Alle verhalen

Jaren online, uit de kast — vóór hormonen of operaties

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd122
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die enkele jaren als non-binair/trans identificeerde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, en grotendeels in de kast bleef afgezien van online gemeenschappen en een paar vertrouwde vrienden. Ik ben mijn dysforie gaan zien als geworteld in vrouwenhaat, pesten op basis van geslacht, emotioneel misbruik door mijn vader en broer, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en vrouwenhaat, een zwak zelfbeeld gerelateerd aan BPS en de wens te ontsnappen aan de mannelijke blik. Ik kwam eruit voordat er hormonen of operaties kwamen, en dat dank ik aan het leren accepteren van mijn lichaam en het verwerpen van genderstereotypen. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw, noem mezelf radfem-georiënteerd en betoog dat gender niet zou moeten bestaan, terwijl ik pleit dat dysforie vaak met therapie kan worden aangepakt in plaats van met transitie. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I never physically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — and I was mostly in the closet the entire time I identified as nonbinary and trans, except in online communities and among a very few trusted friends. My questioning went on for several years; I identified under different labels and developed intense social dysphoria, and even some physical dysphoria, the further I delved into trans communities. What I eventually realized was that deep down I was running from womanhood. Several things fed that: frustration with misogyny and sexism, sex-based bullying, and the objectification of women; emotional abuse I dealt with from my father and my older brother; internalized homophobia; internalized misogyny; a weak sense of self that I attribute to BPD; and the misinformed idea that being tomboyish, hairy, flat-chested, having an androgynous voice, and liking "masculine" things meant I couldn't be a woman. I wanted to be a boy or a man for a long time, and I only came to understand later that I hated being perceived as a woman because of how misogynistic my father and older brother were, because of the dumb stereotypes placed on me as a woman, and because I wanted to escape the male gaze and being seen as sexual all the time. I also came to believe that misogyny and sexism, plus the current influx of transgender people, are confusing a lot of women and girls — that we are frustrated with being sexualized, not being taken seriously, or feeling like we're doing the whole being-a-woman thing wrong by not fitting neatly into stereotypes and gender roles, and that we subconsciously feel being a woman is boring or less cool. I think that's bullshit: you can be a woman and like trucks, men's clothes, or women; you can cut your hair, not shave, bind, and do things that look "manly," and none of that takes away from being a woman. I'd rather people be themselves while also being proudly women than create new genders, which only creates more boxes. I've told questioning people that if it's not your mannerisms, dress, interests, or body that makes you a woman, then what is it? It's just being a woman — it's a choice. I think choosing to be a woman while doing whatever else you want is fine, even taking hormones if you want, but that should be entirely because you want to and not because you feel like you should, and it's an often-irreversible decision that shouldn't be taken lightly. I fortunately snapped out of it before I got hold of hormones or any surgeries. What I think would have helped me snap out of it sooner is having someone acknowledge that being a woman or girl is very difficult in our culture, and that it's not uncommon for us females to resent our bodies and how they "out" us as somebody to be treated as though we're inferior — how people look at our bodies and reduce us to sexual ornaments — but that doesn't mean our bodies are dirty or wrong. I needed to hear that body image issues were very likely contributing to my desire to hide away, cover up, and change; that no matter what boys said there was nothing wrong with my body; that I am much more than a piece of meat to be ogled at or picked apart; and that women are not all of the nasty things misogynists say about us. Now I'm learning to be proud of who I am and not let other people's ridiculous ideas about me affect me. I've spent a lot of time in detrans and gender-critical spaces online. I got banned from ask_transgender simply for saying I found it disrespectful and concerning that people were speculating on whether detransitioners' experiences are valid — I called that "the trans cult." I've said it makes me genuinely mad when people tell others their detransition experiences aren't real, calling it immature, apathetic, and "honestly evil," and I've said I can't imagine being someone who went through medical transition and has their story dismissed as a "transphobic myth." I've talked to multiple detransitioners and say with certainty they had actual dysphoria — diagnosed, with symptoms perfectly lining up with dysphoria and not body dysmorphia — which to me proves that transition isn't always the best solution for dealing with dysphoria; it may work for some dysphoric folks, but for others they may require intensive therapy. I've argued that many dysphoric people are detransitioners, more than I expected. I describe myself as radfem-leaning. I've argued that gender shouldn't exist at all, that it isn't a tangible thing, that it was constructed to oppress women, and that people need to hear it's not real because our culture takes it way too literally. I've also pushed back against other radfems, saying that mtf detransitioners deserve a place to discuss their experiences too. On a thread about a young child, I argued that we shouldn't entertain him being trans at that age, saying he likely was bullied for being feminine or exposed to trans ideology, and that even if he did have gender dysphoria, HRT and social transition are not the only options — most people need to learn to be happy with their own bodies and personalities even if they're unconventional — and I pleaded, "please dont give this child puberty blockers or hormones." I've mentioned having a 120 IQ measured on paper by a real psychologist. I've been combative in some exchanges, including a heated back-and-forth where I told someone they were rude and to "go be a miserable fuck somewhere else," and where I said I'd learned my lesson never to ask questions to spark conversation again. I've also been supportive of others, congratulating someone on their journey and telling them they "definitely still look female," and telling someone I was proud of them for accepting themselves as they are. I don't currently identify as trans.