Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man (als man geboren) die transitioneerde ondanks dat twee therapeuten me waarschuwden voor sociale besmetting, en ik ben het nu met hen eens dat ze gelijk hadden. Op hormonen kreeg ik krimpende testikels, die later weer normaal werden, zonder merkbare verandering in de grootte van mijn penis, en ik dank sport en beweging voor het weer natuurlijk en trots voelen over mijn lichaam. Ik sta sceptisch tegenover therapie voor identiteitsproblemen, al respecteer ik therapeuten die patiënten uitdagen in plaats van simpelweg te valideren. Ik heb mijn volledige transitie- of detransitietijdlijn in deze reacties niet beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I work as a dentist, and I've been thinking a lot lately about identity, therapy, and what I went through around my own transition. In my daily life I see all kinds of people — recently a butch-looking teenager corrected me at my job when I referred to them as 'her,' saying they go by 'they/them,' and it made me wonder how I'm supposed to navigate these interactions now, and how much online support these kids must be getting to feel so confident asserting their identity to medical people during something as innocuous as a check-up.
On therapy, I'm pretty skeptical. I think therapists for issues of identity are basically useless — they can be a sounding board if you have no one to talk to, but that's about it. I find it cringe when people lean on them like they're parents, and I think 'go get therapy' is a dumb Reddit-ism that never explains how therapy will actually help. That said, I do respect therapists who push back. I had two therapists who challenged my thoughts about being trans — one even mentioned social contagion — and of course I ignored them and plowed ahead, but in the end they were right, and I respect that they pushed back rather than just validating everything I said. I notice therapists generally trend toward a feminine view of the world: no aggressiveness, no challenging the patient's premises, just being 'nice' and non-controversial.
On the medical side, I've been on hormones — I'm male — and I can say from my own experience that my balls did shrink while on them, but they returned to normal size afterward. As for my penis, I don't think the shaft changed size at all. When other guys worry about losing length, I'm skeptical — most men don't even measure properly and can be off by half an inch to an inch depending on angle and how hard they press into the pubic bone, so I doubt any real change occurred.
Exercise and sports make me feel natural and proud of my body, which has been an important part of how I feel now. I also think about gender dynamics a lot — I've commented on how the experiences of both genders have their problems, and how extremist corners of the internet being filled with men is itself an example of the hardship and stress men face. I've also observed that the number of submissive men to dominant women is something like 1000:1, and the one dominant woman I met really did feel like a man to me in terms of her energy — masculine rather than 'assertive feminine.' I don't buy the idea that the world is a hellscape for Western women.
When I'm dealing with my own internal energy, I tend to direct rage outwards and pretend I'm facing some kind of challenge, like men of old marching off to war. Sometimes I remember that plenty of people live moment to moment, never prepare, and just chase one 'good time' after another — and while I don't want to live like that, realizing how many people do helps put life in context and shows it can be irrational to be so introspective as to let personal issues control your emotions or drain your energy. Literally there are people running around being criminals living chaotic lives, so maybe your problems aren't so bad.
I haven't laid out every detail of my own timeline here, but the through-line for me is that I transitioned, I had therapists who questioned it and whom I ignored, and I eventually came around to seeing they were right. I'm still working through how I feel about my body and about the medical changes I went through, but exercise helps, and I've found that the physical changes from hormones were at least partly reversible for me.