Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up in a dangerous neighborhood where I always felt like I had to be on the lookout, and I was mistreated by strangers as a female in ways that made me scared of my own feminine clothing — it felt like going around with a mark on my back. Because of that I stopped wearing feminine clothes, stuck to clothes that covered me up as much as possible, cut my hair, and felt panic rising whenever it grew past my ears; I used to have hair down my whole back, and now the thought of long hair scares me. I did prefer wearing more masculine clothes since I was a child and used to cry when they put me in dresses. All of this added up to my conviction that I must not be cis.
For a couple of years before December 2024 I had been going to niche political events in the big non-English-speaking city I live in outside the USA, and I got sucked into a couple of small collectives that I eventually left because I didn't like how they worked. One was a transfeminist group whose meet-ups consisted of pouring our hearts out to what were essentially strangers and calling it political praxis — looking back, quite unhealthy. We were all female except for a couple of males who joined towards the end, and about 90% described themselves as trans, questioning, or "generally not cis." Anyone who claimed to be cis would get constant comments like "But the way you feel about your gender isn't like someone cis would feel" and "You ask yourself questions cis people never ask" until they'd eventually announce that their gender identity wasn't what they thought it was. I belonged to the "generally not cis" segment; I'd always had my own particular take on gender, so it felt natural to say that, even though no one else seemed to share my experience.
I made friends through that group and lost most of them once I stopped going, except for one close friend: a medically transitioned trans guy (FTM) who started in his late teens or early twenties. He's very judgmental of cis people, treats them like they're dumb for believing their gender matches their sex, half-jokes about "transing" people, and talks about being trans like it's synonymous with waking up from the Matrix. Talking to him about confusion about your own gender means getting his seal of approval. Months before my first post, I was talking to him about my doubts and he told me, "You would benefit from some testosterone." That shook me — first I felt invaded, because it was such an invasive thing to suggest so lightheartedly, as if my body was his; then I felt insulted that he thought he could advise me on something so important given he's less mature than me. He also randomly decided to call me with masculine pronouns even though I use feminine pronouns, once in front of a trans friend of his, and I felt too awkward to correct him because it would have meant affirming my identity as a woman. I sent him pictures of myself as a teenager when I was more feminine and he laughed and said, "Look at you pretending to be a girl." When I said I am a girl he replied with a text that made no sense and then sent me a GoFundMe for a stranger's gender-affirming operation. I realized that if he sends me something like that again I'm going to tell him I don't care, he'll accuse me of transphobia, and I'll be treated coldly by a lot of people in my everyday life — but I don't care at this point.
I also noticed that he consistently talks badly about meat-eating cishet men in a way that creeped me out: while trying to explain how much of a creep every single one of them is, he described the fantastical sexual lives of men he'd never talked to but extensively fantasized about being extremely abusive and toxic, and in doing so showed his true colors without noticing. I think he's like that because he desperately needs to feel like he belongs somewhere, and because part of him might be regretting medically transitioning while another part is in denial and looking for people to validate him and "join" him. He once told me he regretted not thinking about how transition would sterilize him; I thought he was too young to know he'd want kids someday, but I kept quiet lest I get an hour-and-a-half earful about how even children can make that choice and that it saves lives, including his own. I realized the only thing keeping him my friend is that I'd feel sorry for him — most of our discussions are about how sad he is and all his problems — but he's starting to irritate me, especially with the masculine pronouns.
I started going to therapy, which made me realize how scared I am all the time and that I leaned more and more into my masculine side because it served as a shield. I'm not saying that's the case for every masculine-presenting person, but it is for me. I went through major changes during 2024, and after almost two years I realized I couldn't put up with the group dynamics anymore. I "socially detransitioned" in the last few months before January 2025 — for me that meant stopping saying certain things about my own gender to a certain group of people in real life, while nothing else changed — but I don't consider myself detrans, because I associate the term detrans with people who detransitioned medically. It didn't feel like as drastic a change. I don't think there's anything wrong with being trans; I think it's a cultural performance as much as being cis is. The problem with how my friends present it is that they completely ignore that: being trans equals being illuminated and having access to a higher knowledge, a weirdly hermeneutical and elitist behavior. I noticed they're never upfront about their positions — they wait a while before telling you that everyone is actually trans and that cis het men who eat meat are 100% rapists or will rape. I also fixated on the fact that, in my non-English-speaking country, most trans people I met choose an English name or a name clearly chosen to present themselves; I think in some cases that testifies to how much they don't actually want to change and how dissociated they are from themselves, and I'm pretty sure some of them will detransition. My friend, who has a beard and a low voice, refuses to change his name because "if I end up in a male prison…" and his chosen name is explicitly chosen and kinda goofy; I think that shows indecision — they don't want their "old cis" name but aren't really okay living as a different gender, so they choose a name that isn't really a name, perpetually floating in the gap between genders they themselves conceptualized.
I asked where someone who is queer and not rightwing-leaning could critically discuss queerness, since discourse on trans issues that doesn't come through the pink-tinted lens of the queer community tends to lean right-wing. I've agreed with critiques describing trans ideology as a quasi-religious belief, noting how they point to "platonic ideals" instead of material reality and expect everyone to accept those ideals as concretely real. I've also written about a date I had with a trans woman where I asked her to put a condom on and she said it made her feel dysphoric and she couldn't stay hard; I was younger and really wanted to keep going so I accepted it that time. A trans friend of mine had the same experience and felt violated because he wasn't given time to consent. I think it's a straight-up lie — a condom makes you feel dysphoric, but not a vagina wrapped around your dick? I've also argued that people who claim to care about passing actually only care about imposing their will on others, that bearded men in women's bathrooms are a slap in the face to every woman with a facial-hair condition and to women generally, since society tells us from puberty that our body and facial hair are disgusting and need to be removed, and then literal men act as if growing a beard while wearing a dress is revolutionary. I don't think there's anything positive to say about gender norms; when discussing them we should reason from people's sex first, not their gender identity — gender is "women should shave!" while sex is "women naturally grow body and facial hair." I've advised others to do an internet detox and to be able to be who they are without someone else's opinion or advice, and I've pushed back when other detransitioners blamed others for their transitions instead of doing their own research, though I apologized when I learned professionals had been involved. I don't consider myself right-wing and I'm wary of spaces that only critique queerness from the right.