Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, ontwikkelde vanaf ongeveer mijn 4e ernstige genderdysforie, kwam uit de kast bij een steunende familie en leefde enkele jaren gelukkig als transman die doorging als man, zonder ooit testosteron te nemen. Mijn detransitie begon door een bijwerking van een SSRI die derealisatie veroorzaakte, waarna ik deels door druk van buitenaf terugkeerde naar een vrouwelijk uiterlijk. Ik ben nu ongeveer 5 jaar gedesisteerd, langer dan ik trans was, en identificeer me als gedetransitioneerde vrouw met slechts lichte resterende dysforie. Lichaamsneutraliteit en afstand nemen van transgerelateerde inhoud hielpen het meest, al heb ik nog steeds OCD-gerelateerd hamsteren van mijn oude 'transkleren' en blijf ik soms worstelen met het gevoel een 'nepvrouw' te zijn. In het verleden had ik suïcidale gedachten gerelateerd aan dysforie, maar het is al vele jaren geleden dat mijn lichaam suïcidale gedachten veroorzaakte.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I can remember wanting to be a boy from a very young age — I was distressed about not having a penis at around age 4, and by about age 6 I was already thinking of ways to gradually, subtly socially transition, even though I had no idea trans people existed. At age 8 I thought I had tumors on my chest because the idea that I could grow breast buds was so foreign to me, and I was even more upset when my mom told me it wasn't cancer. I had an eating disorder from age 13 onward. As a teenager I repeatedly got very close to committing suicide because I was so distraught at the idea that I could never be male. Nobody was surprised when I came out; my family was very supportive and the main reaction was "oh... that makes a lot of sense."
I identified as trans and lived as a man, passing consistently and happily for multiple years — I described myself as having been able to be a "transmed poster boy" with how Very Truly Trans I was. I was a very dysphoric, very transmed trans man at the time. I used binders, and detransition was partly about being unable to continue to damage my ribs with them. I never took testosterone, but I passed for years and had lots of people telling me I looked male and could never imagine me as a woman. I used a prosthetic penis and it felt distinctly right to see myself with one.
I came to detransition through a mental health crisis. A bad side effect to an SSRI caused an intense sense of derealization; I came to believe I was not actually a person and became afraid to go out or talk to anyone because doing so would trick people into thinking I was one. Continuing to present as a man was at odds with that (men are people), but I couldn't go back to a female appearance either (women are also people), so I was stuck in limbo for months. Eventually I reverted to a feminine appearance through outside pressure. I had always believed it would be ideal to be at peace with my female body, so detransitioning wasn't a foreign concept to me, but I wish it had happened some other way. My family's support actually made it a little difficult to go back.
What helped me most afterward was an approach of body neutrality and a decision to stop fixating on my dysphoria. I recognized that as an autistic person I have a natural inclination to fixate, and that the trans community told me this fixation was a natural part of self-discovery. I decided to treat the desire to be born male as no more productive than the desire to be 6 feet tall or born in a different country. I had to distance myself from pretty much all transition-related content on social media because it kept the thought that my body was "fixable" (and therefore in need of fixing) present in my head. I did not cut off the trans people I knew and I do not see myself as transphobic.
I've been desisted for around 5 years now — longer than I was ever trans. My dysphoria is now extremely mild; prior to and during identifying as trans it was extreme. It has been many years since my body caused me any suicidal thoughts. I can look down in the shower and speak to people without being sickened by the thought of them knowing I'm female. I'm not super thrilled to be a woman, but that was never the goal — neutrality was, and the all-consuming obsession is gone. I still struggle to let go of the messages I got about how poorly being a girl fit me.
I still can't bring myself to get rid of my old "trans clothes." I wore them because they hid my body and let me pass as a 14-year-old male, not because I liked them. I keep them "in case of emergency" out of fear that dysphoria will suddenly come back. I have OCD and genuine hoarding tendencies, so I try to err on the side of shutting down hoarding when I notice it. I've always hated tight-fitting or low-cut tops. Because I "missed" the transition from girl to woman while clinging to the idea of being a man, I feel like a fake woman/fake adult and tend to see a 12-year-old drowning in their older sibling's clothes when I don't wear anything form-fitted.
On sexuality and gender, I'm skeptical of claims that hormones change sexual desires or make people more submissive, since trans men on T mostly report only an increased sex drive. I've criticized the idea that transition is motivated by sexual reasons as a universal claim. I've also pushed back on the idea that detransition is about returning to female "privileges" — the time I passed as male was the first time people defaulted to assuming I knew what I was talking about, didn't question my competence, and didn't label neutral personality traits as "being a bitch." Being treated like a woman again immediately sucked. I've argued against transmedicalism, saying it had me convinced my severe dysphoria meant a literal physical brain difference guaranteeing misery, and that it doesn't account for neuroplasticity — I trained myself into and then back out of expecting a flat chest. I've advocated that people evaluate the decision to quit T independently of what a current love interest wants, and I've told others that long hair or femininity doesn't define womanhood. I'm not religious. I've been critical of looksmaxing framings of transition and of people who universalize sexual motivations for transitioning.