Alle verhalen

Vier jaar in therapie, en niemand vroeg naar het trauma

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd625
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een desister, geen detransitioner: ik stopte voordat ik met hormonen of een medische transitie begon, maar ik verloor vier jaar aan therapie die de C-PTSS die mijn identiteitsverwarring echt veroorzaakte niet aanpakte. Ik geloof dat trauma, en niet aangeboren trans zijn, achter mijn dysforie zat, en ik ben kritisch over een overbevestigend medisch systeem en transactivisten die volgens mij kwetsbare mensen in transitie duwen. Ik heb een gendercritische maar niet anti-trans visie en stel dat twijfelen en het onderzoeken van mogelijke niet-trans verklaringen de beste manier is om transmensen echt te helpen. Ik heb spijt van de verloren jaren en de verwarring, maar heb onomkeerbare veranderingen vermeden. Ik blijf actief in de detrans-gemeenschap en bied anderen steun.

Volledig verhaal

I came to the detrans community as a desister rather than a detransitioner — I stopped before ever going down the transition path, but I still feel I lost years to the process of figuring myself out. I dealt with C-PTSD, which I believe was the actual root of the identity confusion and dysphoria I experienced. In my own words, I "lost 4 years to useless therapy for the trauma that had been causing me to falsely suspect I was trans." I have a new therapist now, and I rant to them almost every session about how much the earlier therapy wasted my time. I also had a period where therapy itself seemed to hold me back more than it helped — constant therapy sessions while my physical health declined. What shaped my thinking was the conviction that dysphoria often stems from trauma rather than from being genuinely trans, and that treating the trauma first should be the priority. I've argued that "Trauma or trans" should be one of the first things gender doctors investigate, and that checking off easier alternatives — trauma, autism, depression — should come before a trans diagnosis. I also believe testosterone functions as a mild antidepressant, which can trick people into thinking they're FTM when they're really just depressed, and that stopping hormones can initially make mental state worse until natural levels stabilize. I'm critical of what I see as an over-affirming medical system and overzealous trans activists, which I think are responsible for a flood of detransition cases. I've pointed to examples like how easy it is to legally change gender in Canada with minimal doctor consultation, and I've said things like "Existing as detrans makes you a walking hate crime these days." I've expressed hope for a reckoning in the next decade with detransitioners and lawsuits against doctors. I also believe political correctness around trans issues keeps important safety information from people, preventing truly informed consent. I've tried to be supportive of others in the community — offering to talk via DM, encouraging people to consider stopping hormones before surgery, and suggesting they open conversations about detransition with partners. I hold a gender-critical but not anti-trans view: I've said you can be gender critical and trans, and that believing biological sex is imaginary actually undermines the existence of trans people. I've also suggested that many lesbians are misdiagnosed as trans because societal ideas of "being a woman" are tied to attraction to men. I don't regret a specific medical intervention since I avoided transition, but I do regret the four years lost to ineffective therapy and the confusion itself. I'm generally supportive of detransition and critical of easy access to transition, while acknowledging that transition can be the right answer for some people — it just shouldn't be the first answer.