Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw in de 40 die zich vanaf peuterleeftijd als jongen identificeerde, op mijn 11e de diagnose GID kreeg, op mijn 18e probeerde te transitioneren (geweigerd vanwege mijn geschiedenis van seksueel misbruik als kind), me vanaf 2012 non-binair identificeerde en in 2019 sociaal transitioneerde als transmasculien met de bedoeling testosteron te beginnen, wat ik nooit deed. Mijn genderdysforie was geworteld in seksueel geweld op mijn 5e, ernstige afwijzing door mijn moeder omdat ik een meisje was, narcistische opvoeding, pesten, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en lesbofobie, anorexia, PTSS en autoandrofilie. Ik desisteerde door uitgebreid journalen in DBT-stijl, het tegenkomen van detransitie-content op YouTube, een door THC veroorzaakte psychotische episode en een aan fentanyl gerelateerde hallucinatie tijdens een operatie, waardoor ik mijn zij/haar-voornaamwoorden terugnam. Ik identificeer me nu als een tomboy van middelbare leeftijd, ben getrouwd met een cisgender man en heb kinderen, en mijn depressie, PTSS en lichaamsdysmorfie zijn naar eigen zeggen verdwenen. Ik steun transitie voor wie er echt baat bij heeft, maar ben kritisch over het idee dat genderidentiteit aangeboren is en pleit ervoor eerst het onderliggende trauma te behandelen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and have identified as a detransitioned/desisted woman, currently in my 40s. I was saying I was a boy from around age 2-3, refusing girls' clothes, kicking and screaming when put in dresses, and identifying as a boy for the first 3-4 years of my life. I was diagnosed with Gender Identity Disorder at age 10/11 in 1989. I tried to transition at 18 but was talked out of it due to childhood sexual assault history. I identified as non-binary from 2012, then moved toward FtM identification around 2016-2019 after meeting a trans man through work. I socially transitioned in 2019 with a view toward starting testosterone, and was in therapy and on track to start T at the beginning of 2021. I never actually started hormones or had surgeries related to transition, though I did have a gender-affirming surgery (which I entered the hospital using they/them pronouns and left using she/her). I also took DHEA from 2004-2006 hoping it would masculinize me.
I desisted in stages. I first desisted in my mid-20s (around 23-24) when I started watching heterosexual porn and developed what I described as a MILF/breeding fetish, which shifted my self-perception. I then went through a hyper-feminine 'trad wife' phase for about six years in my 30s. I socially transitioned again around 2019, then began questioning after encountering detransition content on YouTube around 2020. It took about 9 months of listening to detransitioners before I began to waver, and another year to accept desisting. I described experiencing an 'ego death' when I realized I couldn't go on testosterone. I now identify as a tomboy and/or androgynous person, use she/her pronouns (having previously used they/them), and describe myself as a 'middle-aged tomboy.' I am married to a cisgender man and have children.
Causes and contributors: My gender dysphoria had multiple trauma causes. I was sexually assaulted at age 5 (CSA), which intensified my rejection of my female body. I was emotionally, physically, and verbally abused by my mother well into adulthood. My mother wanted a boy, had boys' clothes and a name ready, and rejected me for being 'yet another girl' - she couldn't have more children after me due to a traumatic pregnancy. My father had BPD and was emotionally absent. My mother showed narcissistic tendencies (likely NPD) and had a PhD. I was bullied relentlessly by my sisters, mother, and teachers for being GNC. I was violently assaulted as a GNC tomboy at age 23, after which I adopted feminine clothing for protection. I experienced PTSD (diagnosed at age 15/16) and depression. I had anorexia and exercise addiction from puberty onward, running approximately 10 miles a day and sometimes eating only an apple. I had body dysmorphia. I experienced internalized misogyny and lesbophobia - I was raised to be grossed out by lesbians but sympathetic to gay men. I identified as a 'gay man in a woman's body' from age 11 to 40. I had AAP (autoandrophilia) and what I described as autohomoerotica. I was raised in a matriarchal feminist household where my mother's feminism was intertwined with gender essentialism and a preference for boys. I was given synthetic progesterone in utero to prevent miscarriage (my mother miscarried my twin), which I noted is linked to more 'boyish' play in female children. I was also exposed to social media and online trans communities starting around 2020, which I acknowledged influenced my thinking, though I noted I already had a strong pre-existing gender identity belief.
