Alle verhalen

Vanaf de middelbare school als trans geïdentificeerd, en nooit één dosis genomen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd500
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde butch lesbienne die zich van 2007 (middelbare school) tot in mijn vroege twintigers als trans identificeerde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Mijn dysforie was geworteld in geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, OCD-gerelateerde obsessie en het geloof dat vrouwen minderwaardig waren, en ze vervaagde toen ik mezelf als lesbienne ging accepteren. Ik ervaar nog af en toe milde flitsen van dysforie, maar ik ga dagen of weken zonder. Ik ben kritisch over juridische transitie voor mensen met AGP en over tucute opvattingen van gender, terwijl ik fysieke dysforie steun als legitiem syndroom dat met transitie behandeld kan worden. Ik heb momenteel geen trans-identiteit en blijf deelnemen aan detrans-gemeenschappen.

Volledig verhaal

I first told people I was a boy on Neopets and AOL Kids when I was about 8 or 9 years old, and by fourth grade I was the only student in my class who wrote a main character of the opposite sex. I started identifying as trans in 2007, when I was in middle school, long before the wave of trans awareness around 2015 — at the time I had never even heard of being transgender, and I didn't know anyone else who felt that way. I had a long history of social dysphoria: I frequently said I wanted to be a boy, I thought being a boy was better, and being called a girl or "she" or "her" felt deeply wrong no matter how neutral the sentence was. I was raised by feminists and surrounded by "girl power" media, but I still felt that way. I cried when I realized at 15 or 16 that I would probably never pass as male, because I had finished female puberty and was short even for a girl. I was not abused or molested and went through no trauma before any of this, and I have never been diagnosed with autism, so none of those things explain it. The main reason I never medically transitioned is that in 2008 that would have been unthinkable. I only had something resembling physical dysphoria as a teenager, and I think physical discomfort during and after puberty is completely normal. I think the only reason I didn't develop crippling physical dysphoria is that I'm naturally very thin, androgynous, and flat-chested. I did want a penis and occasionally longed for it so badly that I sort of phantom-felt it, but I don't believe it was real dysphoria. The physical symptoms mostly disappeared when I reached my 20s. I learned to manage my non-physical symptoms by addressing what I now recognize as deeply held internalized misogyny and by accepting myself as a lesbian. I fully believed women were the inferior sex, even though I would never have admitted it — I felt different from and, in many ways, better than other girls, and it was a cope. I still feel the exact same about my gender as I did back then, but now I realize I'm fine the way I am, and that all being a woman means is being a person in a female body. I have OCD and had a trans-related obsession as a teenager; I've also had other obsessions that derailed my life, and I've recommended exposure therapy to others on the sub. I still get flashes of dysphoria, but they're usually short and mild, and I can go days or weeks without experiencing them at all. I identify as a desisted butch lesbian — I never medically transitioned but stopped identifying as trans. I've described myself as a "butch lesbian on the cusp of being a trans man." I've been active in detrans spaces since at least 2019, and I've been open about my views there. I have a friend who detransitioned and identifies as a cuspersomething now after taking testosterone, and another friend who detransitioned but doesn't regret her top surgery at all, about two years out. On the sub I've argued that physical dysphoria is a real syndrome with transition as a recommended treatment, while criticizing "tucute" beliefs as requiring belief in gendered souls. I've been blunt that I don't think people with autogynephilia should transition legally, and that it isn't fair to ask women to accept males with fetishes for being female in women's spaces — though I've said people should be able to dress how they want, call themselves what they want, and take HRT. I've also argued that a female person on testosterone is still female in every cell of their body. I've pushed back on sexist assumptions in questions from others — for example, that shaving, makeup, long hair, girly clothes, and pronouns have nothing to do with actually being female, and that autism can make people feel "othered" in communities they're supposed to belong in. I've been critical of what I see as patriarchal beauty standards and the sexualization of women, and I've said that for me, sexualization and female beauty standards were a factor in my own discomfort, though not AGP. I've expressed sympathy for gay men and masculine-presenting men and argued that society provides few acceptable archetypes for feminine men. I've also said that if you can live your life without lying, that's always preferable.