Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die mijn tijd op r/detrans besteed aan medeleven met anderen die door transitiegeneeskunde zijn geschaad, chirurgen 'slagers' noemen en mensen aanmoedigen die nog stem en uiterlijk navigeren. Ik spreek vanuit kennelijke bekendheid met stemtraining en met op foto's als man gelezen worden, maar ik heb de specifieke data, leeftijden of medische details van mijn eigen transitie en detransitie niet in deze reacties gedeeld. Ik geloof dat deze verhalen vaker voorkomen en dat een afschrikeffect mensen belet openlijk te spreken, en ik bewonder wie het wel doet. Ik heb in het aangeleverde materiaal geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of specifieke spijt beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have only ever posted short comments on r/detrans, so my own story is not told in detail here — what comes through is my voice, my sympathies, and a few glimpses of my own transition-related experience.
In January 2024 I was reading other people's accounts and responding with grief and anger. On Jan 8 I wrote "That's crazy man…...." and two days later, "Heartbreaking af. I am so fuckin sorry." On Jan 16 I commented at length: "It's so sad. I am so sorry. And these stories are only becoming more and more popular. Fucking sad. You said it best; these 'doctors' are butchers." That comment got 58 upvotes, which tells me my view — that surgeons performing these procedures are acting like butchers — is shared widely in this community. On Jan 23 I wrote "You took the words from my brain," and on Feb 2, "Perfectly said." I clearly feel strongly that transition medicine is harming people and that the harm is becoming more common.
The most revealing comments for my own life are about voice and appearance. On Jan 31, 2024, responding to someone posting voice clips, I wrote: "I think your regular voice sounds better than the others, because no cracking and stuff. The others sound very forced and child like. You sound like a woman with a deeper voice, not a man." I know what voice training sounds like when it's forced — the cracking, the artificial quality — which suggests I have direct experience with it, either my own or very close observation. On Feb 4 I told someone "Girl you are STUNNING," and on Feb 5 I wrote "You read male in both photos, but i have never met you in person or heard your voice and stuff. Keep pushing!" That comment scored 85 — the highest of any of mine — and it shows I understand what it means to be read as male in photos while knowing that photos aren't the whole picture. I was encouraging someone who was still presenting or passing in a masculine direction, telling them to keep going, which suggests I have been through the process of trying to be read a certain way myself.
On Feb 15, 2024 I offered comfort to someone struggling: "So shitty and I am so sorry. But just TRY to keep in mind that the internet is only the internet, not real life. Best wishes love." I use terms of endearment like "love" and "girl" with other women here, which fits a female identity and a warm, sisterly register.
By July 5, 2024 I was celebrating someone speaking out. I wrote "Mic drop 🎤" and then, "Oh my gosh. You are SO BRAVE for speaking your truth in this day & age. People don't wanna outright say it for fear of backlash, but I am so proud of you." I clearly believe there is a chilling effect around criticizing transition medicine, and I admire people who defy it.
I have not described my own ages, dates of transition or detransition, medical interventions, mental health, trauma, sexuality, or regret in these comments, so I leave those areas blank rather than guess. What I can say is that I am a detransitioned or desisted woman who is angry at the medical system, compassionate toward others who were hurt, familiar with the mechanics of voice training and passing, and willing to encourage people still in the middle of their own journeys.