Alle verhalen

Geen hormonen, geen operaties — alleen de stereotypen waar ze overheen groeide

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd166
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde of gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit testosteron nam of een operatie had, en ik denk nu dat veel jonge transidentificatie bestaat uit lichaamsongemak in de puberteit, denken in stereotypen en de wens erbij te horen. Ik heb anderen gewaarschuwd tegen medische transitie en operaties, noem transitiegeneeskunde in sommige gevallen ‘medische wanpraktijk’ en dring er bij mensen met enige twijfel op aan niet door te gaan. Ik herken bij mezelf dat ik ooit dacht dat man-zijn er beter uitzag, totdat ik besefte dat ik leunde op genderstereotypen en tussen seksistische mensen verkeerde. Ik heb in deze berichten nooit een formele detransitiegebeurtenis, therapie of diagnose van mezelf beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and, looking back, the first time I said "I'm a boy" was when I was young — it was because I liked skateboarding, martial arts, and video games and just wanted to hang out with guys, because the girls around me were too clicky and weren't into the same things as me. I now see that a lot of what I experienced as a young person was just teens being teens: at that age everyone feels wrong in their body, especially young girls who are constantly on at for being more "lady like" and who have common hobbies like sport and video games gendered at them. I never took testosterone. When I asked other detransitioned females whether facial hair goes away after stopping T or whether laser hair removal is needed, I was asking on behalf of others rather than describing my own treatment. I also never took T but have had a deeper voice, which I've told other girls not to worry about since on the bright side you can hit lower notes while singing. I have experienced something similar to what others describe regarding body/dysmorphia concerns and have reflected on it: I've warned others to look into the stories of life after surgery — infections, pain, total nerve damage, bad smells — and that "the thing with dysmorphia is that you will never be happy, there will always be one thing you want to change and you will try to convince yourself is worth the discomfort when really you're chasing an endless race of social external validation." I've thought a lot about what leads young people toward transition. I believe a lot of young trans issues are just normal adolescent discomfort, and I've attributed some of it to a kind of "cult mentality" — I said that's "why most trans people are autistic, they want to feel like they belong for once." I've also suggested that intense focus on gender identity can be a hyperfixation or special interest, and recommended asking the person to talk about other stuff and explaining that it makes me uncomfortable. I've recognised in myself that I used to think guys "seemed to have it better," until I realised I was leaning on gender stereotypes and hanging around with sexist assholes. I'm supportive of people avoiding unnecessary medical intervention. I was happy for someone who "avoided the medical malpractice and is now happy with your body." I've advised someone with doubts — especially since they liked their penis — not to go through with it, telling them they have an unrealistic fantasy of what being a girl is, that they can still crossdress if it's just flowery outfits they want, and that they can still be a hands-on dad and do everything but breastfeed. I've also told someone considering surgery that you can be a man and like "girly" things, like women's clothes, and date whoever you want — "The only thing that makes you a 'cis man' is your biology, everything else is just you no matter what gender." I've commented supportively on others' appearance and progress, and I've expressed frustration at rules that don't allow for people reverting to what they actually are. I don't describe undergoing hormones or surgeries myself, and I don't describe a formal detransition event, therapy, diagnosis, or mental-health crisis of my own in these posts.