Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw in de vijftig die op r/detrans kwam als bondgenoot en niet als iemand die zelf getransitioneerd is. Ik ben fel kritisch over medische transitie, therapeuten die meegaande brieven schrijven, puberteitsremmers en wat ik zie als een sektarische beweging die kwetsbare gendernonconforme jongeren viseert. Ik adviseer dysforische en detransitionerende mensen hun lichaam heel te houden en hun zelfexpressie volledig te steunen via kleding, haar en persoonlijkheid. Ik heb een sterk spiritueel kader en geloof dat het lichaam de tempel van de Heilige Geest is, en ik pleit voor therapie, dagboekschrijven, gemeenschap in de echte wereld en zelfacceptatie. Ik heb een zoon en een dochter, en ik haal vaak de tomboykindertijd van mijn dochter aan als voorbeeld van iemand die zonder medische ingreep uit genderverwarring groeide.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned woman in my 50s who came to this community as an ally and supporter rather than as someone who transitioned myself. I grew up in the 1970s and studied psychology in the 1980s, and I have a son and a daughter. I have been an active, vocal participant in r/detrans throughout 2019 and into 2020, offering advice, encouragement, and blunt critique of medical transition to dysphoric and detransitioning people.
I never transitioned, but I have strong convictions about why transition is harmful. I describe myself as 'just a bystander watching this train wreck called Trans.' I believe the trans movement targets 'fertile soil' — lonely, depressed, gender-nonconforming young people longing to feel at home — and that young teens are especially vulnerable because that is 'the age of confusion anyway.' I compare the movement to a cult and a religion, and I describe doctors and pharmaceutical companies as charlatans who promise 'Give me tens of thousands of dollars and I will turn you in to a woman,' which I say is simply not possible.
I am deeply critical of therapists who write letters enabling surgery. In a long exchange I argued that a therapist who knowingly put inaccuracies in a surgical letter 'acted in bad faith, cut corners, mislead,' and that the therapist bears responsibility because 'They signed their name, their professional recommendation made the difference between a surgery or no surgery.' I compared it to a therapist giving a suicidal client a gun or a doctor prescribing oxy to a patient threatening suicide. I am also critical of puberty blockers, arguing they stop normal puberty, deprive adolescents of bone density and key sex hormones for brain maturation, and prevent informed decision-making 'with a brain that has been stopped from maturing.'
I frequently counsel young people not to take hormones or have surgery while affirming their freedom of expression: 'Dress how you want and cut your hair however, but please do not supplement with dangerous hormones, or remove perfectly healthy body parts!' I have urged people considering top surgery to 'keep your body whole,' noting 'No take-backs, no Edit - Undo in the case of top surgery.' I support detrans women getting electrolysis or a tracheal shave covered by insurance 'because you were misled about transition in the first place.'
I have a strong spiritual framework. I believe 'the body is the Temple of the Holy Spirit' and that we are 'spiritual beings having an Earthly experience' who 'had to grow a meat suit to be hue-man.' I frequently use religious language ('God bless you,' 'Godspeed,' 'Let your Spirit shine'). I am also drawn to the Human Givens approach to therapy, which I say sounds like 'exactly the method to help dysphoric people.'
I have been supportive of parents of gender-questioning children, defending a mother who vented about her daughter's social scene, saying 'I'd be scared shitless if my daughter was that age and caught up in this mania.' I have shared that my own daughter was a major tomboy who hated pink and dresses, chummed around with guys, and would have 'jumped on board the train' if transitioning had been an option at her awkward puberty stage; she is now 'a vivacious and driven young woman' and 'a creative and driven career woman.' I have also counseled parents that they are relieved when their child detransitions and that they should not blame themselves.
I have been combative with trans posters who come into r/detrans, telling one 'you do, deep down, know the truth, or you wouldn't be so demanding that other people support your delusion,' and accusing them of 'male entitlement.' I have also been warm and pastoral with suicidal or grieving posters, urging one to 'Please stay with us' and another to seek a therapist for grief after a loss. I have recommended the Kelsey Coalition and celebrated media coverage linking to this subreddit. I have been banned from a trans subreddit and told someone else they were 'better off where you can freely say what you feel anyway.' I have criticized a poster who created a subreddit excluding radfems as 'divisive, and exclusionary.'
I have recommended meditation, yoga, journaling, dream work, hobby groups, real-world socializing over internet immersion, and therapy for childhood trauma. I have been open about my own personality — I say I've been accused of seeing the world through 'rose-colored glasses' by my sister, and I like 'seeing the glass half full.' I enjoy my hair, nose, eyes, and my body's freakish flexibility. I have been told I write with a powerful, raw, honest voice and have been encouraged to journal and possibly publish.