Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die op mijn 14e met testosteron begon, op mijn 16e stopte na ongeveer 1 jaar en 4 maanden, en 17 was ten tijde van deze berichten. Ik geloof niet meer dat mijn gendernonconformistische eigenschappen me man maken, en ik heb radicaal feminisme en gendernonconformiteit omarmd als onderdeel van mijn detransitie. Ik 'voel' me nog steeds niet echt een vrouw en draag herenkleding, draag geen make-up en schoor me niet, maar heb een perspectiefverschuiving gehad in plaats van een verandering in die gevoelens. Mijn grootste spijt en onzekerheden zijn de lichamelijke effecten van testosteron – mijn stem die blijvend jong/mannelijk klinkt, lichaamsbeharing en vooral mijn adamsappel, die mijn grootste onzekerheid is. Vóór de transitie was ik suïcidaal omdat ik geen mannelijke genitaliën had, maar dat geloof heb ik niet meer; ik heb sinds de detransitie geen suïcidale gedachten beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I started testosterone when I was 14, less than two months before my 15th birthday, and was on it for about 1 year and 4 months before stopping at 16. I was 16 when I came off T and had been off it for a couple of months by then. I'm currently 17.
My voice is one of my biggest worries. I had my voice recorded and asked people how it sounded; from what I've seen people generally hear a 'very young semi pre pubescent boy' in it. My fear is that I'll never be able to sound like an adult woman. There's a subtle but important change that happens in the voice going from young girl to adult woman, and I feel like testosterone destroyed that. Even if I feminized my voice, I worry I'd just sound like a young girl rather than a woman, or like a little boy with a slightly deeper voice. I recorded my voice at 14, pre-T, to compare — it was a recording of a recording of a recording. I decided not to voice train right now and just let my voice be how it is and let it develop, hoping things aren't as bad as I think.
I also posted asking whether body hair goes back to normal after stopping T — I was under the impression it would, but wasn't sure whether the hairs themselves actually go away or just lighten.
On the psychological side, a lot of the same feelings I had that led me to transition I still have. I still wear and buy clothes almost exclusively from the men's section. I don't wear makeup or shave. I still don't 'feel' like a woman and don't relate or feel connected to most other teenage girls and women, especially in mannerisms, interests and dress. I sometimes hate being female and wish I was male, mostly for societal reasons. The main thing that has changed, besides no longer taking testosterone and binding, is a perspective shift: I no longer believe any of these things make me, or will ever make me, male, and I now believe that believing so is incredibly reductive and misogynistic. I've gotten into feminism, specifically radical feminism. For me, trying to fit into the expectations of women would be counteractive to my detransition — that mindset is what got me into this whole mess in the first place. Embracing my gender nonconformity has been a really important part of the process.
I'm autistic and more masculine/androgynous in presentation.
As a kid I begged my family to let me shop in the boys section and was elated when they caved and let me get one shirt. I liked being called 'he' and being recognized as a guy. I hated my chest and was suicidal over not having male genitalia. Despite all that I still ended up detransitioning. I've told others in the community that their experience doesn't sound all that different from a lot of butch lesbians, and even a lot of women in general, and that they should ask themselves whether they've internalized false ideas about how women can act, dress and feel — I know I sure did.
I've dealt with insecurity about physical effects of T. I've reassured others (and myself) that having a large clitoris is not as uncommon as people think — plenty of women are born with it or develop it later without having transitioned, and there are communities of women who deliberately enlarge theirs. Every time I feel insecure about an effect from T, I think of women who have it and never went through testosterone; if I wouldn't be mean to them about it, I shouldn't be mean to myself. I've also told someone their clit is not 'deformed.'
My biggest insecurity is my Adam's apple. I'm struggling a lot with it myself — it sometimes doesn't feel real, it's a strange experience. I don't have much advice for others in the same position except to try to ignore it: don't intentionally touch it, don't obsessively look in the mirror or take pictures from different angles. I have a folder saved with pictures of women with visible Adam's apples, and I look at a lot of pictures of Francesca Neri to feel better.
I'm critical of how detransitioners are used politically. I think conservatives are the only ones who bother to platform detransitioners, and the ones shown tend to be feminine, heterosexual and somewhat conservative — which is why I barely take conservatives' faux care for detransitioners seriously. Their homophobia and anti-gender-nonconformity beliefs are exactly the kind of beliefs that cause so many people to transition in the first place. I also pushed back on claims that most people detransition because of transphobia, calling it 'borderline gaslighting' when told that to numerous detransitioners who did not detransition for that reason.