Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich nu mannelijk kleedt en voor man doorgaat maar zich niet als man identificeert. Ik transitioneerde terwijl ik diep in transideologie zat, gedreven door intense dysforie, trauma en psychische problemen die ik nu denk onder ogen had moeten zien in plaats van er medisch aan te ontsnappen. Sinds mijn detransitie heb ik geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat onder ogen gezien, doe ik therapie en schrijf ik, en mijn seksualiteit is verschoven van op mannen vallen naar bijna uitsluitend op vrouwen vallen. Ik ben kritisch over transitie als eerstelijnsbehandeling, pleit ervoor dat detransitioners zich uitspreken en maak me zorgen over mijn zus die richting een non-binaire identiteit gaat. Ik heb nog steeds een hekel aan mijn vrouwelijke lichaam en stem, maar heb ervoor gekozen mijn trauma aan te pakken in plaats van verdere medische transitie na te streven.
Volledig verhaal
I am female and detransitioned. Looking back, I can see how I got pulled into a trans identity: I was deeply immersed in what I now call trans ideology, and I describe that period as being so far in that anyone who disagreed with me felt like a threat I had to block out. My dysphoria was intense — I described it as a feeling of going mad, where I couldn't think straight from the pain, a tight feeling of anger and helplessness in my chest because I knew being male was something I would never be, yet I felt so strongly I should be. At its worst, I admitted I thought about hurting myself or others just to feel a sense of control or power over something.
What led me there, in my own reading of it, was a mix of things. I believe a lot of what gets called dysphoria in feminine women is really a response to misogyny — cat-calling, aggressive men, dehumanization — and that what many trans men actually want is the social status and respect men get, not a male body. I also think fixation on identity and on one's own body is a direct pipeline: I told a mother that's exactly how it happened for me, and that I didn't want her daughter to end up on testosterone and its health side effects. I've also come to believe my reasons for transitioning were tied to mental health issues and trauma I needed to face rather than escape through medical transition.
Detransition, for me, has been a process of confronting internalized misogyny and doing deep self-exploration. Writing has helped — I find it almost meditative, clearing the mind, and I've wanted to post my writing on the detrans subreddit. Music helped too: the song 'Burn In Heaven' by Dancing Cigarettes, with its eerie lyrics and super feminine voice, gave me a weird sense of empowerment over being a woman and has even made me feel kind of proud to be female in some regard.
I still dress very masculine despite detransitioning, and I consider myself female — my birth sex — but I prefer to look masculine and pass for male. I don't see myself as a man because I know I'm not, but I also don't identify any more with my birth sex than I did when I was trans; I don't like a lot of things about being female, including my body and my voice. I decided I needed to deal with my trauma and other issues instead of trying to escape it through medical transition. I don't have specific dates for when I started or stopped hormones or any surgeries in this record — what I've said is that I detransitioned and that I now deal with the aftermath of that choice.
My sexuality has shifted noticeably. I'm bi. I was really into dudes before and during my transition, but since detransitioning I've been almost exclusively into girls. I think that might be because I've been confronting my internalized misogyny and can now see women in a different light, or maybe it's just deep self-exploration — either way, it's been interesting to find I'm not the only one.
On transition for other people, I'm now quite critical. I believe hormones and surgery should only ever be a last resort for severe cases, after five or six years of therapy trying to find the root cause of dysphoria and building healthy coping skills, and I think the minimum age for hormones should be 25 so the brain is fully developed. I think the trans community and detransitioners can't really get along, because I see trans ideology as built on misogyny and homophobia, and detransitioners as living proof of that, which threatens the whole framework. I've predicted a coming split between LGB and LGBT communities, and I've said it will take a long time — maybe a hundred years — for people to realize how harmful this has been, including how an entire generation of gay kids was nearly sterilized. I've also argued that detransitioners need to stand up and make a bigger deal out of things, maybe even something like a revolution, because there's a huge and growing industry around this.
I've been active in the community, offering to PM and talk with people, advising a mother to find detransitioners or a transmedicalist to talk with her daughter rather than confront her directly as a parent, and telling people considering transition to avoid it, read detrans stories, and go to therapy to check whether their feelings come from trauma or self-destruction. I also support exposing people to many different views rather than censoring platforms, so they can form their own educated opinion.
On a personal level, my sister has been a live worry. She never showed signs of dysphoria, is extremely feminine, and now wants they/them pronouns going into high school. We've reached a mutual understanding, but I'm worried she'll want hormones one day, and seeing her watch the same YouTubers I watched when I was trans gave me shivers. I feel the same anger another commenter described and I feel just as stuck. I also hold strong views on sex-separated spaces for women's safety, and my politics shift constantly depending on the issue — sometimes extremely liberal, sometimes extremely conservative.