and some of them still think I'm trans or that I'm questioning, but I no longer identify as trans. I've been questioning my gender on and off, and I now see clearly that I am a woman, even though I still have some struggles with my body and gender identity. As a child, before I ever heard the word transgender, I wanted to be a boy. I even thought I was a boy before I became more socialized female. A lot of my friends were boys, my favorite cartoon characters were boys, and I thought being a boy meant you could be the main character more often while girls were background characters. I tried hard to 'act like a boy' — though I now realize it wasn't to become male, but rather to not be female. When I was a teenager I identified as a boy and wanted to become a man; I watched men on YouTube doing and saying things I now know were extreme and unhealthy. I thought being a woman meant being weak, a side character, and I associated womanhood with shopping culture, superficiality, exaggerated accents, and being hypersexualized. A big part of my story is OCD. I have OCD and only learned about TOCD (transgender OCD) about a year ago — I'd always thought OCD was just about cleaning. I had intrusive thoughts about my gender, and 'if I don't like my body, I must actually be trans' was something I thought about every day. Wanting to transition and discomfort with my body became my OCD obsession. My thinking was very black-and-white, and I now believe that OCD, and possibly autism, led me to mistake my other issues for gender dysphoria. I may or may not be autistic — I'm still sorting out whether it's OCD instead. I also had body image issues that could explain my desire to transition. Online spaces influenced me. I was quite active in fandom spaces full of transgender and non-binary posts, and that made me want to be trans. I saw mostly non-binary and sometimes trans people identifying that way, and I felt like them in many ways. Those spaces became a place for me to take on male pronouns and identity to explain why I had intrusive thoughts about changing gender. I also had trans friends in real life as a teenager, mostly female-to-male or non-binary. I think my OCD coupled with childhood and fandom influences caused me to believe I had gender dysphoria. If I had stayed in those fandom spaces, I would still obsess over becoming male. I now believe I never actually had gender dysphoria — I mistook wanting to be the opposite gender and body discomfort for dysphoria. I've come to realize that many non-trans people are uncomfortable with their own sex or manhood/womanhood, and that gender dysphoria is not the only explanation for feeling that way; OCD, autism, or body dysmorphia could be. I also realized that manhood and womanhood aren't as black-and-white as I thought — men don't have it easier either, since showing emotion is frowned upon and men are pressured to be tough. I thought being a man would be better, but it was 'the grass is greener on the other side.' A woman with what some would call 'terf' political beliefs helped convince me to detransition. She explained that it's common for young women not to want to be women, and that it's okay and normal for a cis person, especially a child, to want to be the opposite gender — it may or may not be a phase, and a person may or may not 'grow out of it.' I don't agree with all her views on trans people; I think some people genuinely benefit from transitioning. She helped me understand who I was: not a trans man, but a woman. I'm scared of being labeled a 'terf' for speaking about my experience. I haven't experienced desistphobia online or in real life yet, but I'm afraid to say I'm desisted. I don't like how detransition people are villainized or tokenized, though I'm slowly coping better with that. I've seen anti-detrans content online that made me unhappy, including mocking of detransitioned women's bodies and fetishization of detransition. I believe there needs to be more screening for autism, body dysmorphia, and OCD before someone is cleared for medical transition, and that gender therapists should discuss autism with patients who might be autistic. At the same time, I'm not against transition because it can be life-saving for some, and I want a nuanced middle ground rather than taking sides in the culture war. I've been active in detrans communities online, sharing my story and asking other detransitioners about their experiences, particularly autistic detransitioners. I want to help both autistic trans and autistic detrans people by having this discussion. I don't force anyone to detransition — I think people should figure it out slowly and naturally, possibly with therapy.