Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I support trans people and don't like being used as an example of why transitioning is bad. Transitioning isn't for everyone, but I would likely still be trans had testosterone not given me health problems.
I used to be insecure as a woman because masculinity and femaleness felt mutually exclusive, just as a kneejerk reaction. While I was living as a trans man, I felt confident because my masculinity wasn't at odds with my identity. I had to go off testosterone and thus accept being female — it was either learn to be feminine or accept my masculinity. Your feelings are based on anxieties of how others perceive you. Being female is difficult because our capabilities are measured by how they complement male societal roles. The answer is to unlearn biases and become comfortable with your natural self.
I advise cutting off sources of media or reducing time with friends that make you feel insecure in your masculinity, since it will worsen dysphoria and sexist biases and keep you longing to be male. We as masculine women need strong, masculine women to look up to. There are none in my family, so I look to people like the old butches I meet at my local bar, or famous lesbian trainers like Gordy Bravo or Morgan Olsen, who want to look rough and strong and are comfortable in their female masculinity. It's difficult to find young, truly masculine women who don't transition, unfortunately, since this type of camaraderie is important for us. I have had some success meeting them online, and I've been thinking of starting a discord server or something.
I know what it's like to be young and frustrated with not being taken seriously, having body image issues, and a lack of control over your life in general. To many people, transitioning is something to spend energy on — perhaps it feels like there must be a cause for all your suffering. It sucks to go through this. It is normal to be uncomfortable with your body as it changes drastically during puberty, and feeling the need to lose weight is unfortunately common in young women also.
On minors and medical transition: I think we should reinforce laws to prevent minors from accessing HRT without evidence of dysphoria, rather than making it completely inaccessible. Gender nonconformity is not gender dysphoria. Even if it causes dysphoria, feeling the need to be called a boy or 'he him' pronouns, even wanting a male name, is not solid evidence of sex dysphoria when virtually any negative experience can cause someone to want to be the opposite gender. Gender therapists and psychs today affirm clueless children regardless of background because they can get fired or have their licenses taken away for 'gatekeeping' — it's not a good model of assessment for dysphoria. Ideally a child shows discomfort with their gender and is taken to a therapist who assesses their background, any comorbid mental conditions, and works as a talk therapist for months or years instead of saying 'would you like T?' Of course they'll fucking say yes.
I've told people that their backstory isn't unique to trans people — it shares many similarities with butch women growing into their masculinity, and gender nonconforming female experience in general. Even liking a male name and pronouns doesn't mean you're trans necessarily; that's how most all detrans people started out. If you weren't noticeably dysphoric or dissociated from your body simply because you were going through female puberty, there's not really a good way to be sure.
Testosterone made me look like a 15-year-old boy when I was 21. It was impossible from the start, but I wasn't able to accept it until years later. I am off testosterone now because it causes too many health problems and doesn't change half of what causes me dysphoria. Accepting myself as a woman and just embracing my masculinity was the only way.