Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren, en na een gothpuberteit, pesten, seksueel trauma in mijn kindertijd en een pornoverslaving op mijn 17e identificeerde ik me als trans en gebruikte ik kort een geandrogyniseerde naam voordat ik desisteerde zonder ooit medisch te transitioneren. Het bestuderen van de biologie van sekse en de sociologie van gender, plus een autismediagnose op mijn 30e, overtuigden me ervan dat ik nooit trans was, en ik pleit al zo'n 16 jaar voor een genderkritische visie dat niemand „echt trans” is. Nu ben ik een gedesisteerde, genderkritische, vrouwelijke hetero man, getrouwd met mijn vrouw met een jonge dochter, en werk ik in de geestelijke gezondheidszorg. Ik maak melding van seksueel trauma in mijn kindertijd en PTSS, een diagnose binnen het autismespectrum, een periode van ernstige depressie waarin ik bijna een zelfmoordpoging deed (sindsdien behandeld met Lamictal na Genesight-testen) en het verlies van zeven vrienden aan zelfmoord. Ik voer actief campagne tegen transitie, puberteitsremmers en zorg die alleen bevestigt, en ik ben eind 2024 publiekelijk met deze standpunten naar buiten gekomen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up in a small town that has since been gentrified. As a kid I was a nerd on the spectrum — other boys didn't want to play with me, so I made friends almost exclusively with girls and was, in effect, socialized by women. I was quiet, reserved, in tune with my emotions, a good communicator, and generally carried myself in a feminine manner, which led people to assume I was gay. I was bullied mercilessly for being practically the only androgynous goth boy in town — called slurs and beaten up, including having my head dunked in a used toilet. I wasn't allowed to dress goth until I was about 16.
Around 17, I couldn't get a date and had unlimited access to the internet. I developed what I now describe as a porn addiction, and I believe that, combined with the belief that I had 'a literal female brain in a male body (biologically impossible),' led me to identify as trans. I describe that period as overlapping with my goth era; I went by an androgynized version of my birth name (which I call 'N3') and I consider it 'a particularly embarrassing/traumatic part of my life.' I also say my desire to live as a woman was 'a sort of penance for my maleness,' wanting to be an 'honorary woman.' I passed as female when I wore dresses and makeup, and was 'still miserable.' I never did the pronoun thing. I was prescribed my meds after an extensive psychological screening with several tests, all before the affirm-only model became standard, but I desisted before being pushed further — I never medically transitioned. I now describe myself as desisted rather than medically detransitioned.
I got assessed for autism at 30, and 'a lot of things clicked after that.' I also say it recently came to my attention a few years ago that I may be on the spectrum. I have internalized misandry and describe myself as a borderline androphobe — I hate being associated with men. I hated my male body because I associated it with sexual trauma I was subjected to by men when I was a boy; I also disclose childhood sexual trauma and PTSD flashbacks. Counseling helped a little, but what helped most was empowering myself to know I am a man and am not like them.
What moved me toward desistance was studying what I call 'the actual science' — the gamete-based definition of sex, the sociological definition of gender, and research showing there is no such thing as a sexed brain. I say 'empirical atheistic thinking saved me by helping me see trans ideology as a religious belief.' I've been fighting against what I call trans ideology for about 16 years, have done interviews, and have helped other people who desisted or detransitioned.
I am a feminine straight man. I used to be goth rather than emo. I'm now middle-aged — bald, hairy, wrinkled, out of shape, slightly overweight, close to 40 — and I miss being able to have fun with my appearance without people making political assumptions about me. I still have my Bauhaus and Siouxsie albums, my wardrobe is mostly black, my house is decorated with Halloween craft-store items, and I spent $300 on Cure tickets. I got a band tattoo in the 2000s that did not age well. I was named by my older brother (then four) after a famous man who later turned out to be a sex offender/pedophile; I still go by my legal name. I also had a legal last name change not long ago.
I'm married — I've been with my wife almost 14 years, married almost nine — and we have a baby daughter (born around late 2023/2024, since I mention having a kid 6 months ago in a Dec 2023 comment and a daughter thereafter). Before her I dated nothing but tomboys. I told her about my past simply and straightforwardly when we started dating. I work in the mental health industry (at a mental health clinic, and I've also described working for a company with trans-identifying clients where we log birth names and preferred names with pop-up pronoun reminders). I've been prescribed Lamictal after Genesight testing; I tried Prozac before that and it almost pushed me over the edge — I 'almost went through with it.' I've had seven friends commit suicide.
I have been banned from multiple subreddits (r/feminism permanently for linking an article about a trans-identifying male assaulting female inmates; r/kingkillerchronicle for 30 days; r/comics permanently after someone reported my post history as 'terf'). In December 2024 I came out publicly about my views on my socials; I lost a few friends but got over 100 positive interactions. I've posted two well-received 'visual reminder' posts — one for detrans/desisted men and one for women — and a post recommending an interview with detransitioner Ritchie Herron as compulsory viewing before MtF surgery.
I now hold strongly gender-critical views: I argue sex is gamete-based and immutable, gender is a sociological construct, 'no one is actually trans' (only trans-identifying), that trans ideology confuses masculine with male and feminine with female, that AGP in males is largely driven by porn addiction, and that transwomen are externalized misogyny while transmen are internalized misogyny. I'm critical of puberty blockers, SRS, and affirm-only therapy, and supportive of detransitioners and desisters. I advise people to stay off porn, seek non-affirming counselors (CBT/DBT for personality disorders), and practice radical self-acceptance — including a daily mirror exercise of saying 'I love you' until you mean it. I still wear makeup sometimes, like Jane Austen novels and pumpkin spice lattes, and people call me a feminine man.