Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd/gedesisteerd persoon die zich op dit moment identificeert als non-binair en uit is bij vrienden en op de universiteit. Ik kwam tot deze identiteit na experimenteren met namen en voornaamwoorden op advies van een vriend, en ik ben bewust langzaam gegaan met medische stappen, waaronder overwegen maar niet beginnen met hormonen om mijn stem te verlagen. Ik had te maken met depressie en suïcidale gedachten, kreeg SSRI's van een psychiater voorgeschreven, en ik pleit sterk dat mensen in crisis professionele hulp zoeken. Ik steun transitie voor wie die nodig heeft, maar ben kritisch over het duwen van jongeren richting medische transitie, en ik heb gendercritische opvattingen 'eigenlijk transfobie' genoemd. Ik zit in therapie of zoek die om mogelijke geïnternaliseerde misogynie en gegenderd misbruik uit mijn verleden te verwerken.
Volledig verhaal
I want to start by saying I'm non-binary — that's the label I openly identify with now, and it suits me. I was assigned female at birth, and I've spent a lot of time over the past year or so figuring out what that means for me.
My journey toward understanding my gender wasn't linear. For a long time I wasn't sure if I was "really" trans. What changed things was a friend telling me I should just do the things that make me happy — find a new name, experiment with pronouns — and that it didn't really matter whether I was "really" something. That advice took a huge weight off my shoulders. I realized it's okay to try things out and then change your label if it doesn't fit.
I'm out to all my friends and everybody at my university, and it feels great. I've thought about some medical procedures, but I'm not sure if I want them, so I've decided to give myself time — if I still want them in a few years, I'll try to get them. I've been careful about irreversible steps: coming out to friends, meeting other trans people, talking with my parents when I felt I could trust them, going to a support group, talking with a psychologist, comparing my experience with other trans people, and wearing a binder (I remind others to do it healthily — take breaks, stretch, buy a proper one, don't wear it more than a few hours a day).
I've thought a lot about whether rejecting womanhood is connected to internalized misogyny and gendered abuse I've experienced. I used to be really ashamed of traits associated with femininity — like sensitivity — when I was younger, but I think I'm mostly over that now; I've learned to love those attributes, including liking cute things in pastel colors. Even if my identity is partly a way of coping with internalized misogyny, I don't think I'm hurting anyone — I support my female friends, I read feminist theory, and I'm not acting in a sexist way. I've said that patriarchy and capitalism are bad for almost everyone and everyone needs a way to navigate that, so as long as you're not hurting anybody, do whatever makes you feel less miserable.
I was in the process of getting into therapy around April 2020, hoping to process any issues I might have with womanhood with a professional — and then, if I didn't need my non-binary identity anymore, I could just ditch it.
On mental health: I've dealt with depression and suicidal thoughts myself. In April 2020 I told someone that I knew what it was like to not be able to get out of bed and to hate yourself more and more, because I'd been through it and was recovering with SSRIs prescribed by my psychiatrist. I also mentioned that I was supposed to have seen my psychiatrist two weeks earlier but couldn't because I had to leave the city I study in (this was during the pandemic). I strongly believe people dealing with suicidal ideation should talk to a psychiatrist or therapist — I told someone directly, "You are suicidal. You have an illness. If you want to get better and LIVE, you need help." I also acknowledged that I myself hadn't been perfect about keeping appointments.
I've also shared that some of my dreams aren't gendered at all, and in some of them people refer to me with a gender different from the one I was assigned at birth.
On the question of transition and access: I've argued that there are people genuinely damaged by dysphoria for whom transition is the help they need, and I don't think restricting access drastically is the right solution. I'd rather see a society that encourages young people to explore their gender identities without pushing them toward medical transition. I've said transition wasn't right for some of us, but that doesn't mean there aren't people who need it, and I've said we need more detrans voices in the trans community. I've also pushed back against the idea that hormones are toxic, pointing out that HRT is mostly used by cis women after menopause and asking whether people think contraception is toxic too. When someone called altering your body insane, I compared it to things cis people do all the time — piercings, vasectomies, tattoos, cosmetic surgeries — and said I just wanted to slightly lower my voice with hormones.
I've been critical of gender-critical positions, calling them "basically transphobia." At the same time, I've defended this subreddit as a place specifically for people who detransition or are considering it, explaining that its negativity toward transition is a function of who it's for, not proof that transition is good or bad — it's "a right way for some people and wrong for others."
I've also expressed frustration with the community itself: in June 2020 I wrote, "I wish this sub was nice and informative."
Overall, my position is that self-discovery is okay, getting lost along the way is okay, and no one else can tell you whether you're trans — only you can. If my label ever changes, that's fine; I'll just come out again.