Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die als volwassene is getransitioneerd nadat ik genderdoorbrekend, autistisch en in een extreemrechts gezin was opgegroeid, grotendeels gemotiveerd door angst en schaamte rond mannelijkheid en mannelijke seksualiteit. Ik gebruikte ongeveer vier en een half jaar met tussenpozen hormonen en leefde sociaal als vrouw, ook op werkplekken waar ik me als vrouw moest presenteren om mijn baan te houden. Ik ben mezelf gaan zien als bepaald door mijn geleefde ervaring, die volgens mij niet in dezelfde categorie als die van vrouwen past, en ik accepteer de rigide trans/cis-categorieën niet meer. Ik werk er nu naartoe om in mannenruimtes als gewone kerel geaccepteerd te worden, terwijl ik op het werk soms nog moet meespelen met het gezien worden als vrouw. Ik pleit voor een realistische, geloofwaardige discussie over de schade van transitie in plaats van harde anti-transretoriek, en ik geloof dat onbehandeld autisme en het ontbreken van genderdoorbrekende hetero-representatie sleutelfactoren in mijn weg waren.
Volledig verhaal
I was diagnosed with autism in third grade but never got treatment for it, and I've often wondered how differently things might have turned out if I had. Growing up I was a loner as a child, teen, and young adult, and I never built up experience fitting in with same-sex peer groups. I was gender nonconforming from early on — I wanted to carry a purse, have female platonic friends, style my hair in various ways — and I grew up in a household with parents who were far-right conservatives, well to the right of even Trump, which gave me a strong desire to do something that would upset them.
As a kid I read a popular radfem blog post arguing that reproductive sex is always rape, and I internalized the message from both feminist and patriarchal culture that a man's natural sexual urges are predatory. That made me feel like a monster, like I was less human. I also absorbed the 'men are trash' rhetoric on Tumblr as a teen, which made me feel morally unredeemable unless I could find some way to escape seeing myself as a man. I feared growing up into the kind of man I saw around me — in locker rooms I'd hear men engaging in misogynistic talk, being toxic to one another, and being GNC-phobic, and since I wasn't a misogynist myself it was hard to consider myself one of them. A huge transition motivator for me was the hope of resisting and overcoming maleness-linked aggression and sexuality that felt monstrous and harmful. When you're scared of men and write them off morally as violent oversexed aggressors, the last thing you want to do is grow up into one.
I also felt that being a feminine male is a very harsh existence, and in certain ways it's easier to transition — though transition is obviously a very difficult, rough, sometimes damaging thing itself. I don't think a man can wear a skirt to a job or apartment interview and realistically have a shot at getting either the same way a transsexual can. I transitioned as an adult. At some point I did voice training; it took me maybe a year and a half from starting voice practice to no longer having to consciously think about it in normal conversation.
I've used hormones on and off for about four and a half years as of October 2020, relapsing most of the time and trying to quit at other times. Three years before that post (so around October 2017) I was asked at my old job to take on a female name, because my coworkers there no longer accepted that I was a man. By January 2020 I was living as female at a restaurant kitchen job in a relatively conservative region of Washington state in the US, where I'd been about five months. I presented female at that job interview and continued at work — not my first choice at all — because I'd been laughed out of three earlier job interviews at different places when I tried to present male despite having a legal name typical for a woman. I had to compromise in order to pay rent and eat. I worried about whether I could be fired for detransitioning, since both bosses had made off-the-cuff negative remarks about people 'identifying as whatever.'
By October 2020 I had another job across the country, in an all-male kitchen staff. When I applied I proudly indicated on every application and piece of relevant paperwork that I was male, and it never came up in the interview, but since day one every other employee has spoken about me and pretended as though I were a woman. It feels really othering, and I hate that I'm expected to keep up this fiction along with them in order not to rock the boat at work, stay employed, and stay housed. I asked how to earn my way towards men accepting me as one of them, and how to get the experience of being accepted in male peer groups that I never had.
On the question of identity, I came to grips with the fact that we are defined by our experiences and realized there's no realistic way you could categorize my lived experience with that of women. I don't really believe, nor do a lot of detrans people, that there is any such thing as people who are trans and people who are cis, so much as there are people who have dysphoria and people who don't, and people who transition and people who don't. I don't think anyone should feel like they owe it to anyone to fit themselves into any one identity box. I also don't think there's a workable definition of a 'really trans' person that manages to universally exclude detrans and reidentified people.
I've thought a lot about how differently things might have shaken out if I'd gotten autism treatment after being diagnosed in third grade, and I believe that could have put me on a path that didn't involve eventual transition as an adult. I also believe that more GNC straight representation could have made a difference — straight boys are constantly bombarded with messages from conservatives and hateful segments of GC feminists alike that GNC behavior indicates either being gay or being a misogynistic pervert/AGP, so for a non-misogynistic straight boy who wants not to conform, the transgender movement's 'you're actually a girl' answer can seem like the only remotely plausible one. I was certainly one of those kids forcing myself into the transgender identity box.
I'm critical of both hardline anti-transition rhetoric and of trans activism. I think the way to keep more people from being harmed by transition is by making sure they have an accurate and realistic understanding of transition and what it does — pretending estradiol is as damaging to males as testosterone is to females backfires and makes us look like ideologues. I've said we're in a public relations battle with trans activists for many people's futures, and PR battles are won with credibility. I'm also frustrated when gender critical people co-opt detrans spaces, and when GC spaces treat transitioning as a moral failure. Attitudes that treat all men as predatory or all trans women as autogynephilic are, I've said, the reason a lot of us ran away from our maleness to begin with.