Alle verhalen

Uit de wens een jongen te zijn groeien vóór de volwassenheid

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd675
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw die aan de rand van detransitie staat, die nooit hormonen nam of een operatie had maar in mijn kindertijd intens weerstand bood tegen meisje worden, onder meer door me als jongen te kleden, mijn haar af te knippen en te vragen om een jongensnaam, waar ik vóór de volwassenheid uit groeide. Mijn weerstand in mijn kindertijd was geworteld in armoede in het gezin, waardoor meisjesachtige dingen onbereikbaar voelden, en in fysieke intimidatie door oudere jongens rond mijn 10e, waardoor ik de gedachte aan vrouw worden haatte. Ik ben nu een vrouw die van zichzelf houdt en een sterk besef van vrouw-zijn heeft, al blijf ik diep betrokken bij detrans-gemeenschappen en ben ik kritisch over medische transitie, vooral hormonen en genitale chirurgie, die ik gevaarlijk vind en in sommige gevallen systematische zelfbeschadiging. Ik heb geen trans identiteit meer en identificeer me volledig als vrouw, en ik pleit actief voor de stem van detransitioners en voor voorzichtigheid bij medische transitie van jongeren.

Volledig verhaal

I am a woman who never took hormones and never had any surgeries, and I want to be clear about that up front because I think it matters when I talk about these topics. I ended up deeply involved in detrans spaces not because I detransitioned myself, but because I recognized my own childhood in what people describe. When I was growing up, my family didn't have much money. "There is no money for that" was a refrain I heard constantly, and I think that as a coping mechanism it turned into hatred for girly things. I would say, "No I want to dress like this, I hate the girls' section, it's just stupid, I don't want makeup or hair-curlers." On top of dressing like a skater-dude in baggy, boy-style clothes, I cut my hair and told people to call me by a boy's name. I also have some male "hobbies." On top of the money stuff, I was physically harassed by older boys at a very young age, around 10 years old. That turned me into not wanting to become a woman. I hated the thought of it. I cried so many times because I didn't want to be a woman or a girl. I have written elsewhere that I don't really know what the word gender dysphoria means and I can't relate when people write that they feel gender dysphoria, but I remember crying for a few years because I didn't want to be a girl or become a woman. Maybe that is what dysphoria is? I honestly don't know. But as I have written, there were issues I was not able to deal with on my own. My parents, whom I love, had their own issues and their own trauma from their childhood. The crucial difference for me is that trans was not a thing back then, at least not where I lived. So I just grew out of it and there was never any talk about hrt or surgery. I came to fully accept me, my feelings, my body, and that happened before I was an adult, or around the time of my late teen years. I love myself today. I have a very strong womanhood inside me. I am a woman, when and if it matters. But at first and foremost I am a human being. Because of my own history, I feel a strong pull toward these issues. I don't fully know why I'm so stuck on detrans issues, but this post just opened so many memories for me. I think that in a perfect world kids get to try several hobbies - sports, tech, arts - and in a perfect world there is enough money to try out different styles and self-expression, and they should be allowed to do so. What worries me now is that right now some people are going through harmful hormone treatments and irreversible operations, so when they come out from the dysphoria they have a whole other set of problems to deal with. I have never taken hrt or done surgery, so maybe I won't understand some people's situations, and I try to be honest about that. But I have looked closely at what these interventions do. I have talked about how some detrans men on YouTube describe hrt making dysphoria worse, about trans men whose vaginal walls get so thin and fragile on testosterone that they tear and bleed, about hair loss and constant pain. I have also learned here on this detrans forum that the cervix has a role in female sexual function - I had no idea, honestly - and that women who have had unnecessary hysterectomies have in some cases lost their cervix for nothing, with negative effects. As an adult, I am just going to put it out there plainly: a healthy sex life is something that every person has the right to choose. If someone has surgery on the genitals and that injures nerves, then that is just not okay. I actually find it difficult to accept systematic self-harm, which is what I believe srs is. I have written about how very few people get a functioning neo-vagina that doesn't close up, how the ones that stay open often can't get any pleasure from it, how dilation is painful for many, how scar tissue and painful areas are common. I don't say that no one feels pleasure after srs, but having srs can reduce the level of pleasure, inner and outer. Some people online claim their neo-vagina is self-lubricating. We all know that is not possible. Some people lie. I have also thought a lot about why people end up identifying as trans. I have watched videos by a detrans YouTuber called Isaac Uncooked about different categories of trans - people who suffered trauma, people with autism, people with a weak sense of self, and narcissistic men with autogynephilia. That last category made sense to me. I have also followed Shapeshifter, a detrans YouTuber who came from another country with a lot of internalized homophobia, started hormones, got confused, had surgeries that didn't work long term and ruined a lot of feeling in that area. Shapeshifter regrets it so much, especially the bottom surgery, but it isn't reversible. Shapeshifter realizes that you can't be born in the wrong body and just embrace life with the body you have. Shapeshifter has also said that when he began taking hormones is when he really got a problem with dysphoria, and that led to the surgery. I have also talked about Munchausen by Proxy - "munch-moms" who coach their kid to be trans to brag on social media about being a trans-mom and get likes. I have talked about how moving to a new country can create a crisis, and about how trans has been turned into a subculture where people identify as trans and have transactivism and transideology as hobbies, just like educated, normal, intelligent people believe the earth is flat. I am critical of trans activism but I try to be careful about how I say it. I don't call trans women men. I really don't care what people call themselves or how they live their lives. I just oppose srs and also hrt because I believe that hurts people and disables them. I may also not think that trans women should be in female prisons or changing rooms because it is too easy for predator men to pretend to be trans and gain access to victims, and this has already happened. I think detransitioners are the most qualified to speak about these topics. I have encouraged people to share their experiences if they are comfortable, and to contact mods and explain when they are silenced. I have also tried to support people directly. I have told a young person considering transition that two years ago they were living with their mom and planning trans surgeries in her bubble, and now they are with their father, and that change happens over time. I have told people that their future partner will accept a trans phase in their life, that no one will think less of them, that they are making it bigger in their head than it is. I have told people to go to real doctors, not just trans doctors, and ask for help. I have told people that detransitioning means you are in your normal state, that it can't be a mistake to be you, and that if a person planned a cosmetic surgery, backing out couldn't be a mistake or an obsession. I have also pushed back on people I thought were being contemptuous of detransitioners. When one person tried to distance themselves from detransitioners by saying they didn't have autism and weren't assaulted as a child, I told them that reeked of contempt and superiority, that survivors are the bravest and strongest people there is, and that there are many reasons people become trans - for ftm it can be about subconsciously not wanting to be an object, or feeling limited in a female gender norm. I have also been honest about my own confusion and my own history. I have written about being harassed by men and wondering whether some women transition so they won't be traumatized again. I have written about being jealous of lesbians and seeing myself that way at times. I have written about how some of these feelings could stem from being exposed to porn early and not understanding what was really going on. I think we have all been brainwashed by Hollywood and media. Right now I am doing okay. I have a strong sense of who I am. I am not on any medical pathway and I don't plan to be. I do worry about young people going through irreversible procedures, and I try to speak up about the lack of information and what I believe are flat-out lies about the dangers of medical transition. I am all for information. I don't want to lie. That is why I keep talking.