Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man die zich als trans identificeerde, als vrouw leefde en feminiserende stappen zette, waaronder hormonen die me onvruchtbaar en afhankelijk van medicatie maakten. Het afgelopen jaar of zo heb ik me weer als man geïdentificeerd en het concept genderidentiteit afgewezen, terwijl ik (nog) niet formeel of medisch detransitioneer en me nog vrouwelijk presenteer en vrouwenruimtes gebruik. Ik ben het eens met gendercritische feministen over ruimtes voor één sekse, maar ben bang om weer herentoiletten te gebruiken vanwege het risico op mishandeling. Ik ben over het geheel veel gelukkiger, al erken ik de kosten van onvruchtbaarheid en medicatieafhankelijkheid. Ik ben nog aan het uitzoeken hoe ik mijn leven leid en heb nog niet definitief besloten of ik zal detransitioneren.
Volledig verhaal
I've been slowly re-identifying as male over the past year or so — or, more accurately, accepting and admitting to myself that I am male. I have accepted myself for what I truly am: a male who wants to be seen as female. I can't change that; no matter how much I want to be female, it doesn't make me female. I've dispensed with the concept of gender identity, having only recently, in the last few months or so, come to understand that gender identity is bullshit.
I don't want to formally or medically detransition (I think...), but it raises questions about authenticity and identity that I haven't fully answered for myself. I've taken steps to alleviate dysphoria which has led to me being mistaken for a woman. I wear women's clothing but I don't often wear makeup. I don't insist on any pronouns and never correct people. People mistake me for a woman, but it would be strange and unpleasant to constantly insist that I'm a man. I don't dress particularly stereotypically female compared to women, but I definitely dress feminine compared to men — I'm a feminine man. I've not claimed womanhood at any point; it would be a pointless and dishonest claim. A woman, as we all know, is an adult human female.
I'm not sure what makes it so important that people see me as a woman; I think such an answer would be a psychological revelation. Hard to say what living as a woman means for me.
I've been using women's spaces, including women's toilets, for a long time. This is the hardest question for me. I don't think any subjective concept of identity should determine who has access to spaces. Male people do not have an unalienable right to enter female spaces, I think, unless they have made some commitment to some sort of social or legal fiction such that it might be acceptable. But am I just adding this clause for selfish reasons? I know that if I were to start using the men's toilets again, I would be extremely vulnerable to abuse, physical or otherwise, and I also know that I am no threat at all to women. I understand the case for single-sex spaces, of course — I'm not devoid of empathy. But at the same time I can't bring myself to induce harm on myself in order to make no difference to the world. I'm not claiming to be a good feminist; I'm just relaying my own human fears. Someone suggested I go back to the men's bathroom, and I said maybe they're right, but it's been a long time since I was in one. I said I'd think about it and may change my behaviour as a result of the answers I got. I also said I might go back to using men's toilets but that I am genuinely scared and will have to work up courage.
On my medical situation: I am much happier on the whole, though it's not all rosy — being infertile and dependent on medication are among some of the problems I face. I don't have exact dates for when I started hormones or when I became infertile, but I have been on medication long enough to be dependent on it and to have become infertile as a result.
I've been engaging with gender critical feminists and find that, on this occasion, I agree with them. I resent being told I'm being brainwashed — I have my own brain, morals and principles, and I find it condescending when people suggest I don't. I call myself a TIM and I'm not ashamed of it or insulted by it; even if I were, it would be fairly pointless because I can't change reality no matter how much I would desire it. I've pushed back on people using misogynistic slurs when others are mean to them, asking them not to use that word.
I've also commented on AGP (autogynephilia), saying that the difference between people like Jonathan Yaniv and others in the AGP crowd is behaviour, not ontology — Yaniv is just as trans as anyone else (especially any other AGP), but it's unfair to suggest the rest of the AGP crowd are as bad as Yaniv. They might have the same condition and even the same desires, but in the vast majority of cases they do not behave so terribly, though they do in many cases behave very badly.
I've encouraged someone else to make themselves heard, if only for the people whom they might reach and save from terrible decisions, saying that the trans community is wholly anti-truth, as I used to be, because the truth is sometimes too painful.
I'm still trying to work out how to live my life, having only recently understood that gender identity is bullshit. I'm in a similar boat to others who are questioning, except I'm not a radical feminist.