Alle verhalen

Zes ex-vriendinnen transitioneerden, zij bleef

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd154
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een 54-jarige butch lesbienne die eind jaren 1970 als tiener in Los Angeles uit de kast kwam en 15 jaar werkte op het Michigan Womyn’s Festival, wat volgens mij mijn leven heeft gered en me heeft geholpen mijn lichaam te accepteren. Ik ben zelf nooit getransitioneerd, maar zes van mijn ex-vriendinnen en veel vrienden wel, en ik schreef op Reddit dat ik de butch-dykegemeenschap mis waarin ik ben opgegroeid. Ik identificeer me als een lesbienne van de oude stempel die alleen valt op butch womyn die als womyn geboren zijn, en ik heb kritische opvattingen over de huidige genderpolitiek, terwijl ik benadruk dat iedereen het recht heeft om te bestaan. Een groot deel van mijn activiteit bestond uit het adviseren en aanmoedigen van detransitioners en twijfelende jongeren, waarbij ik detransitie zie als de „frontlinie” van een beweging. Ik blijf een stem uit de gemeenschap die tegen detransitie aan zit, in plaats van zelf detransitioner te zijn, en ik pleit voor zelfacceptatie, zelfvertrouwen en het aparte bestaan van lesbiennes.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a level 54 butch dyke — I came out in the late 70s as a teenager in Los Angeles, when there were no role models except Kristy McNichol. I cut the sleeves off my shirts, wore tan work boots and Levi's, and had to fight for the right to dress that way: one job told me I couldn't wear the boots, another required me to wear a dress at least once a week, and I was laid off for being gay and later rehired when the person who fired me was let go. I always understood myself as paving the way — 'If I cant wear tan work boots, no girl can. So I will until all girls can.' I found my lesbianism in part through the Michigan Womyn's Festival. I started going as a baby dyke and worked there for 15 years. Those two weeks a year, surrounded by womyn of every body shape, were a kind of therapy that doesn't exist anymore: my body issues mostly disappeared in that setting, and over time that accumulated into confidence. The loss of Michigan was, for me, much more than the loss of a festival — it was a kind of therapy that kept me on this earth, and in many ways saved me. I've always been drawn to butch dykes and it's never been easy finding girlfriends, though I've had quite a few over the years. Six of my exes have transitioned (FTM), and many friends have too, which is why I posted that I miss my butch dykes. I don't judge anyone for what they do — 'I wake up in this body everyday and I dont want anyone telling me how I should or should not be me' — but I'm an old-school lesbian and my body responds to butch womyn born womyn. I've tried to change what I'm attracted to and I can't. I've described myself as a TERF if that's what people want to call me, but I can't force my mind or body to like anything else. I view the whole gender issue as being on a 'pendulum swing' — it comes out hard, overshoots, and eventually settles in the middle, and I believe simpler explanations will come after long, well-thought-out consideration. I worry that butch womyn are being treated as 'incubators for a coming transition' and that young dykes are being erased the way lesbian bars have been. I don't care what anyone identifies as, but I believe lesbians — womyn born womyn who love womyn born womyn — are their own category with a right to exist, and I feel I can no longer proudly proclaim my journey without being seen as a transphobe. I've spent a lot of time advising other detransitioners and questioning people on Reddit: encouraging them not to obsess over what others think, to walk with confidence as they are now, to replace toxic self-critical thoughts with positive ones (the kind of homework a therapist might assign), and to see their detransition as being 'on the frontlines' of a movement they got swept up in. I've told people in that position that their detrans are 'battle scars,' that they're doing important work, and that they should share their expertise with others. I've also pushed back on studies (a survey of surgeons, the Amsterdam Cohort study) that are used to argue detransition isn't prevalent. On relationships, I've said the only easy pairing is heterosexual couples, that gay people have a smaller pool and trans people smaller still, and that as a butch woman who only likes butch women I'm in a very small pool — but that the key to a successful relationship is loving yourself and projecting that.