Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... [transvrouw die als MTF identificeerde en later als bondgenoot van detransitioners; in het hele gesprek heb ik mijn eigen detransitie nooit beschreven, dus mijn huidige identiteit wordt niet genoemd]. Ik begon in 2019 op mijn 17e met oestrogeen-HRT, die ik zelf bekostigde omdat de wachtlijsten van de Britse GIDS te lang waren, en in 2020 postte ik als 18-jarige bondgenoot met de vraag hoe ik detrans-mensen kon steunen. Ik werd kritisch over hoe transruimtes twijfelende mensen richting transitie duwen en over puberteitsremmers, nadat ik onderzoeken had gezien die op cognitieve effecten wijzen. Ik adviseerde anderen die transitie overwegen om voorzichtig te zijn, therapie te doen en grondig onderzoek te doen.
Volledig verhaal
I was 17 in July 2019 when I first introduced myself on this subreddit as an ally rather than as someone who had detransitioned. I described myself as a college student who had come to my own conclusion that I was transgender through introspection, and I was critical of trans sites like r/asktransgender for pushing people toward transition when they were still questioning. I had actually been banned from r/asktransgender after I told a 14-15 year old who was questioning that most people with pre-pubertal dysphoria see it subside once puberty begins, and that seeing a counsellor or waiting a year or two was reasonable; I was called a "gatekeeper" for it.
By July 2019 I had been on cross-sex hormone therapy (HRT, estrogen) for about two weeks. I had self-funded my medical transition by working a part-time job for six months because the UK's Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) was taking too long to give me an appointment. Before obtaining medication on my own, I saw a therapist independent of GIDS who declared me of sound mind. I also mentioned having had brain surgery 11 months earlier (around August 2018). I identified as MTF / a trans woman and also described myself as bisexual, attending Pride and other LGBTQI+ events.
My stated position in 2019 was that 16 should be the minimum age for cross-sex hormones, with therapy available earlier, and I was initially supportive of puberty blockers (GnRH analogues) as reversible. However, after seeing studies on this subreddit suggesting GnRH analogues could affect cognitive function (IQ), I became unsure about blockers and argued for better informed consent and the development of alternatives such as GnRH antagonists. I was a fan of Blaire White, Kalvin Garrah and Miss London as trans commentators critical of the "progressive left."
Through 2020 I continued posting as an 18-year-old ally, asking how I could support detrans people online and in real life. I acknowledged that therapy for gender identity often seemed to push people in one direction and hoped this would change so people could make up their own minds. I argued against legislation restricting minors' access to hormone blockers, supported informed consent for hormones at 16 with a year of counselling, and surgery at 18 with additional requirements. I defended the subreddit against accusations of transphobia, while also criticizing a meme mocking trans men as cruel. I advised a sibling of a questioning person to listen, ensure their brother researched everything, and seek a therapist experienced with trans people, and I advised a parent to take it slow with their daughter and consider therapy if feelings persisted.
I never described detransitioning myself in these posts; throughout the transcript I identified as a trans woman and as an ally to detransitioners. I expressed the view that detransitioners should not be thought less of for stopping transition to get back on their path, and I agreed that detrans people are not automatically LGBT+ just because they detransitioned.