Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I am a 48-year-old lesbian (as of May 2020) who is Dutch and has been part of the LGBT community for over 30 years. I am not trans and not detransitioned — I come to this community for reading and learning. I have never transitioned, so I have no personal transition timeline, medical interventions, or detransition process of my own to describe.
My involvement in this community comes from a place of long-standing engagement with lesbian and gay issues and deep concern about what I see happening to them. I have been involved in the LGBT community for 30+ years and feel strongly that the 'TGQ' ideology has destroyed it. I describe this as 'lesbo/homophobic to the max' and as 'toxic, damaging religious right homophobia.' I have been upset about this for about 7 years as of October 2019, having watched what I consider the destruction of the community I was part of. I have suggested to young lesbians and gays that they stay away from what I call the 'TRAQUEERlgb.'
I am critical of the concept of 'inclusivity' as it is currently used, arguing that it has been hijacked and turned into a form of authoritarianism and oppression — 'all about power and domination' that is then labelled inclusivity, which I call abuse. I believe the original definition of sexual orientation (biological-sex based) has been changed by LGBT organisations and youth to be gender/identity based, and therefore when people claim their orientation changed after transition, their self-labelling may be incorrect from the start.
On the question of responsibility for transition outcomes, I argue that medical and psychological professionals should bear responsibility, comparing it to PTSD treatment: you go to an expert who is supposed to have more knowledge than you, and the results are not solely your responsibility. This is why I want psychological evaluation and therapy restored to the treatment of gender dysphoria, though I say this could be optional. I am critical of informed consent models, saying they are used to put responsibility solely on the patient, which I believe should never happen in medicine. I see detransitioners blaming themselves as a product of a broken system rather than their own failing.
I am aware of and critical of what I see as a defense mechanism among some trans people: blaming detransitioners so they can maintain belief in the reality of their own transition. I also think the claim that detransition is rare is untenable given how many detransitioners there are today, and reflects a general problem of denying everything to uphold one's own identity.
In the Netherlands, I note that the 'watchful waiting' approach is used for gender dysphoria — psychological screening, therapy, and proper diagnosis by a team of specialists, with hormones or blockers given case by case and potentially taking a long time to obtain. I contrast this with what I see in the USA as 'malpractice and medical neglect in over the counter treatment of young gender dysphoric people,' which I find shocking. I have also asked others in the community whether they suffered physical or sexual abuse, trauma as a young male, or had bad male role models — suggesting I see such experiences as potentially relevant to transition decisions.
I posted once asking whether there were any Dutch detransitioners in the community. I have not described any personal mental health conditions, trauma history, family situation, relationships, sexuality beyond being a lesbian, or personal regret, since I have not transitioned.