Processes toward detransition: I encountered detransition videos on YouTube around 2020 through the algorithm, which began my questioning process. I did extensive journaling using what I described as a DBT-inspired technique - keeping a pocket notebook to record dysphoric/euphoric thoughts throughout the day, then expanding on them in exercise books each evening. I did this for at least 6 months of solid commitment. I examined every possible cause of my gender identity including trauma, misogyny, AAP/AGP, sexuality, kink, and dissociation. A gender therapist asked me 'why do I need a gender identity at all?' which was pivotal. I had a 'spiritual awakening' via an accidentally large dose of edible THC that caused psychosis and hospitalization - during this experience I looked in the mirror and saw myself as normal/acceptable rather than wrong. I later had a surgery where I was given too much fentanyl due to a weight calculation error, causing hallucinations during which I was misgendered and deadnamed by hospital staff but felt cared for - this experience helped me reclaim she/her pronouns. I also used tarot cards during my questioning period, which I viewed as tapping into my unconscious. I read work by Hacsi Horvath on 4th Wave Now about identity disorders. I found a study showing brains are monomorphic, which relieved my belief in having a 'male brain.'
Medical: I never took testosterone or had transition-related surgeries. I took DHEA from 2004-2006. I had a gender-affirming surgery (details not specified) during which I was given too much fentanyl. I was scheduled for a hysterectomy due to fibroids/polyps pressing on internal organs and suspected adenomyosis, keeping my cervix (6-week recovery). I used tranexamic acid for heavy periods. I had suspected PMDD. I was anorexic for many years. I have a very flat chest (AA size) partly attributed to eating disorders. I used a men's compression top for gynecomastia and occasionally still wear a binder or tight sports bra for comfort.
Mental health: I was diagnosed with PTSD at age 15/16 and again in adulthood, depression, and had identity issues similar to BPD (though I didn't meet criteria for BPD or NPD). I had debilitating depression, anxiety, and social impairments. I experienced frequent suicidal thoughts before social transition. I described being 'on the verge of mental health hospital' at my lowest. After desisting and doing trauma work, I reported that my depression, PTSD, body dysmorphia, and anxiety symptoms resolved. I stated 'I don't have depression anymore' and 'I would be surprised if a psych could even find one mental illness now.' I also suspected I might have ADHD.
Adversity: CSA at age 5; violent assault at age 23; multiple instances of sexual harassment and stalking; bullying from family (mother, sisters) and peers throughout childhood and adulthood; emotional/physical/verbal abuse from mother; emotionally absent father with BPD; narcissistic mother; being rejected by family for being female; being told I was 'ugly' and compared negatively to sisters; being forced into dresses; being told I'd grow up to be a lesbian; corrective assaults from a school teacher and university lecturer; domestic violence episodes in adulthood.
Social: My husband and children were supportive of my social transition. My birth family (mother, sisters) switched pronouns without me asking, which I later realized was performative. I ended contact with my birth family during my desisting process because their comments were affecting my self-esteem and preventing PTSD recovery. I had friends of 30 years who affirmed me. I lost some trans friends when I began questioning trauma as a cause of gender identity. I described feeling isolated and having to rebuild my sense of self from scratch.
Sexuality: I dated a girl/woman from age 18-23 (nearly 6 years living together), then married a man. I identified as a gay man inside a woman's body from age 11 to 40. I now describe myself as 95% heterosexual but increasingly realize I may be a lesbian - I stated 'I'm in my 40s and have just realised I'm more likely a lesbian than bisexual.' I have only ever been attracted to people assigned female at birth, including trans men and butch lesbians. I experienced internalized homophobia/lesbophobia. I described having AAP and autohomoerotica. I was in a relationship with a trans man who became stalkerish.
Regret: I expressed that I wished I hadn't needed to socially transition to learn self-acceptance, but I don't regret the social transition itself because it was instrumental in my healing. I had 'a bit of regret following surgery but I don't anymore.' I regret the lost time and identity confusion. I described feeling like I 'killed my own self' during ego death. I expressed anger at being denied effective trauma treatment for decades. The regret appears to be improving over time as I've built resilience and self-acceptance.
Outcomes: I now describe myself as a 'middle-aged tomboy' who presents androgynously in men's clothes with short hair. I have a supportive husband and children. I work in a female-dominated field with STEM education. I have a rural holiday home where I go to be alone in nature. I report being mentally healthier than ever, with resolved depression and PTSD symptoms. I still face social challenges being read as trans or masculine by strangers.
Attitudes: I support people making conscious decisions about transition and believe transition can be genuinely helpful for some people. I am critical of the idea that gender identity is innate and fixed, and of affirmative care that doesn't explore underlying trauma. I believe gender dysphoria can have trauma causes that should be treated first. I advocate for gender non-conformity without pressure to transition. I have not done formal activism but write extensively online about my experiences. I explicitly state 'nobody has permission to use my words to push an agenda' and 'Trans/detrans rights are human rights.'