Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde biseksuele vrouw die 12 jaar als transjongen leefde maar nooit testosteron nam, en ik leef nu als gendernonconformistische vrouw zonder labels. Mijn pad richting transitie werd gevormd door genderongemak in mijn kindertijd, grooming door een oudere transvrouw op mijn 17e en misbruik door transvrouwen-partners, samen met een trans-gemeenschap die ik oppervlakkig en niet-ondersteunend vond. Ik verliet de trans-gemeenschap omdat de nadruk op uiterlijk, voornaamwoorden en slogans mijn dysforie triggerde en losstond van de fysieke werkelijkheid. Ik ben dankbaar dat ik nooit hormonen nam of een operatie had, al heb ik aanhoudende gezondheidsproblemen waaronder rugpijn en ademhalingsproblemen. Ik pleit nu voor ruimtes alleen voor LGB en ben kritisch over transitie bij kinderen, puberteitsremmers en reguliere trans-activisme.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I had a childhood phase where I hated skirts, hated girls, and wanted to be a boy because boys seemed 'cooler' and 'better,' but it never got to the point of 'I am a boy.' I got more comfortable with my sex as I got older, until I learned about the whole trans thing and had to seriously consider transition as a real option — for me, having the option actually made my dysphoria worse. I came out to my ex-boyfriend's mom many years ago, telling her 'I'm more like a boy on the inside,' and she replied by gesturing to her body and saying 'I'm a woman because I'm female. It doesn't mean anything else.' I had no comeback at the time, and I now look back on those words as a pearl of wisdom.
I lived as a trans guy for 12 years. I passed decently well even without testosterone, and I'm now really thankful I never took T, because I'm living as a woman and that probably would have been impossible if my voice had dropped or I'd grown a full beard. My health is already precarious, so I'm sure I'd have had atrophy, acne, and panic attacks on T, plus the difficulty of navigating dating. I also tried binding when I was trans but found it way too painful — I have back pain and respiratory problems to begin with, so I instantly knew how much it would hurt my body, which is why I now worry about young people being pushed to 'just try binding.'
I made a ton of friends in the trans community very quickly, but they were fake friends — they overwhelmingly only wanted to sleep with me or thought associating with me made them look cooler. When I broke up with my abusive ex, they were all gone in a flash, because even though he was abusive, he was a 'kinky poly transgirl' with more social capital than I had as someone moving in a 'vanilla monogamous desisting direction.'
I was also groomed by a 40-year-old transwoman when I was 17; she solicited underage nudes from me, and 'it all went downhill from there.' I was abused and raped by one transwoman ex, and then a second, and I observed how these transwoman rapists and pedophiles abuse others. Recently I found a site for people who experienced this kind of violence in the trans community, which was a big relief — evidence that I'm not crazy and not just unlucky, and that this is an epidemic. I planned to submit my story once I finished writing it out.
Since I stopped identifying as trans, I've become more and more uncomfortable with mainstream LGBT subreddits — it triggers my dysphoria to see everything focusing on pronouns and timelines 24/7. I've found it extremely important to get outside the trans bubble. I feel a lot better since I left the labels behind and just started living as a female. I don't tell, I show. I'm still 'technically non-binary (although most people technically are)' but I only mention that in rare contexts online. I now live as a 'bisexual tomboy weirdo' — my hair is long, I never wear makeup or women's shoes, I wear women's jeans and men's t-shirts, I shave my legs and armpits sometimes, and I like crochet, gardening, and being handy with computers. I'm not as sensitive to society's perceptions anymore; I find it fun to blow people's minds by defying their assumptions.
The pronouns question makes me extremely dysphoric — it suggests I even have the option of choosing pronouns. Everyone calls me 'she' because I put some effort into passing as female to save people awkwardness, but I'd rather be called anything than be asked to interrogate my feelings. I've spent 12 years living as a trans guy trying to control what people thought about me, and I'm done with it.
I'm critical of mainstream trans activism: I think the trans community has appropriated narratives of others (hate crime rates of black and latino gender non-conforming gay men, intersex people's lives, the concept of misogyny), and that travestis in Brazil are gender non-conforming males who don't identify as trans but whose murder rates are used as a cudgel. I think gender identity discourse has become indecipherable nonsense detached from physical reality. I support gay people and everyone's right to marry, vote, have health care, education, job security and a livable wage, but I don't see how that relates to giving drugs to kids or biological males playing women's sports. As a detrans bisexual woman, I hate that we're not allowed to discuss the nuance of trans issues without having accounts deleted. I've advocated for LGB-only spaces, promoting r/LesBiGay as a subreddit free of trans posts so it can't be banned for transphobia. I believe severe childhood dysphoria can fade or be coped with in other ways, and that there's no test that says 'you are a Real Trans.'