Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde of desisterende man die jarenlang testosteron heeft gebruikt en ermee is gestopt, waarbij veranderingen in de gezichtsbotten grotendeels blijven maar gezichtsspieren en lichaamsvet naar verwachting richting de uitgangssituatie terugkeren. Ik rouw om de routinematige besnijdenis die ik als baby onderging en probeer vrede te sluiten met wat ik en mijn partners nooit zullen ervaren. Ik ben sterk kritisch geworden over transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen en jongeren, en dring er bij anderen op aan te wachten tot ongeveer 25, geen operatie te laten doen en vrede met zichzelf te vinden via therapie, krachttraining en betrokkenheid bij de gemeenschap. Ik heb mijn eigen redenen om te transitioneren, mijn geestelijke gezondheidsgeschiedenis, of of ik spijt ervaar anders dan het verdriet om de besnijdenis, niet beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and have been on testosterone for a period of years; I came to terms with the consequences of routine infant circumcision in the US, which I describe as something done to me "in the name of good medicine" and something I will "simply never experience" the full effects of, along with what my partners will miss out on. Working through that has been hard — I've said the best anyone can do is learn to live with it, and that trying to be grateful for what I do have left is hard but can be rewarding. I hope to eventually find peace with it.
On hormones and physical changes: I've noted that facial changes are driven primarily by forces exerted onto bone by muscles, notably the tongue and masseters, and that testosterone increases muscle strength, which likely boosted my facial development over the years I was on it. I've said the expansive changes in my bone structure are unlikely to go away, but that my facial muscle volume will likely decline over the next year or so back to baseline. I've also observed that my shoulders probably didn't change much and that's more likely just muscle growth, and that my facial changes should level out as T leaves my system and my body fat percentage increases — indicating I have stopped testosterone at some point. I've framed a wider face as generally a good thing since it widens the airway, with cascading effects on posture, nasal breathing, sleep, snoring, blood oxygen, memory, and stress levels, and I've pointed others toward r/orthotropics for more on facial development.
I've reflected on the permanence and reversibility of transition decisions. I've told others they can always get back on hormones but can't undo their effects, and that if you take a break and decide to start hormones again you can do that without much issue, whereas if you take the drugs and realize it was a bad call, the doctor keeps your money and you're basically screwed. I've strongly cautioned against surgery and hormones for others, saying "Don't get the surgery dawg even you know it's a horrible idea," that "You *will* regret going through with this, and it cannot be walked back," and that "Surgery and hormones are the coward's way out, and it will never be enough." I've also pushed back on the idea of lifelong synthetic hormone dependence, asking whether someone wants to be dependent on synthetic hormones for the rest of their life and warning of hair loss, decreased bone density, and mood swings without regular testosterone. I've advised people to wait until around 25, when they're done growing and hormones have settled, before making permanent decisions, and I've told a 16-year-old flatly: "Do not do this."
I've been blunt with people I see as flip-flopping on hormones or fantasizing about using romantic partners for personal gain, telling them they need professional help and that nobody on the forum can give them what they need. I've also told someone who seemed to think becoming trans would solve their problems to think again, "and maybe once more for good measure," and I've suggested smaller, reversible steps like wearing a pronoun pin in a place like Seattle. I've encouraged strength training, crossfit, eating well, and community volunteer work as alternatives, and I've told people they're perfectly fine the way they are and don't need to change themselves to meet others' expectations or avoid societal roles. I've been skeptical of women transitioning, saying a lot of women want to distance themselves from the bad parts of being a woman only to find that being perceived as a scrawny 5'6 dude isn't an improvement, and I've told one person they have no idea what being a man is like — that what they're describing is societal conditioning, not manhood, and that men also feel powerless, lost, and unheard.
I have not described my own full transition timeline, my reasons for transitioning, my mental health history, my sexuality, my current identity beyond being a detransitioned/desisting male voice in this community, or whether I experience regret beyond the circumcision grief I've written about.