Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die sociaal transitioneerde maar, naar eigen zeggen, alleen voor medische transitie terugdeinsde omdat ik vastzat bij mijn familie. Ik ben als vrouw geboren, wilde vanaf minstens mijn 17e een platte borst en geen menstruatie meer, en zag transitie deels als ontsnapping aan seksualisering, gedwongen vrouwelijkheid en ongelijke genderrollen opgelegd door mijn ouders. Nu identificeer ik me stellig als genderonconforme vrouw, definieer ik vrouw zijn als ‘een volwassen menselijk vrouwtje’ en heb ik gendercritische opvattingen. Ik blijf actief onder een gekozen naam uit mijn sociale transitie en ben me aan het bekeren tot het katholicisme. Ik heb geen medische transitie, operaties of suïcidale gedachten beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and by my own account I've been flat-chested for the first 12-13 years of my life, which is the body I keep wanting to get back to. In April 2021, when I was 17, I posted asking whether I could dislike or want to get rid of my breasts and still be a woman. My biggest problem, I said, was that I just wanted to be shirtless and flat, and I didn't care about dating or what other people would think. I framed it as possibly odd but not necessarily meaning I was trans — I just wanted to be flat like I was for 12-13 years. I also said I'd like to permanently stop my period, maybe with a hysterectomy, mostly because it was annoying and I don't want kids. When someone suggested alternatives, I said the depo shot seemed like a 'better less extreme option atleast for now.' I also said I was fine with keeping the organs — 'it's not like I'm gonna use those organs ever in my life' — and that even if it's technically a female chest, I don't care as long as it's flat. I told someone I'd think about it a lot and that I was working out, so maybe in a couple of years I'd feel better and wouldn't need anything.
I did do a social transition at some point — by December 2023 I said I still use the name I chose when I did a social transition, and I'd legally change it if I didn't have to pay the government. In February 2024 I said I wouldn't share that name publicly because I still go by it, and that it makes job interviews fun when I pipe in at the end with my legal name.
Looking back on why I wanted to transition, in December 2023 I explained that men have it easier in the majority of the world — they don't have periods, don't get sexualized the way women do, aren't as vulnerable to male violence such as rape. 'It seemed like an escape, to blend in with males is to be safe.' In February 2024 I described trans people generally as 'just people trying to run from the societal expectations and perceptions of their sex. Like for me it was the constant sexualization and forced femininity.' I also said my parents and their gender roles were one of the driving factors: my brother doesn't have to dress up or sit quietly but I do, and I was angry about that double standard. I hate wearing women's clothing because it's designed to show the body, so I strictly buy from the men's section now because those clothes are actually comfortable.
Crucially, in February 2024 I admitted: 'To be completely honest.. i think I would've transitioned and kept at it if I was in a better position. But I'm stuck with my fam so I'm just not gonna bother.' That suggests my detransition or non-transition was at least partly constrained by living situation rather than purely internal resolution.
By late 2023 and into 2024 I had become firmly gender-critical. I defined myself as 'a very gnc woman' with short hair who wears men's clothing. I said 'To be a woman is to just be born female, ezpz' and 'Woman is just an adult human female. Ezpz.' I called gender 'a fraud concept' and said it's just stereotypes associated to each sex. I was critical of both political sides — I said I could never support people who want women to be submissive, baby-making, home-cleaning machines, but I'm also not a leftie, 'just somewhere in between.' I expressed strong views on sex-separated spaces, saying putting male prisoners in women's prisons is not okay. I was happy being gender non-conforming and said I like seeing 'all these conformists stay crying.'
I also described myself as being in RCIA, set to be baptized and confirmed at Easter 2024, and said my parish, priests, and catechists were welcoming of my gender non-conformity. I said gender stereotypes aren't part of Catholicism. I'm not American and was living in British Columbia as of December 2023, wanting to move further north to the Yukon. I gave up on dating apps within about two weeks and said I'd 'just die alone it's fine.'