Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die ongeveer 14 jaar als trans identificeerde, rond mijn 20e-21e begon met transitie en officieel detransitioneerde op mijn 34e, nadat intensieve traumatherapie na ernstig huiselijk geweld mijn genderdysforie deed verdampen. Ik herleidde mijn dysforie tot verwaarlozing en misbruik in mijn kindertijd, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, overidentificatie met hoe anderen me zagen en een verlangen naar een gezinsachtige gemeenschap die ik hoopte te vinden in lhbtq-ruimtes. Ik ontdekte dat mijn oorspronkelijke gendertherapeut in mijn staat nooit een licentie had, een ‘online briefjesmolen’ die me hormonen gaf zonder echte zorg, al ben ik voorbij de verjaringstermijn voor claims wegens medische fouten. Ik heb een mastectomie gehad en onomkeerbare veranderingen door meer dan een decennium testosteron, heb het verlies van mijn jeugd en lichamelijke veranderingen betreurd, en leef nu stealth als cis op mijn gesyndiceerde baan in de foodservice, waar de meeste collega’s en HR trans zijn, doodsbang om uitgeouted te worden. Ik ben nu veel gelukkiger en gezonder, studeer weer psychologie om anderen zoals wij te helpen en spreek me openbaar uit over detransitie ondanks aanhoudende intimidatie, in de overtuiging dat transitie een laatste redmiddel moet zijn en geen eerstelijnsbehandeling.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and identified as trans for about 14 years, starting my transition at around 20-21 years old. I was deeply embedded in advocacy: I was president of an LGBT club for several years in college, served in student senate, participated in faculty diversity meetings and trainings, and had a strong social media presence. I completed my undergraduate studies in philosophy, studying ethics, feminist theory, queer theory, and transgender theory, so I knew all the arguments for and against transition and they made sense to me at the time.
What changed came gradually. Around the peak of the COVID pandemic I realized I still had a lot of healing to do. My intimate relationships had always been rocky. I tried to seek out therapy, particularly EMDR, but trauma therapists were overwhelmed with pandemic anxiety cases, so that got tabled.
A few years later I moved in with my partner at the time, who also identified as FTM. Things were good until they weren't. Once it was just the two of us, they became nightmarishly abusive, which culminated in torture (felony assault) and an attempt on my life when I tried to leave. They were arrested, convicted, and removed from my life, but not before the damage of abuse, social isolation, and the assault was done. Shortly after, they dropped the trans identity and took up a narrative that I was a man who abused her and made her do what she did, and everyone believed her without question. The system went easy on her because of her history of severe mental illness. I sought zero restitution because I believed we could move on from what happened, which we didn't.
Devastated and isolated, I spent the next few years in very intensive therapy programs untangling everything: the self-blame, the thought distortions, self-image issues, sexuality issues, and eventually childhood traumas and the rigidity in my thinking. As I pulled up those roots, my gender dysphoria sort of just evaporated. It was as though I woke up one day and felt like I was in someone else's body. I no longer recognized who I was in the mirror and I couldn't tell anyone.
Quietly, I stopped HRT, started laser hair removal on my face, and wore chest prosthesis when I went out by myself. I try to talk as little as possible because when I do, people are startled and it makes me feel sad - not because they don't see me as a girl, but because it hurts to be regarded as strange. Most of the time people assume I'm a trans woman and try to be respectful, which on some level frustrated me. I officially detransitioned at 34.
I later identified the roots of my 15+ years of gender dysphoria as early childhood neglect, trauma, and abuse, internalized misogyny, an over-identification with external perception, a longing for familial community and acceptance I thought I'd find under the LGBTQ banner, and transition as a way to have agency and access to love and care I never received. Learning to love myself in my 30s through years of intensive therapy was a huge piece of getting rid of the dysphoria.
I also discovered that my gender therapist who wrote my HRT letter a decade ago never had a license to practice in my state. She conducted 'therapy' through text conversations, only accepted PayPal for out-of-state clients, and her therapy was little more than a checklist for diagnostic criteria plus a letter after paying out of pocket per session under the table. I have PayPal receipts, email correspondences, and session transcripts from 2013 and 2014. I'm outside both malpractice statutes of limitations (4 and 7 years). My endocrinologist even looked at the letter back then and said 'Oh. Her,' which I mistook for legitimizing recognition. I also met another therapist who offered letters without care and made her stance against gatekeeping clear.
Medically, I was on testosterone for over a decade. I was never told about vaginal atrophy until I started experiencing it, which was extremely painful; the only treatment was local estrogen, which made me very sick and was one of the reasons I ultimately stopped T. After stopping, my system turned back on after 2-3 months and it took about 6-7 months to be as it was before T. I've had a mastectomy (there's no breast tissue, so I wear prosthesis), and I still need to update my passport and state ID. I'm back in school studying psychology and designing research to maybe one day help others like us.
Currently I work in food service with almost exclusively queer and trans people; we're unionized and I make good money. I've been able to hide under the guise of gender nonconforming or genderqueer at work. I haven't told them I'm not he/him anymore, but it doesn't really bother me - I don't feel dysphoria and I'm pragmatic about it. I changed my name back to my legal name on everything and HR (also trans) jumped on me in a panic asking if I really meant to. I know if I come out I could face real alienation; my employer, HR, and half my coworkers are trans, and I'm terrified they'll find out I'm living as cis outside of work because I could lose everything.
I recently had to delete my social media because of abuse and harassment from people in the transgender community. My therapist and psychiatrist don't know how to navigate the conversation with me. Trans people have harassed me and told me not to talk about detransition unless it fits the narrative of 'being trans was too hard' or 'my surgeons messed up,' and I was told to shut up because 'we're cis and it's easy being cis.' I've been told my entire experience is a lie because I couldn't possibly have been trans, or that I'm 'cisgender with extra steps.'
I feel a measure of guilt for remaining invisible as the detransition debate keeps coming up, because our stories matter. I'm now exploring narrative and philosophy-informed therapeutic approaches and was recommended 'The Wounded Storyteller.' I spent months and years grieving the youth I lost and the changes I made to my body, but I'm much happier and much healthier now, and finally living at peace with myself. I wish I had been offered real healing instead of a sword when I was young and vulnerable.
I'm critical of transition being offered so readily: I believe transition is symptom management and ought to be a last resort, not a rubber stamp after a 30-minute assessment. I think there's no 'true' transgender origin - you either discover the origin of your dysphoria and work through it or you don't. I'm outspoken about the lack of longitudinal studies, the coaching of patients to get diagnoses, WPATH as a lobbying organization, and the lack of infrastructure for detransitioners.