Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben geboren als vrouw, identificeerde me als trans, leefde als man en detransitioneerde om als butch lesbische vrouw te leven. Ik had ernstige dysforie en was 100% zeker dat ik nooit zou detransitioneren, maar toch deed ik dat nadat ik ongeveer 17 maanden een lage dosis testosteron had gebruikt. Stoppen met herkauwen van dysforische gedachten, plus tijd in lesbische en vrouwenruimtes, verminderde mijn dysforie van ernstig en levensbeperkend naar een incidentele ergernis. Ik pleit nu sterk tegen transitie als je twijfelt, en ik heb een video gemaakt over mijn redenen voor transitie en detransitie. Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich identificeert als butch lesbienne.
Volledig verhaal
I made a video about my reasons for transition and detransition in March 2020, and I mentioned that I'd been active on this subreddit under a different username before creating a fresh account for that post. I've described myself as having been about as 'True Trans' as you can get — I had horrible dysphoria, and my gender identity was the one part of myself I never doubted. I was 100% certain I would never detransition, ever, until I detransitioned.
I'm a butch lesbian and a detransitioned woman. I've said that a lot of women, particularly butch lesbians like me, have dysphoria, and that there aren't many resources on recovering from it. Over the last couple of years I've made great strides: my dysphoria has gone from being severe and life-limiting to just an occasional annoyance. Crucially, the thing that helped me most was not transitioning. Whenever I wore my binder or worried about pronouns or how people were seeing me, I reinforced my dysphoric thoughts and made them worse — like other mental disorders, ruminating on the thoughts and doing what they say is a great way to make them worse.
I also used to think I had nothing that could have led me to develop dysphoria, that it was just part of my brain. Only after I stopped ruminating on my dysphoric thoughts could I see the various factors that influenced their development. One factor I identified was feeling like my body existed for men — that feeling was one of the reasons I developed dysphoria in the first place. I noted that transition did help me get away from certain parts of patriarchy, since I transitioned enough to pass as 'male enough' that men don't hit on me anymore.
On medical details: I was on testosterone — on a pretty low dose though — for about 17 months, and I stopped about a year before I wrote that in March 2020. On my voice, I told someone that their voice will stay lower than it was originally but will probably go up a little bit naturally, and that voice training can help if it's a huge bother. I said I like having a deeper voice than before, but I'm pretty sure it's raised a bit since stopping T. I also asked someone else how long they'd been off T, noting that changes in hormones can mess things up.
On coming out as detransitioned, I acknowledged it's uncomfortable admitting you were wrong about something that seemed so big and important at the time, but I said that since we're young, not many people will hold dumb teenage decisions against us. I suggested coming out about detransition the same way you did for being trans — you've learned new things about yourself and that's taking you in a different direction. It can be awkward but you can't move on without ripping off the bandaid eventually.
What has helped me most is seeking out lesbian and female-only spaces. Even though it was only for short periods, my visit to a women's land and a lesbian camp helped my dysphoria a lot and made me realize that being female is more than whatever men want from me. From those experiences I even managed to feel a sense of pride about being female — which, as a woman who has experienced dysphoria, can seem impossible. I also come back to the reason I decided to detransition: in a lot of ways it would be an easier life to live as a man, but before I get stuck in those thought cycles I remind myself why I'm not doing that. For me it's the thought of little girls like I once was, and the hope that I can help at least one realize that being a woman can be more than just men and makeup.
I've advised people who are having enough doubts to post on the detrans subreddit not to transition for a good few years until they've figured themselves out much better. I've told people that if they're at all concerned they're going to change their mind, they shouldn't do it — I was 100% convinced I was trans forever with no doubts at all, and I still ended up detransitioning. I've also said that doesn't mean you have to wear 'girl clothes' and be feminine.
I'm not attracted to males, and I noted that I realize how much harder detransition would be if I couldn't call myself a lesbian/butch. I mentioned Carey Callahan as a straight detrans woman whose YouTube channel and Twitter are gone, and said I don't know many other resources for straight detrans women. I'm friends with another detrans woman in New Zealand and also a desister, and I think most of us stay pretty quiet. I offered to share a link to a Discord for detrans women. I'm goth — I wore a Sisters of Mercy t-shirt — and I'm trying to reconstruct the ancient Egyptian religion, which is why I wear an Eye of Horus necklace. I know a little German. I've also commented on things like men's long hair tending to be greasier, and affirmed someone's appearance as definitely male.