Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man, geboren als man, die zich identificeerde als trans en ongeveer 3,5-4 maanden als vrouw op oestrogeen leefde voordat ik besloot te detransitioneren, en ik beschouw mezelf nu als cis man. Ik detransitioneerde vooral omdat ik niet geloofde dat ik echte dysforie ervoer en het nodige twijfelwerk had overgeslagen, niet omdat dysforie terugkwam. Ik heb spijt dat ik niet beter nadacht toen ik op mijn 15e voor het eerst een trans-identiteit aannam terwijl ik depressief was, en ik zou alles geven om die maand opnieuw te beleven. Ik heb nog onopgeloste vragen over of mijn gendergevoelens een ontsnappingsmechanisme waren voor depressie, eenzaamheid en pesten, en ik ben onzeker of ik misschien weer ga transitioneren. Ik woon nog bij transfobe ouders in dagelijkse vecht-of-vluchtstand, heb zintuiglijke problemen die zo ernstig zijn dat ik mezelf wil pijn doen zonder koptelefoon, en kan moeilijk routines volhouden sinds ik terug ben op testosteron.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I am male. I first got depressed at 15 and, from around then, likely became dysphoric — I have no signs of dysphoria before 15, like at all, and years before 15 are still mostly a huge memory hole for me. I ended up getting depressed at 15 and disastrously enough, that's when I decided to read about trans people. I first decided a non-binary label was most accurate, but then without much questioning I decided I'm transfem because almost everything about it felt like a better idea than what was then. My deepest regret comes from this period: I didn't think about it much. I knew my body was changing in a direction I dreaded, and I knew I'd have to fight my parents to even start diagnosing. I ended up fighting for two whole years to even start diagnosing, which took a whole year. I transitioned fundamentally because I didn't care — all of it was "yeah I guess so." I transitioned while living in my transphobic parents' house, who I simultaneously feel deep connection and sadness towards. I'm in daily fight or flight with not much control because of my parents. I did 3.5 months of HRT with mixed results (elsewhere I mention 4 months of E), after which I was passing really well in a way that looked very natural, especially with more masc looks, which is what I'd been going for. I now consider myself a cis guy after thinking a lot about things. I'm detransitioning not out of dysphoria but euphoria. I'm about 3/4 satisfied with the results — my chest looks kinda funny but I have a much prettier face. Breast growth was probably the biggest reason I stopped (if SERMs were studied on MtFs I'd probably be on them and on E still), but I ultimately like what happened, at least most of the time. I'm most afraid of being socially dysphoric about my breasts if I retransition, because I very much don't want anyone but people I'm dating looking there. The longer I'm back on T, the worse I feel with my body. I do feel much happier in sports bras and being referred to in feminine pronouns, and I think HRT reduced my dysphoria. I think my feelings about gender very likely come mostly from a "plastic" place — some sort of mechanism of escape for depression and isolation, not something I was just born with. I can rule out most well-known explanations (classical dysphoria, AGP) for myself. I was bullied a lot as a kid. I had a lifetime of rejection from male social groups — my life peaked preschool, then guys started being more aggressive. I usually preferred the more retreated role in social groups, and there was a brief period when I got into philosophy and economics and would just read while other men did the "fun" stuff, which was the nicest I've felt in groups. I'm an insanely analytic person, and I swear that's more isolating from boys than being very emotional. I went to a football-oriented school and never felt any belonging from masculinity, just fitting in at best, and it made me feel miserable. I never experienced joy from masculinity or need for it before I started passing as a woman. I never said I wanted to be a girl as a kid. I remember feeling weird about stuff like PE being split by gender but it never bothered me significantly. I consider men pretty hot, while I more often feel kinship towards women. I never questioned whether severe loneliness could have contributed as an escape mechanism, and I didn't think about my sexuality a lot either. I severely neglected the questioning phase — I didn't give a fuck about myself so I just did things that gave me some joy without thinking much. The primary reason I've detransitioned is because I didn't believe myself I actually experienced dysphoria, and I didn't do the necessary work when questioning to have peace of mind now that I care about myself more. I spiraled into questioning all my identity. I'm still living with my parents and I want to hurt myself without headphones usually, because my sensory issues around them are so bad. Since deciding to detrans, I've often felt like I'm mimicking emotions rather than feeling them, with no core to my person — like all strong emotions are habits copied from how normal people do them, and there's just a boring sad person underneath. I feel very different inside when I think I'm being considered a woman by others versus a man. I have a best friend (18, half a year younger than me) who is transitioning FtM, probably for far better reasons than I did, and I'm worried because we have a lot in common — he also had zero signs, struggled with depression for a long time, and experienced unwanted touching as a minor. He's planning top surgery in a year and I'd like to talk to him about what I've learned without being paternalistic. I'm in Poland. I've been told by others that I should just not be confident in my identity, get sleep, and journal — journaling helps me, but interpreting emotions is pretty hard. I don't think I struggle to accept being a feminine man. I don't find "MtFt" particularly appealing, just more fitting. I still don't see anything interesting about having a male body, and I very much didn't feel that way on E — I actually cared for it then, now it's hard to keep a single routine again. One of my reasons to detransition was fear that things would begin to look too clean and nice for my liking; one of the more irrational reasons. My face changed on HRT in a very weird way — I started passing quickly but looked like an older person; my face is pretty masculine in structure but the effects of E looked very natural, and I honestly liked that part. I'm not excited for "youthful" parts of femininity. I was more on the "I want to transition and disappear into society" side. I ended up befriending a trans guy from a girls' group; that group fell apart and we stick together now. I don't think I'd get to anyone by considering their chosen pronouns forced. I'm critical of conservative takes on detransition, arguing they enforce gender roles, a healthy rejection of which led some to make unhealthy choices.