Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die mijn eigen tijdlijn niet heeft gepost, maar van eind 2019 tot en met 2020 anderen heb aangeraden transitie uit te stellen, niet-affirmerende therapie (CGT/DGT) te zoeken en detrans-verhalen te lezen. Ik ben kritisch over het gender-affirmerende medische model, big pharma en de invloed van sociale media, en zie zelfacceptatie en het doorwerken van onderliggende problemen als prioriteit. In dit transcript heb ik geen specifieke leeftijden, medische ingrepen of operatiegeschiedenis gedeeld. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have never written out my own transition or detransition story in a post here — I've mostly shown up in comments, offering advice and support to others, and through those replies a picture of where I stand has emerged.
I came to these communities around late 2019. Early on I was mostly cheering other people on: I told one person I was "so very happy" for them and hoped they'd "continue on a path of self acceptance and self love" and find healthy people to support them. That framing — self-acceptance as the goal rather than transition — has been my consistent position ever since.
By December 2019 I was giving detailed advice to a parent whose daughter wanted to start testosterone. I recommended having her read detrans stories from people with regrets, and finding butch lesbians who could guide her "that aren't all hopped up on gender theory." I urged waiting, because "what T does, and surgeries, are irreversible," and I warned about social media pushing transition "as a quick fix to escape their other struggles," leaving people "stuck on dangerous hormones for life with no way to put their bodies back to how they could have been." My line was: "There's no harm in waiting, but plenty of harm in rushing." I also told them to find a good mental health team, "not one that goes to gender affirming the second a struggling kid asks for hormones."
That advice recurred. In late December 2019 I told someone else to find a psychotherapist "that doesn't run to gender affirming first chance they get" and to make it known they wanted to work on self-acceptance, not transitioning — adding, "I'm so sorry the system failed you." In February 2020 I recommended therapists outside the gender identity clinic who don't practice the affirmation-only model, a couple of years of intensive psychotherapy, and specifically CBT and DBT. I said I saw "red flags" in their situation and advised delaying major decisions. I also suggested sliding-scale clinics, Buddhist-style mindfulness, and radical acceptance, saying I'd "seen it make a major difference in patients who put the time and work in" — phrasing that suggests I have some clinical or clinical-adjacent exposure, though I haven't stated a profession.
My critique is not only medical. In January 2020 I thanked someone for "realizing the colonization of womanhood," saying it was something "I wish more people would take the time to try to conceptualize to see what it's like from a woman's perspective." That, plus my references to womanhood and to the system failing me, indicates I am a detransitioned woman. In November 2019 I'd also expressed suspicion about financial motives: "Really curious how much big pharma is raking in from all of this."
In July 2020 I admitted I "can't help you with the detrans stuff" directly in one thread, but again pushed DBT for coping, mindfulness and acceptance, calling it "life changing once you master it." Around the same time I was reading up on Dr. Money, calling him "the architect of our current nightmare" and predicting that the current approach to gender medicine will eventually be discredited "like that, but on a much grander scale."
I haven't posted my own timeline — ages, hormones, surgeries, or the details of my detransition — so I can't fill those in. What I have made public is my stance: I regret the direction the gender-affirming system takes, I believe in waiting and in deep psychotherapy over affirmation, I identify with womanhood and with critiques of how it's being redefined, and I'm skeptical of both the medical and ideological machinery behind rapid transition. I try to be a supportive voice for people trying to detransition or desist, while being honest that I don't have all the answers myself.