Alle verhalen

Een zakkende stem en de theorie erachter

Man · Gedetransitioneerd144
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gedesisteerde man die zich als AGP (autogynefiel) identificeert en zich vroeger als trans identificeerde. Ik kwam tot desisteren in mijn vroege twintiger jaren, rond 2019-2020, en ik ben kritisch over wat ik de sekteachtige aspecten van transgenderideologie noem. Ik geloof dat mijn autogynefilie relaties met vrouwen onverenigbaar liet voelen en dat eraan toegeven psychologisch ongezond is, dus ik heb geprobeerd een 'vanille' seksualiteit aan te houden. Ik denk dat veel van wat dysforie wordt genoemd eigenlijk een verzamelnaam is voor algemene ongelukkigheid, en dat de meeste mensen die transitie overwegen andere verklaringen voor hun lijden zouden moeten zoeken. Ik heb enige ervaring met de effecten van testosteron, met name een geleidelijk dieper wordende stem.

Volledig verhaal

I have identified as AGP (autogynephilic), formerly trans-identifying, and now desisted. I described myself as considering 'himself AGP, former trans identifying, now desisted.' I am in my early twenties as of early 2020, and I've noted that my own voice has slowly been getting deeper over the last several years. On my sexuality: I posted in January 2020 that I was at a point in life where I would like to have a girlfriend, but that my sexuality is 'very agp' and I thought it was incompatible with most women. I said I was really insecure about it and had begun to hate that part of myself, and asked if anyone had similar fears and then had success. In follow-up comments I said only 'a small percentage' of people had success, and that it's 'not something i'd like to base a relationship around' — in fact I thought it was 'probably psychologically unhealthy to indulge. vanilla is best, it's more natural.' I also compared maintaining vanilla sex fantasies to sobriety. I described AGP as 'a fetish that makes otherwise, straight-seeming men, crossdress and do really gay things. but it's not gay.' I said I'm 'fairly masculine actually' and that 'agp isn't actually that related with feminine personality traits.' I have been critical of transgender ideology. In October 2019 I described a Discord server as 'full of a bunch of narcissistic turds' and said that when I mentioned how I thought there were cultish aspects to transgender ideology, five people joined the channel and ganged up on me and eventually got me banned. I've argued against appeals to authority in these debates, saying you 'can't just link to authority to convince any thinking person' and that an ideology 'should be able to argue its merits on it's own.' I have some familiarity with the medical side of transition, particularly voice changes on testosterone. I warned someone that voice deepening can be 'a pretty rapid change' but then edited to say that looking back it was 'very few people that happened too' and most guys took a long time for their voices to get deeper. I noted 'me personally my voice has slowly been getting deeper over the last several years and i'm in my early twenties,' suggesting I have some personal experience with testosterone's effects. I reassured a detransitioning woman that even with testosterone 'you are still a woman' and that she didn't sound male. On detransition and desistance generally, I asked in July 2020, 'What about someone like me who considers himself AGP, former trans identifying, now desisted?' I believe people are 'much more malleable than they seem' and that a large portion of both sexes could learn to occupy the opposite role if socially sanctioned. I said I can't prohibit anything for people who truly experience debilitating gender dysphoria because I can't be certain what the truth of gender and sexual differences are, and that 'science and philosophy has really let us all down here.' I think there are real measurable average differences between men and women in temperament and psychology, but that a lot of what is called 'dysphoria' is really just a catch-all for general unhappiness with life. I think many, perhaps nowadays most, should not transition and should seek alternate ways and alternate explanations for their suffering. I've been involved in gender-critical (gc) communities and observed their internal politics — I recalled a schism or coup, mod purges, and a head mod who was 'just a narcissist who slowly banned all the more reasonable radfems.' I also speculated about moderators banning detrans communities and the likely backlash. I tend toward a philosophical, somewhat pessimistic worldview. I told someone not to blame themselves because 'everyone is brainwashed, we live in a highly indoctrinated world' and that 'everyone is sick, it's a side effect of a cruel culture.' I described a spectrum from 'complete ignorance narcissism and a life ruled by superstition, all the way to complete enlightenment' and said we aren't 'churning out Buddha candidates in large numbers here in the west.' I urged self-compassion, saying 'we are mostly products of our environment' and that if you are to blame anyone, blame the world. I related to having one's understanding of the world pulled out from under you.