Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw: ik heb nooit hormonen genomen of een operatie gehad, en op mijn 21e leer ik femininiteit opnieuw kennen (make-up, jurken) nadat ik als kind wenste mannelijke personages zoals Naruto en Vegeta te zijn. Ik pleit nu hartstochtelijk tegen medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, met verwijzing naar sociale besmetting, door trauma gedreven transitie en onomkeerbare schade, en ik heb sterk kritische, TERF-sympathiserende opvattingen over transvrouwen in vrouwenruimtes. Ik raad eerst therapie aan en transitie alleen als laatste redmiddel voor volwassenen. Ik noemde dat een transvriend(in) onlangs door zelfmoord is overleden. Ik heb zelf geen dysforie, diagnoses of formeel detransitieproces beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I am a woman; I never took hormones or had any medical procedures done, and I am learning to be comfortable with femininity now at 21. I first wrote about my own experience in December 2022, when I told someone that I was 21, that I had not taken any hormones, and that I was just now learning how to put on makeup, buy makeup brushes, and wear dresses. I described cutting my hair short in high school and always wearing a Naruto headband wishing I was Naruto, and I added that I am "literally a brown woman" and that thankfully my parents shut me down at the time. I also said I wanted to be Vegeta from Dragon Ball Z when I was in middle school, which I use as my argument that minors do not know what they want to be.
Most of my posts are addressed to a male-identified person who was planning to go on HRT, and I argued with him at length. My core position is that biological sex cannot be changed: "There's no way around biological sex," and "YOU WILL NEVER BE A WOMAN!" I told him that having long hair, colored nails, and taking HRT would not change that fact and that he was "masquerading as a woman." I framed TERF positions sympathetically, saying TERF essentially means "be who you are but you're still a man," and I argued that trans women should not enter women's restrooms, locker rooms, or prisons. I repeatedly cited the Loudon County case, where a trans student in a skirt allegedly raped a girl in a school restroom and committed other assaults, and I claimed California allows trans women convicted of sexual assault into women's prisons. I argued that separate bathrooms are a deterrent and that legalizing trans women's access would enable assault, summing up my view as "Feelings < Safety/Privacy." I also listed experiences I consider uniquely female — first period and "the talk" with my mom, bleeding through pads and pants, being paid less, being sexualized since childhood, fighting for reproductive rights — to argue that a male can empathize but never experience being a woman.
I believe the recent spike in trans identification is social contagion, saying trans people have "only ever been less than 1% of the population" and that the spike is "due to social contagion," which is also why there is a spike in detransitioners. I pointed to TikTok, classrooms in California, children's books, drag queen story hour, teachers hanging flags, and favoritism by openly trans teachers as drivers. I repeatedly said many people transition because of past traumas or other mental illnesses and recommended therapy first: "When I say 'Love yourself' I mean go to therapy," with transition only as a last resort if everything else fails. I criticized the medical establishment for selling puberty blockers and hormones as reversible when they are not, and I cited Marci Bowers saying children on puberty blockers will never experience an orgasm. I supported a law banning gender-affirming care for minors, saying therapists are meant to push back and question rather than affirm, and that kids cannot consent to changing their sex the way they cannot consent to sex. I said I have no problem with tax-paying adults doing what they want.
I also commented on a person identifying with a fictional character, calling it a serious mental illness and hoping they were not taking hormones or doing body modifications to become a fictional character. On video games, I said playing as a character of another gender means nothing — I play as male characters because they are handsome — and that people who read otherwise are "chronically online." I encourage people to do whatever they want without medicalization: "You don't need to take artificial drugs and get surgery to do whatever you want. Don't sell your body to big pharma." I also noted that living as a constant performance "shouldn't" be necessary and that altering yourself to live comfortably "isn't freedom."
I have not described any dysphoria of my own beyond wanting to be male characters as a child, nor any diagnosis, trauma, or mental health condition. I have not described a formal detransition, since I never transitioned medically; I describe myself as a girl learning femininity. I have not described sexuality, relationships, family beyond my parents shutting down my haircut, career, or advocacy beyond posting. I have not mentioned suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts, though I mentioned that a trans friend of mine killed herself recently.