Alle verhalen

Een jaar als transjongen, geen hormonen, geen operatie

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd91
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich ongeveer een jaar als transjongen identificeerde, hij/hem-voornaamwoorden gebruikte en bond, maar nooit testosteron nam of een operatie had. Een gendertherapeut die beide mogelijkheden onderzocht en een standvastige maar begripvolle moeder hielpen me mijn identiteit in twijfel te trekken, en uiteindelijk besefte ik dat ik niet trans was. Ik desisteerde door trans-discussies af te sluiten en met mijn presentatie te experimenteren, en ontdekte dat ik het gelukkigst en zelfverzekerdst ben als vrouwelijk meisje. Ik voel me soms nog ongemakkelijk als ik mezelf een vrouw noem en heb ruimte nodig van de trans-gemeenschap, maar ik heb veel trans vrienden en beschouw mezelf als een bondgenoot die gelooft dat transitie sommige mensen helpt. Ik ben kritisch over de acceptatiecultuur rond trans zijn en de smalle transitiepijplijn, en ik heb me af en toe boos gevoeld op mensen van wie ik denk dat ze een trans identiteit claimen zonder echte worsteling.

Volledig verhaal

I am a female who desisted from a trans identification without ever medically transitioning. When I thought I was trans, I wanted to be a boy and to be more masculine, driven partly by internalized misogyny and partly by deep discomfort with my body. I spent about a year questioning my gender, during which I cut my hair and used he/him pronouns around certain friends. I hid a binder in my backpack and would rush to put it on in the bathroom stall before class, shopped for men's clothes in secret, avoided letting people hear my voice for fear they would figure out I was female, and had trouble making friends because I did not know what gender I was supposed to be. I was deeply insecure, had no identity, no friends, and no confidence. I framed it as a binary choice: either I was trans, and testosterone and new pronouns would fix everything, or I was cis, and I would have to somehow learn to love myself as I was. Deep down I think I wanted to be trans because it would give all my insecurities one simple, relatively fixable reason. Admitting I was not trans was hard because it meant a lot of difficult emotional work ahead. What got me out of it was a good gender therapist who understood trans issues but also helped me explore the possibility I was not trans, and a mother who was understanding but firm in pushing me to consider alternative explanations. At the time I was furious with her and thought she was being transphobic, but I am glad now she questioned me because I probably would have transitioned medically otherwise. What would have kept me from going down the rabbit hole at all would have been not being insecure and not having access to Tumblr and trans subreddits. I also found truscum ideology attractive because it gave me validation when deep down I knew transition was not right for me, and I used the term 'transtrender' in the same way. After deciding not to transition, I cut myself off from trans discourse online and in person, started listening only to myself, and experimented with both men's and women's fashion and gender presentation. I found I felt most confident and happy presenting as a girl, especially with tomboyish yet feminine fashion. Unlike many female detransitioners, I want to be more feminine and to be perceived as a pretty girl, both for the social advantages and because it makes me feel good about myself. It is relieving to know there is no shame in being a woman and that liking feminine things has nothing to do with my intellect or career capabilities. It also helped with dating: when I thought I was a gay trans guy I knew my options were slim, but now as a mostly straight girl about 75% of the guys I like could like me back. I am bisexual, and I notice that when I am attracted to someone I get an urge to dress and act like them, usually more with guys, but actually trying to be masculine makes me unhappy. Becoming happy as a girl was in some ways harder than transitioning because there was no set path and I had to build confidence on my own. I still feel that if I had been born male I would be happy, but that cuts both ways and now I think I could be content with either body. Cross-dressing still makes me kind of happy and I do not wear super frilly clothes, but I have worked hard to build a feminine version of myself I can be confident in. I still feel uncomfortable calling myself a woman even though I try to identify with that label, and I feel like just a cis woman who is a little too eager to seem woke when trans topics come up. When I meet trans people I want to tell them I understand, but to them I am just another cis woman. I still have many trans friends and consider myself an ally, but I need space from the community to get clarity, because when immersed in it you only pay attention to evidence supporting being trans. I see my experience as finding out I was not really trans, and I believe medical transition does work for some people because trans people do exist. I think there are not 'real' and 'not real' trans people, just people who will and will not benefit from transition, and that the right question is not 'am I really trans?' but 'will social or medical transition benefit me?' I still think I might have been fine as a trans guy, but the drawbacks far outweighed the benefits, and dealing with my internalized misogyny and sometimes presenting masculinely was easier than transitioning for meager benefits. I am critical of trans acceptance culture that convinces anyone questioning at all that they must be trans, and of the narrow egg-to-self-acceptance-to-social-transition-to-HRT-to-surgery pipeline, believing people should be allowed to experiment and be gender non-conforming without following those steps. In April 2021 I posted about being irrationally angered by feminine women using she/they pronouns, feeling they claim a non-binary identity without the struggles I endured, including hiding a binder and losing a large portion of my youth to thinking I should be a man and hating my body. A kind reply helped me realize they are not claiming my experience and I calmed down. I am wary of gender-critical and radical feminist spaces, wishing r/GenderCritical had not been banned only so radfems would be quarantined, and I believe detransition stories should not be twisted to invalidate all trans people.