Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich van ongeveer mijn 12e tot mijn 15½ identificeerde als een jongen genaamd Brian, gedreven door een vaderfiguur die vrouwen seksualiseerde en devalueerde, een moeder die me leerde dat vrouwen zwak waren, en extreme isolatie in een klein conservatief stadje in Iowa. Ik kreeg nooit hormonen of operaties omdat mijn voogden weigerden te tekenen, en ik desisteerde zelf nadat ik in een pleeggezin kwam en een meisje ontmoette dat me liet zien dat ik een meisje kon zijn en toch stoer. Nadat ik accepteerde vrouw te zijn ontwikkelde ik anorexia, waar ik ongeveer acht jaar mee heb geleefd en waar ik nu van herstel, naast blijvende sociale moeilijkheden door mijn isolatie. Ik werd op mijn 8e geseksualiseerd en op mijn 18e verkracht, en ik identificeer me nu als gelukkige heteroseksuele vrouw die blij is dat ze niet transitioneerde. Ik ben nu scherp kritisch over medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en over wat ik zie als sekte-achtig gedrag in de online transgemeenschap.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in a tiny conservative rural town in Iowa with about 1,200 people and five churches. My father figure treated women badly, said women were only good for sex, and sexualized me from around age eight or nine. I remember being about nine and wanting to put on a magic show, tucking a small blanket into my shirt as a cape, and him saying, "look she's already stuffing wanted boobs," which made me feel weird and uncomfortable. He treated boys and men much better than me, favoring his friends' sons. My mother figure told me women were weak and needed to be protected, and I was taught it was unsafe for women to be alone anywhere. I learned that being female made me lesser and less deserving of respect. I always liked playing with boys and being "tough."
When I was 12 I decided I wanted to be a boy. I went to a salon and had all my hair chopped off to my ears into a "boy cut." I became afraid of my developing breasts and started binding with ace bandage wraps, and I slept on my stomach thinking it would keep my breasts from growing. I was mocked at school. I started going by a male-oriented name, "Brian," tried to play male sports like football, though my parental figures wouldn't sign the permission forms. I didn't tell classmates I was a boy because I knew they wouldn't understand.
I was extremely isolated growing up. I wasn't allowed on the internet, wasn't allowed to go out and play, had to come straight home from school, and the TV and DVDs raised me. I had no friends at school and very little social interaction until I graduated high school. Because of this isolation, "trans" wasn't a word in my vocabulary and I had no idea people could get hormones or surgery until after high school. I'm glad I didn't know, because I would have been in even more distress wanting HRT.
Around 15 and a half I was removed into foster care and placed in a new home two hours away in a new town. That home had other girls with different personalities. After about a week, talking with a foster sister who was into punk rock and "masc" things, I realized I could be a girl and still love those things. I decided to present as a girl at the new school and forget the whole thing. I slowly grew my hair out, wore androgynous clothes, and went by my female name. I still didn't make friends, but I became comfortable being a girl and learned I could be strong and tough, that there were no real limits to being a girl, and I began to stand up for myself.
My guardians refused to sign papers for hormones and knew it would be bad for my physical and mental health. I'm very glad they didn't push me toward transition and "nipped that shit right in the bud." I never got hormones or surgery.
My foster care experience was not positive. I went through lots of abuse and neglect: I wasn't allowed to eat in the same room or at the same time as the foster parents, was constantly called dumb, and wasn't allowed to explore other facets of my identity. Walking to school at minus 20 Fahrenheit was considered a "privilege" because it meant they trusted we wouldn't run away. We could go to the library for one hour once a week, which was a big deal. We were fed ramen, hot pockets, and cheap cereal. They would go on vacations without us, dump us at another home, and then rub it in our faces. The only positive was seeing an alternative-looking girl, now like a sister to me, and seeing that not all girls fit the stereotype.
I was also raped later, at age 18. After I accepted being a girl, I developed anorexia nervosa as a way to cope instead of transitioning. I've been dealing with anorexia for going on eight years, but I'm in recovery and working to stay recovered in the long haul in therapy. I also struggle with making friends and keeping them because of my lifelong isolation.
Coming out of the male identification was uncomfortable. I had to tell everyone I wasn't a guy anymore and ask people to stop using my male name, which was embarrassing. I felt like a fuckup and ashamed of how I had tried to present as something I wasn't, really trying to fit the male stereotype. My friends were very supportive, with a "we told you so" attitude, laughing and saying they knew I'd come around. Family and friends were receptive and happy to have me be myself again. Very few people even knew I had identified as trans for a while; my girlfriend doesn't know. I find it embarrassing to think about but wanted to share it to help questioning FtM people.
Now I identify as a happy heterosexual female, the way I was born. I feel so much better being comfortable with who and what I am, and I feel free, not worrying about how others perceive me. I no longer worry about appearing masculine or tough or keeping men's attention at bay. I know I can be anything I want and that what's between my legs won't stop me; I don't need to change the outside to love myself.
I have strong opinions about transition now. I'm critical of medical transition, especially for kids, and angered by what I see as trans propaganda. I got a YouTube ad for hormones despite not having looked anything up about that in years, and I saw ads from Planned Parenthood targeting kids with puberty blockers and HRT, which disgusted me so much I didn't want to support them anymore for birth control. I've seen pregnant men at that clinic. I think doctors should recommend therapy, not drugs. I've described the online trans community as cult-like, having watched a friend who detransitioned (MtFtM) get "ate alive" by the online trans community and school LGBTQ group while family and cis friends were most supportive. I've also said I dated a trans MtF person who was always worried about making every action feminine, was always crying about feeling "fake," and whose hormones were doing awful things to them; I tried to bring them back to reality. I also dated a guy who didn't fit masculinity and decided he was a girl instead and started hormones. I think gender questioning has been made trendy and turned into a quirk rather than treated as a medical problem, and that all this limits possibilities for women's representation. I'm passionate about this community and try to be supportive of others considering detransition.