Alle verhalen

Butch, uit de arbeidersklasse, en klaar met doorgaan voor wie dan ook

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd75
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, een gendernonconformistische lesbienne bij wie genderdysforie werd vastgesteld en die later fysiologisch transitioneerde voordat ze detransitioneerde. Ik ben kritisch over medische transitie en omschrijf hormonen en operaties als zelfbeschadiging die blijvende fysiologische schade veroorzaakt, en ik verwerp de druk om na detransitie als cis 'door te gaan'. Ik verwerp zowel het reguliere links als sociaal conservatisme, identificeer me als butch/gnc lesbienne uit de arbeidersklasse, en pleit ervoor dat de geleefde ervaringen van detransitioners worden erkend in plaats van ontkend. Ik heb publiekelijk gevraagd of detransitioners bij het Amerikaanse ministerie van Defensie kunnen komen gezien een eerdere dysforiediagnose. Ik heb in wat ik heb gepost geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of specifieke mate van spijt besproken.

Volledig verhaal

I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria, which I now describe as having been given "for the all-but-literal crime of nonconformity" — I was a gender-nonconforming, butch, rural-identified person (I've described myself as a "detrans butch hick"). I transitioned physiologically at some point and later detransitioned; I don't give specific dates or ages for any of these steps in what I've posted. After detransitioning, I found that people treated me as though I now had to "present" cis and work overtime on "passing" as whatever gender or sex, rather than just existing as myself — the same way I existed while I was physiologically transitioning. I reject that pressure. I don't think transitioning or detransitioning implies conformity, and I've told others that femininity and masculinity are "bullshit" and that people should do what they want, but that they shouldn't cause damage to their body "chasing dragons that don't exist." I'm critical of the medical pathway. I've written that it will cause more physiological problems "(sooner rather than later)" to physiologically transition, let alone undergo surgeries, and I've described endocrine treatment and surgery as "self-harming via endocrine system and surgical bodily trauma." I've encouraged people to familiarize themselves with their own bodies and to value themselves instead. I've also flagged a case involving what I called "a budding ethical and HIPPA nightmare," suggesting I'm alert to medical/privacy misconduct in gender-related care. On politics, I'm wary of both mainstream leftism and social conservatism. I've said it might be worth studying materialism rather than "mainstream leftism" or "commie nonsense," and equally warned that "social" conservatism won't heal anyone unless they're willing to "wear the dress and kneel for the man and bear a quiverfull of his children to then be left once you've aged with no employment history." I'm skeptical that current protections for detransitioners will survive the next Presidency. I identify as a lesbian — "homosexual female and GNC" — and say I was always assumed to be bisexual. I've spoken about being targeted by "predatory freaks" who expect women to be vulnerable because of how society responds to gender nonconformity, and I've advised being rude in response. I've also discussed class and belonging: I described trying to enter a professional field typically reserved for people from upper-middle-class backgrounds, with a glass ceiling built on childhood-absorbed microbehaviors needed to "pass" as them, and being directly asked how "someone like me" was accepted into my professional and academic experiences, even after months of grooming and emulation. I've defended detransitioners against having their experiences denied, arguing that many trans people are outright hostile to detransitioners and telling others to "Stop denying people their lived experiences" and "Be better." I've also supported a couple going through detransition-related social fallout, telling them they are the same people with the same personalities and histories and that they deserve better. I've posted asking whether detransitioners with a prior gender dysphoria diagnosis can join the U.S. Department of Defense, and whether this differs between officer and non-officer roles. My tentative conclusion was that a detransitioner with no mental comorbidities and no lasting, disabling chronic conditions — i.e., someone not on cross-sex hormones for an extensive period, and either not surgically altered or without crippling side effects — could theoretically join, though I doubted this would hold under the next Presidency. I don't discuss my current mental health, relationships, family support, regret levels, or quality of life in what I've written here.