Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw die nooit testosteron nam, maar dagelijks genderdysforie en innerlijk conflict had, en koos te desisteren omdat als man bevestigd worden voor mij minder belangrijk was dan andere dingen in het leven. Ik geloof dat mijn PCOS-gerelateerde verhoogde testosteron bijdroeg aan mijn dysforie en queerheid, wat verbeterde toen mijn hormonen genormaliseerd waren, en later werd ik zonder hulp zwanger en beviel ik van een gezond kind. Ik had toen ik jonger was vaak suïcidale gedachten, die met de leeftijd vervaagden, en ik blijf sceptisch over de onderzoeksbasis die wordt gebruikt om transitiegeneeskunde te rechtvaardigen, vooral rond zelfmoordstatistieken en sterilisatie van minderjarigen. Ik identificeer me als queer vrouw, getrouwd met een man, en ik ben kritisch over genderbevestiging, over bepaalde bekende transfiguren en over medische transitie voor mensen wier enige motivatie een seksuele fantasie is, zoals autofallofilie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up as a neuro-atypical, shy kid — what I called an "ugly duckling" — with essentially no male attention. Around ten years ago (so roughly my teens or early twenties, around 2013), I was taught, and took at face value, the idea that trans people need to be transitioned or they generally kill themselves. I had very frequent suicidal ideation when I was younger and was, at one point, 99% convinced I would kill myself when I was younger.
I have PCOS, which raises androgens (testosterone) naturally. I believe it actually contributed to my gender dysphoria. My main symptom was rarely getting my period. When I was told I would have trouble having children, I felt broken as a woman, and given my other developmental issues I suspected something was deeply wrong with me — I even suspected a chromosomal issue like mosaic Turner syndrome. I had a very feminine figure which I hated, in part because I hated being sexualised; I went from zero male attention to a lot of it, and guys would stare at and harass me, and would ask for casual sex before even getting to know a woman. At a party I once hit a guy in the face for asking me for casual sex, which felt like a normal reaction given my upbringing.
I identified as lesbian at one point. I saw the link between lesbianism and PCOS early on: when my PCOS is not being treated, I get more attraction to women, a higher sex drive, and less attraction to men. I have been with women as a "lesbian" — it was somewhat arousing but felt weird, and I don't like people touching my genitals due to dysphoria. I don't consider myself a lesbian; I'd say I have gender issues more than being lesbian. I described a fantasy I called "autophallophilia": my ultimate fantasy is to actually feel a vagina around a penis, seeing the girl naked while doing it. I'd love to try a strap-on but I'm already married to a man. I didn't try one before because I was against toys when I dated women and found it intimidating, and I don't think a toy could compare to an actual penis.
Despite that fantasy, I didn't feel transitioning would be worth it — I'd need full phalloplasty to get the result I wanted, which is very risky, and even then I'd be a really short dude since I'm short. My advice to others in that position is: don't transition if this is the only reason, because it's very risky and likely to lead to huge complications and it's very hard to get functional genitals.
I desisted. I never took testosterone. I explicitly said: "I desisted because being validated as a male was less important to me than other things in life. That doesn't mean I don't have internal conflict and dysphoria daily." So I still experience daily dysphoria and internal conflict, but being seen as male is not a priority for me compared to other things.
My gender dysphoria and even overall queerness did seem to reduce when I got my hormone levels back to normal through PCOS treatment. I later got pregnant unassisted and was in shock — I could hardly believe my body was functioning normally as a woman capable of bearing life. It was the first time I felt like a "normal woman." I recently gave birth to a very healthy child, and my AMH test showed my eggs were not "fried" (high AMH).
On the research side, I asked whether there are studies on actual suicide rates rather than attempts or ideation, and I couldn't find them — only anecdotal ones, which were people who were affirmed. I found one study reporting 0.8% of trans women and 0.25% of trans men in the sample died by suicide: higher than average but not matching the hysteria and huge taxpayer expenditure, and it doesn't conclude that transitioning prevents suicide. I'm sceptical of self-report measures of "suicide attempt" and think they shouldn't inform care involving risky, experimental medical procedures and permanent sterilisation. I think sterilisation of an underage person is a huge side effect that for any other condition would be a last resort, and that sterilisation may not affect someone's mental health when young but can have a huge impact later and even lead to suicidality. I predicted that in 10–20 years doctors will have major regrets when sterilised kids realise what happened. I also think trans men will suffer most, since they're generally more family-oriented, and that continuing testosterone can cause reproductive organ side effects severe enough to require hysterectomy.
I'm critical of how gender dysphoria is treated: I don't really believe in gender affirmation outside very rare examples, which I think should be privately funded rather than taxpayer funded, though I accept gender dysphoria as a psychopathology. I don't consider people with slight discomfort around gender roles trans. I don't believe Dylan Mulvaney is trans and think people can fake being trans for clout, and that validating such people damages the queer community. I think endocrinologists signing off on this is scarier than anything else, since they're supposed to be PCOS specialists. I've learned more about hormones from detrans YouTubers who read medical journals than from actual doctors. I also believe gender politics gets disproportionate focus partly so governments can distract from other issues.
On relationships: I'm a queer woman married to a man. I've advised someone dating a practising Muslim that a practising Muslim can't date, only court with intent to marry, and would likely want conversion; if not practising, religion wouldn't factor much. I've also advised that the dating pool shrinks in the late 20s and onward, that many queer women end up with men for reproductive reasons, and that I was mostly attracted to straight women and non-obviously-queer women, so I wouldn't have found someone in the remaining queer-identified pool.