Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die jarenlang worstelde met het niet accepteren van vrouw zijn, gedreven door ongemak met seksualisering, de kritiek van mijn moeder op mijn lichaam en geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat. Ik beschrijf niet dat ik zelf hormonen of operaties heb ondergaan, maar ik waarschuw anderen voor blijvende medische veranderingen en pleit ervoor mannelijkheid te verkennen zonder die. Nu, halverwege de dertig, identificeer ik me als heteroseksuele vrouw en zeg ik dat ik me eindelijk verbonden voel met mijn vrouwelijkheid en zelfverzekerd in mijn vrouwelijke lichaam. Ik ben kritisch over de transbeweging, bespreek autogynefilie openlijk en pleit voor het recht van vrouwen en lesbiennes om over deze kwesties te spreken. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up reading a lot of slash fan fiction, and my entire world of sexual fantasies revolved around men with other men — or, more accurately, boys with boys, because the thought of grown adult men was unappealing to me. I would imagine myself with a male body engaged in gay sex, and it would feel amazing. I now understand that as some form of what they call autoandrophilia — being turned on by thoughts of myself as a man. If I could snap my fingers and have a sexy male body and have hot gay sex, I totally would. Except now I know I wouldn't want to live my entire life as a man.
For a long time I didn't accept that I was female. I didn't enjoy being sexualized as a woman. Attention from men has always made me very uncomfortable. I thought that if I was a man I wouldn't feel so vulnerable, because I would feel equal to other men and sexual attention would feel safe and okay and not a potential threat. Getting catcalls from grown men at 12 years old was scary. I internalized the rampant misogyny in our culture just from growing up in it, and on top of that my mom's criticalness of my female body and her pressuring me to adhere to the restrictive, humiliating, and disempowering standards of femininity our society upholds was a very real and big psychological trauma that I've been recovering from and healing for most of my young adult life. I've described wanting to take hormones and hide behind a male appearance as a perfectly reasonable response to try to deal with all of this — it may help for a time, but you still have to eventually come to terms with being female in this world, and hormones and surgery can leave you with life long health issues.
In my 20s I had a few relationships with some very androgynous men who enjoyed getting into their feminine energy in bed, and I would get to feel like a man. It was incredible, and it was part of learning that I can embody my masculine energy and still be a woman. Going through my process around being a woman and living in the patriarchy took me decades to unravel. Now, in my mid thirties, I finally feel in touch with my womanhood and give thanks and praise for it. Women are amazing. The female body is incredible. I feel strong and confident in myself as a woman now. Lifting weights and building upper body muscles is extremely empowering.
I am neutral now about the hypothetical of having been born male — if I was born a man, cool! But I am a woman and I don't believe anyone is born in the wrong body, so I accept that I am female. Self love has been the hardest thing for me: for so long I wanted to get rid of the parts of myself that I loathed, and I finally realized there is no getting rid of those parts — I can only accept them and love them because they are me.
I identify as a straight woman. I find androgynous men sexually attractive and I love that a man can uniquely define what manly means for himself just by being a man and embodying his feminine aspects. I've said that that allure disappears the moment a man denies his maleness and claims to be something 'other,' and that the ideological aspect of someone identifying as non binary is a total turn off for me. I feel the same way about gender nonconforming women, though I'm not sexually attracted to them.
I have been critical of transition and of the broader trans movement in my public comments. I've pointed out that wanting to explore masculinity without permanent changes made to your body is something I strongly support, and I've warned about the lifelong health issues hormones and surgery can cause. I've also argued that the trans movement is not a grassroots one, linking to articles about Open Society Foundations funding, and I've expressed alarm about what I see as the erasure of women and lesbians and their ability to even talk about it. I've discussed autogynephilia openly, saying that most popular places on the internet will 'straight up shit all over you' if you try to bring it up, and I've argued that AGP combined with BPD or NPD is 'the entire reason people have a problem with trans people.' At the same time I've expressed appreciation for someone with AGP who is 'sane and rational and not afflicted with a debilitating personality disorder.' I've also commented that a parallel between AGP, NPD, and BPD is that they all seem, to some extent, like the person is mentally trapped in adolescence.
I have not described undergoing hormones, surgery, or a formal social transition in any of my posts. I have not described a formal detransition process either — my account reads more as someone who struggled with accepting being female and with sexualization, worked through it over decades, and now identifies as a woman. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or a suicide attempt. I have not described a specific diagnosis of any mental health condition for myself.